|
Post by MichyM on Aug 9, 2019 1:15:55 GMT
I'm super tired (forgive any typos) but I did a search and didn't see a thread about the Mississippi raids. If there's one and I missed it, please let me know.
First off, the raids in Mississippi make me so angry, and what our government is doing to hard working families trying to improve the circumstances of their lives is inconceivable to me. And it's un-freaking-believeable what the government, AGAIN, is doing to innocent children.
That said, are the owners, managers, HR specialists, higer-ups at these plants being arrested as well? And leaving their children to fend for themselves <sarcasm>? But serious question.... if not, why not?
|
|
|
Post by Merge on Aug 9, 2019 1:38:54 GMT
|
|
|
Post by papercrafteradvocate on Aug 9, 2019 1:41:09 GMT
I was reading about it, looking to see if the owners/managers would also be arrested, because the reports from ICE were stating that they had insider help, and that someone within at least one of the companies was taking $500-$800 per person for them to get jobs (as a fee I assume?)
Other articles have stated that the likelihood of the owners/managers being charged are nil. Apparently it hasn’t happened in a long long time.
Here’s what’s going to happen as a result of these ICE raids:
1. Employers now have 680 less workers, doing jobs that most don’t want (so it’s bullshit that immigrants are taking away jobs), these employers are going to either have to pay those that are left overtime, struggle getting product out, or close, leading to...
2. Poultry and egg prices are going to go up. The “affordable” meat is not going to be affordable anymore, eggs are going to be $$$ higher.
3. All these children left behind. Neighbors, churches, other aid trying to help them, food, clothing, emotionally, educationally. ICE never NEVER had any plan on what to do with the children of these 680 people. This administration is the party of lying bullshit that they care about lives—once they are born, they don’t give a fuck—leave them stranded in the streets, let them get murdered by gunfire. Republicans suck. MAGA people aren’t taking care of them.
4. Landlords. They can kiss their rent goodbye. For this many to be removed from society (their little towns) is going to cause the landlords (and banks if they had loans on homes, cars, etc.) to take a hit. All of a sudden, there will be lots of empty houses/apartments in already depressed areas. Who will fill all those empty homes now?
5. The burden that these raids put on others in the community, depleting resources (food banks, churches, etc) to care for those children who were left behind.
6. The USA is looking pretty crappy in terms of inhumane treatment of human life, ICE raids, mass killings where those who can do something about it refuse to, a potus that’s a fucking idiot, the ugly nasty rhetoric being spewed by the administration. They are letting the world know that if you are brown, Black, POC, different ethnicities you are not welcome. Proof is that they are targeting these people. You NEVER see immigrants who are white getting deported with no rights.
The USA under trump is getting worse. Every damn day.
Sick to death of the conservative “Christians” rhetoric and pretense with this administration. YOU ARE NOT CHRISTIAN IF YOU SUPPORT THIS ADMINISTRATION. There is NOTHING that this administration is doing that is remotely Christian like. NOTHING. Jesus didn’t put children in cages. Jesus didn’t separate children from parents. Jesus didn’t glorify wealth and only support the wealthy. Jesus did not divide or hate or bully people.
I fucking hate the division that this administration is driving. He’s full of shit reading the TelePrompTer saying we have to unite, then out of the other side of his big pie hole, he lies, gaslights, and bullies people.
|
|
|
Post by SockMonkey on Aug 9, 2019 1:42:49 GMT
I saw pictures and a video of the kids. I don’t even know what to say.
It’s just so sad and disgusting.
|
|
|
Post by SockMonkey on Aug 9, 2019 1:47:11 GMT
I found this:
Seriously, fuck this President.
|
|
|
Post by jubejubes on Aug 9, 2019 1:56:42 GMT
I simply can't imagine this happening in Canada. At least, not on such a large scale that I have heard or read about. Maybe I am living under a rock.
Canada isn't a perfect country and there are immigration issues. There are a few cases where there are children involved, but those are in front of the courts and everyone has legal representation.
