|
Post by papercrafteradvocate on May 27, 2020 17:20:19 GMT
No no no. You misunderstand me. I felt exactly the same way. I felt shamed by her too. That I wasn't doing enough. I had virtually the same exact reaction. And I posted because I wanted you to see the events that followed and the process by which I sorted my feelings out. Because you are someone I deeply respect as well. I thought that you might like hearing what process I went through and where my views are at this point. And no, we aren't doing enough. None of us are. That's just a fact. And I don't want you to feel shamed. I just want us to really try as best we can to step inside the life of a person of color. I want us all to be outraged and trying to make our personal interactions better. Shaming solves nothing. But shining a light in places where we are dark is the goal. So please accept my post not as a handslap. But as a I see you, I feel you, I've been there. But it's legit part of our privilege. When I said “I’m sorry you feel that way” I really did mean it. I don’t take ownership of other people’s feelings but what I will say is I’ve clearly stated my feelings were hurt by the things peas have said to me and no one gave a damn. Olan I’m introspective enough to know my delivery sucks and it’s often confusing to follow my train of thought. But I won’t own having said A SINGLE THING** hurtful enough for Elaine or any pea to wish harm upon me at the hands of police. To say that to another woman knowing what we all know about the history of police and Black people.That’s really shitty. It’s unconscionable. So I’m confused why the peas think I’d somehow come here to find camaraderie and friendship. Outside of a handful of peas most are incredibly rude to me. Don’t misconstrue this as me wanting that to change. I’m okay with my role here at 2peas and like the friend circle I’ve cultivated for myself. ****With as many rabid supporters as Elaine has trust me they are all trying to find that one comment and can’t. What they are finding is Elaine consistently interacting with me despite all of her claims. OlanYou are lying again.
|
|
|
Post by papercrafteradvocate on May 27, 2020 17:39:54 GMT
I would also like to point out I WAS here for the camaraderie and friendship for many many many years. Ive been a pea since 2005-2006. It was only until I started talking about the issues that I face as a black woman that everyone labeled me a bully or started the mean girl shit. Nope. Another lie. You continue to keep on telling tales...Anyone can see—documented in quite a few posts in the thread you dragged over here from 2017 alone— where peas have called you out for lying, you claiming peas said things that they did not, you shifting their words to mean something that they never said or meant. You blame it on peas being “mean girls” because you are black when in reality, they call out your lies, your manipulative word play, and you assigning words/statements to peas who have never said what you claimed. You are a bully—at least to Elaine as you’ve repeatedly attacked her using her children, made reference to karma “exalted so that her real life situation doesn’t suck as much” (her children). you are constantly@ and tagging her in posts where she had not first engaged you, and then you then play victim and claim you’ve asked her to leave you alone. You are so full of shit.
|
|
|
Post by elaine on May 27, 2020 17:56:41 GMT
I adore you SockMonkey . You're one of my faves. I love your commitment to better listening, better understanding...being a better advocate. You really inspire me. I did state that "shocked" is probably not the right word. But outrage definitely is. One of many others, likely. This is a message board. What more can we do right here in this space other than discuss? Listen? Open our minds? Come together in our grief and anger? Cuss and call it all exactly what it is? Does more need to be done? Of COURSE. But I don't think that's what this website or forum were designed for. And what I don't like is that women who come to threads like this to do exactly what I described above feel they are being shamed because their words aren't enough. I feel like it's the correct assumption to make of the people who rally in threads like these that we know that. We know. Do we need to post what we are doing away from the board to fight racism and stand with brown and black people in order to "qualify" our feelings on the subject? And if we aren't actively doing anything, do our words and thoughts and feelings not count for anything? Thank you so much for responding. I appreciate you, too, and appreciate that you are willing to engage in this conversation publicly. I think that's important for all of us. I'd like to respond to a couple of things you said that have me thinking. The first thing is the idea that this forum isn't designed for doing more. I guess for me, being anti-racist means doing that in whatever space I am in, whether that's at dinner with my family or on a (non)scrapbooking message board. Now, that doesn't necessarily mean I'm going to throw down on any old thread, but certainly on a thread like this where we're discussing an issue of race, I think we (white people) need to consider our whiteness and our own racial frame and consider how we are responding, especially to women of color who participate here. This is how I feel and how I am framing my responses. Even my own response at first was like "Oh and the dog," and I was like... "Did I need to say that? Was that important considering the gravity of the rest of the situation?" A human response, to be sure, but in reflecting I'm trying to consider my racial frame and whose lives, safety I'm centering. I'm sharing this because I want people to understand my thought process in how I'm considering my responses to this thread. What might "doing more" look like here, beyond expressing our disgust? (I don't have that answer... just a question I ask myself). I also think a lot about shame and how much we're doing as white people. It can often feel like it's not enough, and it's hard to hear that it isn't. And, yes, our feelings count, but I try to consider how my feelings are being centered as a white woman in conversations about race, pause, and consider whether that's appropriate. We are all going to mess up, and I have messed up and continue to do so. Even on this thread, I wondered "Is it my place to jump in and defend Olan? Am I othering her or speaking over her?" So, I guess for me it's just about trying to just do better. Anyway, this is messy and complicated, but I really do appreciate your willingness to discuss. Sock, when you decide to defend objectively bad behavior - such as the posting of a person’s personal information on the internet - simply because of the races of the perpetrator and the target, you are part of the problem in race dialogue, not part of the solution, in my opinion. And it has nothing to do with speaking over Olan. It has to do with defending things that really are indefensible - regardless of ethnicity- if you are an ethical person. Some things are just wrong, regardless of the race of the person doing it. I could say a lot more on this, as I have given it quite a bit of thought, but this is the crux of it for me.