I am so sorry about what is happening to my southern neighbour.
|
|
|
Post by ajsweetpea on Aug 9, 2019 2:01:22 GMT
I read this story earlier today:
(CNN)An Iraqi national who had lived in the US since he was an infant died shortly after being deported to Iraq as part of the Trump administration's crackdown on illegal immigration.
Jimmy Aldaoud, 41, died from complications of diabetes, his attorney Edward Bajoka told CNN. Aldaoud, who had a long criminal record, was deported in early June to Iraq, where he had no family or contacts and did not speak the language. His body was found Tuesday at an apartment he shared with another Iraqi American deportee.
"He was not able to get insulin in Iraq. That was essentially the cause of his death," Bajoka said. "This death was completely preventable. It did not have to happen. The death has been devastating to Jimmy's family and to the community."
Immigration and Customs Enforcement officials in Detroit tell CNN that when Aldaoud was deported on June 2, "he was supplied with a full complement of medicine to ensure continuity of care."
Aldaoud, part of the Chaldean Catholic community in Michigan, had never been to Iraq, his attorney said, despite holding Iraqi citizenship through his father. He was born in a refugee camp in Greece. His family came to the US lawfully as refugees in 1979 when he was 6 months old, ICE confirmed to CNN. His now-deceased parents and three other siblings all became US citizens, Bajoka said, but he never did.
Bajoka shared a video of Aldaoud taken in Iraq two and a half weeks after he was deported, where he discusses being apprehended by ICE agents in May before being coerced onto a commercial flight days later.
"I begged them. I said, 'Please, I've never seen that country. I've never been there,' " Aldaoud says in the video. "They forced me. I'm here now, and I don't understand the language. I've been sleeping in the streets. I'm diabetic. I take insulin shots. I've been throwing up, throwing up, sleeping in the streets. I've got nothing to eat."
Aldaoud had an extensive criminal history "that involved no less than 20 convictions between 1998-2017," a Detroit ICE official told CNN, including assault with a dangerous weapon, domestic violence, contempt of court, failure to appear, breaking and entering, malicious destruction of a building, home invasion and possession of marijuana. His criminal history ultimately led to him being incarcerated and transferred to ICE custody in the early 2000s, Bajoka said.
"He had severe mental health issues. He was bipolar, schizophrenic, suffered from severe depression and anxiety," Bajoka said. "That's ultimately what led to his trouble with the law, and ultimately what led to his deportation."
Aldaoud's family, along with Democratic Rep. Andy Levin, of Aldaoud's home state of Michigan, is hoping to be able to bring his body back to the US to receive a Catholic burial and be laid to rest next to his parents.
"This should say to the Trump administration, if they continue to deport vulnerable people to Iraq that they will -- people will continue to meet the worst kind of fate that they can imagine," Levin said. "What I ask is what policy interest of the United States does this serve? I do not understand."
Levin is sponsoring a bill along with Republican Rep. John Moolenaar of Michigan that aims to halt deportations of Iraqi nationals in order to give them time to appeal their immigration cases.
"I've had intense discussions with the administration about this. They've been friendly and not hostile at all. But it just doesn't seem like they're likely to change course," Levin told CNN. "My message to Iraqi diplomats right now is that they need to not take anyone in if they can't provide a true safety for them."
Bajoka said Aldaoud had been released from ICE custody in the early 2000s and been redetained in June 2017, as part of a massive immigration sweep that targeted Iraqi nationals with deportation orders. Aldaoud had had deportation orders since 2005, ICE confirmed to CNN.
He was part of a class action suit brought by the American Civil Liberties Union of Michigan aimed at releasing detainees who were being held indefinitely, partly because of Iraq's unwillingness to receive them, according to court filings.
After spending 18 months at an ICE detention facility in Ohio, Aldaoud was released in December 2018 because of a court order in that case, along with other detainees, but he "immediately absconded from ICE's noncustodial supervision program by cutting his GPS tether on the day of his release," according to a Detroit ICE official.
As his immigration case continued to hit roadblocks, Bajoka said, Aldaoud had given up on continuing to appeal it when he was detained in May. ICE officials say he was arrested by local law enforcement for stealing from a vehicle in April.