|
|
Deleted
Posts: 0
Nov 23, 2024 10:50:45 GMT
|
Post by Deleted on May 27, 2020 18:05:04 GMT
I'm so all over the place.
I grew up in Southern California. During my elementary school years, I was one of less than 10 white kids in my grade. I'm from the generation that was taught "color blindness." I now live in a suburb of Phoenix that is equally white and non-white.
Until I came to twopeas as a young adult, I truly had no idea this shit happened on such a regular, pervasive basis. I know that ignorance is part of my privilege.
17 years ago, I went to visit my white best friend, who had a black roommate. This was in Washington DC and they both had professional jobs on the hill. The roommate got up at 4:00 in the morning to straighten her hair. One night we all stayed up late hanging out and she was bemoaning her early wake up. I suggested she just skip the straightening and sleep longer. She was adamant that that wasn't possible and it wasn't til years later that I could sort of grasp the expectations that she felt were at stake for her. White women roll out of bed and throw their hair in messy buns all the time and go on about their lives without consequence.
About 8 years ago, I was eating in a fast food restaurant and a visiting out of town high school boy's athletic team was there. It was a large group. They were all non-white, and primarily black. They were so loud and rowdy that they made it difficult to hear each other and they were scaring my 2 year old son. I (what I thought was) politely asked them to quiet down. The coach came uncorked at me. He made it very clear to me that he perceived my request as an act of white aggression that I would dare tell them to quiet down in my presence. He also said that if I had a complaint, I should have directed it to the manager and he could speak to them. I was gobsmacked. I said "why would I "tattle" on you when we're two adults capable of speaking to each other?" I can 100% say that I would have (and have had) made the same request if the team were white or any other color but I truly had no concept that my actions could be taken racially. I now see that if you've spent your life perceiving that white people wish to put you in your place, that that shaped how he saw my words, no matter how they were intended.
When we went through our adoption classes, they were very adamant that if you adopted a child of another race, you needed to intentionally seek out community in that culture. One example was making sure someone taught you how to care for your black child's hair. Again, in my ignorance, my first question was "What do you mean? Hair is hair?"
Watching the Olive Garden video last week, a commenter posted about the racism of the onlooking crowd (none of whom were visible on camera), by pointing out that no one said a word until the non-white person put her hands on the hair of the white aggressor. Again, I didn't even SEE that until it was pointed out to me.
I can truthfully say that I don’t know of any active, overt racist feelings or opinions in my heart. I also realize that there may be things I hold that I don’t even know have racial bias. I am trying to overcome colorblindness. I realize that I have a life experience of privilege.
We spend most of our life in an almost "commune" style of living with two families. My family is all white, with both children adopted. One family has two white parents, with one adopted, fair skinned, non-European multi racial child. The third family has one white parent, one Hispanic parent, their two biological boys, and two adopted Black daughters. We are constantly having conversations about how to shape our children's world views. With 5 of the 7 being adopted, that's one component that we try to tackle. Of the two biological boys, one looks more white than his brother. Of the two girls, one is much darker than the other. They grew up until last year in a white foster family, so they gravitate toward me and my white neighbor differently than to their Hispanic mom. Their mom grew up wealthy in Mexico so even see says she struggles to see racism right away because she grew up as a privileged majority, though she isn't now. The boys were playing toy guns last week and we had the conversation about not pointing them at cars and I had to tell my white son that if he and the 4 other boys did that to a police officer, in certain parts of the country, he and his brother would be treated differently than the other 3, and even among those three, there might be differences based on their shades of darkness. We're constantly asking each other how to see things through each other's eyes, and through the eyes of our kids. My friend last night compared it to adoption and how people say stupid things all the time about adoption and adopted children without realizing how offensive they are and how terribly shaking to an adoptee's identity such comments could be (think things such as "real child" and "real parents" and "gave up for adoption"). We all went through lots of training to be taught those things to identify them and defend our children and help them shape their identities with those unique foundations.