"They (ICE) redetained him and basically told him, 'Look you don't have a choice. We don't care if you don't want to go,' " Bajoka said. "They were physically intimidating to him, and they basically forced him onto this plane."
Levin said deporting Aldaoud to Iraq was essentially sending him to "his death."
"It was a death sentence to send him to Iraq," Levin said. "He has no family there. The Chaldean community is largely destroyed there. He doesn't speak Arabic. He's totally Americanized. He's got mental health problems, so he's not able to deal. He's diabetic. He had no reason to have access to medicine there."
|
|
lizacreates
Pearl Clutcher
Posts: 3,856
Aug 29, 2015 2:39:19 GMT
|
Post by lizacreates on Aug 9, 2019 2:54:08 GMT
Their kids were left stranded. The community is pulling together trying to figure out which children may need foster care. Approximately 280 of the near 700 arrested have been released with notices to appear in court so at least some of them can make arrangements for their kids should they be deported. Teachers have said that approx 150 children did not show up for school. Latinos are not opening their doors to anyone and teachers are trying to reach out to parents to send their kids back to school. It’s horrific. And just a couple days after the massacre in El Paso fueled by hatred against Latinos.
|
|
DEX
Pearl Clutcher
Posts: 3,354
Aug 9, 2014 23:13:22 GMT
|
Post by DEX on Aug 9, 2019 3:00:44 GMT
I think the reason there hasn’t been much chatter here is because we might be becoming “war weary”. Seriously, My heart just can’t handle much more news about bad things happening to people. Shootings, a stabbing, raids, child abuse. It is seriously weighing heavy on my heart. I have had a tough time even watching fictional stories like on Orange is the New Black because so many storylines now are stories about characters who have no control over their lives. I feel so lucky that I am able to determine my own destiny right now. It just makes me sad.
|
|
|
Post by femalebusiness on Aug 9, 2019 3:02:07 GMT
Those children broke my heart. I hope that fucker trump and every one of those ICE agents burn in hell for what they did.
|
|
|
Post by bc2ca on Aug 9, 2019 3:02:54 GMT
There is no way management doesn't know and/or isn't actively recruiting workers from this community. They are completely disposable assets for the business to use and abuse and it makes me very angry. Why isn't ICE raiding Devin Nunes's family dairy farm in Iowa? Esquire had a great article on them last year.
|
|
|
Post by revirdsuba99 on Aug 9, 2019 3:07:15 GMT
That said, are the owners, managers, HR specialists, higer-ups at these plants being arrested as well? Teh government will NOT even name the facilities ... We know there will be nothing done to them!!Many more immigrants waiting to fill the positions. I am almost sure that Americans wouldn't do those jobs even if they were paid $15.00 an hour. ** It was the first day of school. The kids had no idea what had happened. They felt abandoned, sure good for their mental health... thanks Stephen Miller and dt, your punishment awaits you both!! ICE claims about half have been released with ankle bracelets. I am sure it was Stephen Miller's idea to take the parents after they dropped the kids off at school, much better to also punish the little kids, babies and toddlers left at daycare... Stephen Miller is truly a very warped person!
How amazing is it that it took 600 ICE agents to arrest 680 people..
And yes food prices will go up and up for all the other things that dt has messed with, with the tariffs etc... gas, fuel..... and the list goes on....
|
|
|
Post by MichyM on Aug 9, 2019 3:45:11 GMT
If this kind of thing is happening ... Ok, who am kidding, of course it happens ... I feel more sick.
|
|
|
Post by MichyM on Aug 9, 2019 3:51:33 GMT
I found this: Seriously, fuck this President. I don't Twitter (I know, I know). Who is this woman? Aka: why should I take her advice? Thanks.
|
|
|
Post by mom on Aug 9, 2019 4:20:26 GMT
I'm super tired (forgive any typos) but I did a search and didn't see a thread about the Mississippi raids. If there's one and I missed it, please let me know. First off, the raids in Mississippi make me so angry, and what our government is doing to hard working families trying to improve the circumstances of their lives is inconceivable to me. And it's un-freaking-believeable what the government, AGAIN, is doing to innocent children. That said, are the owners, managers, HR specialists, higer-ups at these plants being arrested as well? And leaving their children to fend for themselves <sarcasm>? But serious question.... if not, why not? In 2006 a local to me processing plant was raided and they arrested about 1300 employess. The owners, managers and higher ups were not charged. However, the HR manager plead guilty on a charge that he had counseled an illegal immigrant on how to be hired. There were fines as well (but not fines so high they were devastating to the company). At the time (and probably still) this was the largest immigration raid & honestly, the repercussions to the company weren't as devastating as one would think they would be. The workers were the ones who felt it most. My husband used to work in corporate for a different (very similar) company that processes meat. He said that there is a pretty tight wall between those who are higher up & HR. They keep an iron curtain between them so they have deniability. So I think its possible that the owners/managers did not know what was going on...but its only because they didn't want to know.
|
|
Deleted
Posts: 0
Apr 24, 2024 23:07:48 GMT
|
Post by Deleted on Aug 9, 2019 4:37:12 GMT
Kamala Harris...
”These ICE raids are designed to tear families apart, spread fear, and terrorize communities. These children went to daycare and are now returning home without their parents because Trump wants to play politics with their lives.”
|
|
|
Post by myshelly on Aug 9, 2019 5:07:21 GMT
I found this: Seriously, fuck this President. I don't Twitter (I know, I know). Who is this woman? Aka: why should I take her advice? Thanks. RAICES is the Refugee and Immigrant Center for Education and Legal Services. If they’re retweeting her, she’s legit. I would assume she’s one of their lawyers or activists. www.raicestexas.org/
|
|
|
Post by nlwilkins on Aug 9, 2019 5:37:25 GMT
My heart goes out to those children. They are the ones bearing the brunt of the "punishment". How in the world are they going to be able to process an addition 698 people when the courts are already overwhelmed? This was a PR stunt pure and simple.
That being said, I have to wonder about the people arrested. Some of them have been here decades. Why in the world have they not taken steps to become legal? I am sure it is not easy and there must be a lot of fear, justified fear, but to live in limbo would be unbearable for me. There were amnesty programs at one time. Are there no other ways for them to get papers?
Also, Trump has been warning us for some time now that he was going to do this. Why did not the parents put some kind of back up plan in place? Kind of "if I am arrested will you please take care of my children?" or "if I am arrested go to this adult's house and she will take care of you."
While ICE was totally brutal, they were within the law doing what they did. But that does not make it right. Surely there has to be a way around this. Both Dems and Reps have refused to address the issue. There is no good answers. Any solution would anger enough people to cause Congress members to lose their seats. So the issue has grown out of control.
|
|
|
Post by katlady on Aug 9, 2019 6:17:20 GMT
My heart goes out to those children. They are the ones bearing the brunt of the "punishment". How in the world are they going to be able to process an addition 698 people when the courts are already overwhelmed? This was a PR stunt pure and simple. That being said, I have to wonder about the people arrested. Some of them have been here decades. Why in the world have they not taken steps to become legal? I am sure it is not easy and there must be a lot of fear, justified fear, but to live in limbo would be unbearable for me. There were amnesty programs at one time. Are there no other ways for them to get papers? Also, Trump has been warning us for some time now that he was going to do this. Why did not the parents put some kind of back up plan in place? Kind of "if I am arrested will you please take care of my children?" or "if I am arrested go to this adult's house and she will take care of you." While ICE was totally brutal, they were within the law doing what they did. But that does not make it right. Surely there has to be a way around this. Both Dems and Reps have refused to address the issue. There is no good answers. Any solution would anger enough people to cause Congress members to lose their seats. So the issue has grown out of control. Once you are here illegally, it is almost impossible to get legal status. The last amnesty program I believe was back in the 80’s, almost 40 years ago.
|
|
|
Post by SockMonkey on Aug 9, 2019 11:19:03 GMT
I don't Twitter (I know, I know). Who is this woman? Aka: why should I take her advice? Thanks. RAICES is the Refugee and Immigrant Center for Education and Legal Services. If they’re retweeting her, she’s legit. I would assume she’s one of their lawyers or activists. www.raicestexas.org/She says she's just a concerned citizen in the thread, so she's being clear that she just did her own research. I agree that if RAICES retweets her, there are probably legitimate resources there. We should all feel free to do continued research on the sites she posted. I posted it to try and help.
|
|
|
Post by SockMonkey on Aug 9, 2019 11:19:47 GMT
My heart goes out to those children. They are the ones bearing the brunt of the "punishment". How in the world are they going to be able to process an addition 698 people when the courts are already overwhelmed? This was a PR stunt pure and simple. That being said, I have to wonder about the people arrested. Some of them have been here decades. Why in the world have they not taken steps to become legal? I am sure it is not easy and there must be a lot of fear, justified fear, but to live in limbo would be unbearable for me. There were amnesty programs at one time. Are there no other ways for them to get papers? Also, Trump has been warning us for some time now that he was going to do this. Why did not the parents put some kind of back up plan in place? Kind of "if I am arrested will you please take care of my children?" or "if I am arrested go to this adult's house and she will take care of you." While ICE was totally brutal, they were within the law doing what they did. But that does not make it right. Surely there has to be a way around this. Both Dems and Reps have refused to address the issue. There is no good answers. Any solution would anger enough people to cause Congress members to lose their seats. So the issue has grown out of control. All of your questions come from a place of privilege.
|
|
pyccku
Pearl Clutcher
Posts: 2,817
Jun 27, 2014 23:12:07 GMT
|
Post by pyccku on Aug 9, 2019 12:21:05 GMT
That being said, I have to wonder about the people arrested. Some of them have been here decades. Why in the world have they not taken steps to become legal? I am sure it is not easy and there must be a lot of fear, justified fear, but to live in limbo would be unbearable for me. There were amnesty programs at one time. Are there no other ways for them to get papers? No. It is very difficult to get papers if you are here already. It is very difficult to get papers if you aren't here already. If you are educated or rich, you might be able to get papers - but if you are the type of person who would get a job working in a chicken processing plant, you likely aren't going to be able to get papers. We need these workers. But we don't want to treat them as actual people. One of my former students posted about his uncle trying to get permission to move to the US and join the rest of the family. He had been on a waiting list for the past 20 years. He recently died, so he won't be coming to the US any time soon. Turning a blind eye when they show fake/stolen documents is one law that is OK to break, but when it comes time to raid the place, it's never the employer that gets taken away in handcuffs while his kids cry in a gym somewhere. In many cases, even starting the process to become documented means having to leave the country for 10+ years. If you've been here 15 years, you may have a family and a life - in order to change your status, you'd likely have to leave the US for a long time, then apply for admission and hope that you get it - but you probably won't, because you're a criminal. So you have the choice of staying here without papers and hoping you don't get caught, or leaving your family behind, or taking your family with you - back to a situation that was bad enough that you wanted to leave in the first place. There used to be programs to sponsor people to come in and put them on a path to citizenship. Those aren't around anymore. And with Stephen Miller running things, you can bet that they won't be coming back any time soon.
|
|
|
Post by busy on Aug 9, 2019 12:30:57 GMT
I found this: Seriously, fuck this President. I don't Twitter (I know, I know). Who is this woman? Aka: why should I take her advice? Thanks. Here’s her bio www.alidagarcia.com/biography
|
|
lizacreates
Pearl Clutcher
Posts: 3,856
Aug 29, 2015 2:39:19 GMT
|
Post by lizacreates on Aug 9, 2019 12:38:03 GMT
My heart goes out to those children. They are the ones bearing the brunt of the "punishment". How in the world are they going to be able to process an addition 698 people when the courts are already overwhelmed? This was a PR stunt pure and simple. That being said, I have to wonder about the people arrested. Some of them have been here decades. Why in the world have they not taken steps to become legal? I am sure it is not easy and there must be a lot of fear, justified fear, but to live in limbo would be unbearable for me. There were amnesty programs at one time. Are there no other ways for them to get papers? Also, Trump has been warning us for some time now that he was going to do this. Why did not the parents put some kind of back up plan in place? Kind of "if I am arrested will you please take care of my children?" or "if I am arrested go to this adult's house and she will take care of you." While ICE was totally brutal, they were within the law doing what they did. But that does not make it right. Surely there has to be a way around this. Both Dems and Reps have refused to address the issue. There is no good answers. Any solution would anger enough people to cause Congress members to lose their seats. So the issue has grown out of control. In the name of all that’s holy, just give them work visas. They’re working, trying to earn an honest living. We’ve always issued work visas. Why not just increase the quota for this and expand the opportunity? I’m well aware it’s the law, but for god’s sake, change the law. Why criminalize the presence of people who have jobs? Why deny them the chance to work at jobs Americans don’t want? We actually have a labor shortage that's negatively affecting industries that depend on them. It just doesn’t make any practical or moral sense to treat them as criminals.
|
|
|
Post by dewryce on Aug 9, 2019 12:45:12 GMT
In the name of all that’s holy, just give them work visas. They’re working, trying to earn an honest living. We’ve always issued work visas. Why not just increase the quota for this and expand the opportunity? I’m well aware it’s the law, but for god’s sake, change the law. Why criminalize the presence of people who have jobs? Why deny them the chance to work at jobs Americans don’t want? We actually have a labor shortage for these kinds of jobs. It just doesn’t make any practical or moral sense to treat them as criminals. Especially since the people and companies that employ them are not treated as criminals.
|
|
lizacreates
Pearl Clutcher
Posts: 3,856
Aug 29, 2015 2:39:19 GMT
|
Post by lizacreates on Aug 9, 2019 14:12:35 GMT
In the name of all that’s holy, just give them work visas. They’re working, trying to earn an honest living. We’ve always issued work visas. Why not just increase the quota for this and expand the opportunity? I’m well aware it’s the law, but for god’s sake, change the law. Why criminalize the presence of people who have jobs? Why deny them the chance to work at jobs Americans don’t want? We actually have a labor shortage for these kinds of jobs. It just doesn’t make any practical or moral sense to treat them as criminals. Especially since the people and companies that employ them are not treated as criminals. I actually do not blame employers. When you have a labor shortage and Americans don’t want these jobs, you need bodies to keep your enterprise viable, and the undocumented are the ones who are willing and able to do them. I knew a tree maintenance company owner who informed me of this reality back in the early ‘90s. He told me that when his company was raided, he had to replace almost three-quarters of his workforce. Many were hired but guess who stayed past one week? The undocumented immigrants. He said every American – whites and blacks – he hired lasted only a week or less because of how hard the job was, and the undocumented ones stay on for years. And he told me this was not an outlier case, that this was very common in his industry. In other words, it’s an economic imperative. I just checked what the quota is for H2B visas (low-skilled, temporary, non-agricultural) and it’s capped at 66,000/year. How do we sustain industries when the shortage of low-skilled labor currently stands at more than a million? I don’t know why we can’t get this down to a science by now – our immigration policies and quotas are almost completely divorced from economic realities. We have a Congress that can change laws but it’s like we’re paralyzed or something and can’t get it done.
|
|
|
Post by Merge on Aug 9, 2019 14:48:46 GMT
Especially since the people and companies that employ them are not treated as criminals. I actually do not blame employers. When you have a labor shortage and Americans don’t want these jobs, you need bodies to keep your enterprise viable, and the undocumented are the ones who are willing and able to do them. I knew a tree maintenance company owner who informed me of this reality back in the early ‘90s. He told me that when his company was raided, he had to replace almost three-quarters of his workforce. Many were hired but guess who stayed past one week? The undocumented immigrants. He said every American – whites and blacks – he hired lasted only a week or less because of how hard the job was, and the undocumented ones stay on for years. And he told me this was not an outlier case, that this was very common in his industry. In other words, it’s an economic imperative. I just checked what the quota is for H2B visas (low-skilled, temporary, non-agricultural) and it’s capped at 66,000/year. How do we sustain industries when the shortage of low-skilled labor currently stands at more than a million? I don’t know why we can’t get this down to a science by now – our immigration policies and quotas are almost completely divorced from economic realities. We have a Congress that can change laws but it’s like we’re paralyzed or something and can’t get it done. I see it both ways. On one hand, I think if large billionaire employers were held accountable, they'd push their elected representatives to change the laws. The big companies see the undocumented immigrant workers as disposable - one batch goes, and another batch comes in to take their place. Maybe they lose a little money in the short term, but long term they're better off financially for having these workers. Fearful workers don't make waves and don't "whine" about their rights. Smaller companies, like restaurants, landscapers and others who also rely heavily on undocumented labor also take a hit - sometimes a fatal one. There are two restaurants in the little town in Maine where we vacation that had to close down last summer because they could not find the labor they needed. In the past, they had relied heavily on undocumented immigrants, but many were fearful and didn't want to travel to a place for seasonal work where they would stick out like sore thumbs in the largely white community. They couldn't find locals to take the jobs, so they had to shut down and lost a whole year's income. Those are the people I feel for and I don't personally hold them accountable.
|
|
|
Post by dewryce on Aug 9, 2019 15:29:07 GMT
They’re both breaking the law, so I find it unfair that only one is being punished. I agree completely that the workers are needed, and there should be a viable legal pathway for them to live here. It ticks me off to no end that it’s the people with terrible options just trying to make ends meet that are being held responsible, not the employers that are often taking advantage of them.
|
|
|
Post by bc2ca on Aug 9, 2019 15:40:54 GMT
My heart goes out to those children. They are the ones bearing the brunt of the "punishment". How in the world are they going to be able to process an addition 698 people when the courts are already overwhelmed? This was a PR stunt pure and simple. That being said, I have to wonder about the people arrested. Some of them have been here decades. Why in the world have they not taken steps to become legal? I am sure it is not easy and there must be a lot of fear, justified fear, but to live in limbo would be unbearable for me. There were amnesty programs at one time. Are there no other ways for them to get papers? Also, Trump has been warning us for some time now that he was going to do this. Why did not the parents put some kind of back up plan in place? Kind of "if I am arrested will you please take care of my children?" or "if I am arrested go to this adult's house and she will take care of you." While ICE was totally brutal, they were within the law doing what they did. But that does not make it right. Surely there has to be a way around this. Both Dems and Reps have refused to address the issue. There is no good answers. Any solution would anger enough people to cause Congress members to lose their seats. So the issue has grown out of control. One of the very real problems is there is no legal route for these workers. We need them in our economy and don't provide any legal route for them.
|
|
|
Post by bc2ca on Aug 9, 2019 15:45:11 GMT
Especially since the people and companies that employ them are not treated as criminals. I actually do not blame employers. When you have a labor shortage and Americans don’t want these jobs, you need bodies to keep your enterprise viable, and the undocumented are the ones who are willing and able to do them. I knew a tree maintenance company owner who informed me of this reality back in the early ‘90s. He told me that when his company was raided, he had to replace almost three-quarters of his workforce. Many were hired but guess who stayed past one week? The undocumented immigrants. He said every American – whites and blacks – he hired lasted only a week or less because of how hard the job was, and the undocumented ones stay on for years. And he told me this was not an outlier case, that this was very common in his industry. In other words, it’s an economic imperative. I just checked what the quota is for H2B visas (low-skilled, temporary, non-agricultural) and it’s capped at 66,000/year. How do we sustain industries when the shortage of low-skilled labor currently stands at more than a million? I don’t know why we can’t get this down to a science by now – our immigration policies and quotas are almost completely divorced from economic realities. We have a Congress that can change laws but it’s like we’re paralyzed or something and can’t get it done. I agree with you for the most part, but DO blame the employers for not demanding immigration reform and electing officials that will get it done. The article I linked up thread talks about dairy farms in Iowa where employers have a pact to help each other out if one is raided (because they can't exist without undocumented labor) and they keep electing rabid anti-immigrant politicians like Steven King.
|
|