I want the same kind of education about issues of race, but I also don't want to go out and find "the token black friend." I understand it's not the black person's job to educate me. But then what? That's where I'm stuck. I'm not even at the "what can I do to help" stage because I first have to learn to see. I don't want to be surprised by this crap anymore, because I want to better grasp the reality that black people experience. But I don't know how. And I don't know how to learn how without contributing to more racism in the asking.
|
|
|
Post by jeremysgirl on May 27, 2020 18:15:28 GMT
I’ve clearly stated my feelings were hurt by the things peas have said to me and no one gave a damn I am not getting in the middle of your argument with Elaine and I'm not going back to the post and reading it. I'm just not going there. I think we all need to give each other grace because I have had extensive contact with Elaine and her being racist (and just in general being unkind) goes against everything I personally know of her. I have seen her be the bigger the person and apologize on more than one occasion here. I think we need to own when we say something that hurts someone else and that goes for everyone here. I'm sorry if you were hurt by comments made by her or others. And I wholeheartedly apologize for my hand in that old thread. I was wrong in that instance and I own it. I would also like to point out I WAS here for the camaraderie and friendship for many many many years. You still can be. There are a lot of women on this board who would benefit from knowing you. And I think you might benefit from knowing some of us. I think there is potential for huge amounts of influence and growth. I think these topics are worth talking about. ETA: I was just triggered thinking my statement there made it seem like you are responsible for our growth and that isn't your responsibility. I meant that your perspective is valuable on not just on topics of race.
|
|
|
Post by mom on May 27, 2020 18:22:03 GMT
Thank you for sharing this. I hadn't seen it yet. What a kind man he is. When it would be easy to want to see her hurt and punished, he cares more about how she grows from this and how the story isn't just about him but its about the underlying issues that arent being dealt with. He says about her firing and death threats: “I can’t see how that addresses the underlying issues. I think it’s important to move beyond this instance and this one individual. T oo much focus has been put on her when it really is about the underlying issues that have plagued this city and this country for centuries. Racial issues,” he said.A graduate of Harvard University’s class of 1984, Christian Cooper suggested he’s willing to reconsider his assessment of Amy Cooper based on her actions going forward.
“I don’t think she was thinking in that moment. I’m very upset she’s getting death threats. That’s antithetical to the appropriate response,” he said. “If you’re upset that she put my life in danger by trying to bring the cops down on a black man, then how can you turn around and make a death threat? That makes no sense. It’s downright awful,” he told The Daily News. Geez. He's right. Talk about grace. However, I'm not sure her company could have allowed her to stay. Death threats to her? I didn't realize that was happening. Never an excuse for that. NEVER. If Amy Cooper has a change of heart and character, it will not be because of the reaction of the public these last 24 hours. It will be because of the kindness and grace afforded to her by Christian Cooper. That's my guess, anyway. Oh I agree. There are consequences that even the victim can't stop from happening. Losing your job, people hearing and knowing your name is just a consequence of being a racist ass. Honestly, if Christian Cooper ever wrote a book about racism and his thoughts, etc. I would be the first in line to read it.
|
|
|
Post by SockMonkey on May 27, 2020 18:23:12 GMT
Thank you so much for responding. I appreciate you, too, and appreciate that you are willing to engage in this conversation publicly. I think that's important for all of us. I'd like to respond to a couple of things you said that have me thinking. The first thing is the idea that this forum isn't designed for doing more. I guess for me, being anti-racist means doing that in whatever space I am in, whether that's at dinner with my family or on a (non)scrapbooking message board. Now, that doesn't necessarily mean I'm going to throw down on any old thread, but certainly on a thread like this where we're discussing an issue of race, I think we (white people) need to consider our whiteness and our own racial frame and consider how we are responding, especially to women of color who participate here. This is how I feel and how I am framing my responses. Even my own response at first was like "Oh and the dog," and I was like... "Did I need to say that? Was that important considering the gravity of the rest of the situation?" A human response, to be sure, but in reflecting I'm trying to consider my racial frame and whose lives, safety I'm centering. I'm sharing this because I want people to understand my thought process in how I'm considering my responses to this thread. What might "doing more" look like here, beyond expressing our disgust? (I don't have that answer... just a question I ask myself). I also think a lot about shame and how much we're doing as white people. It can often feel like it's not enough, and it's hard to hear that it isn't. And, yes, our feelings count, but I try to consider how my feelings are being centered as a white woman in conversations about race, pause, and consider whether that's appropriate. We are all going to mess up, and I have messed up and continue to do so. Even on this thread, I wondered "Is it my place to jump in and defend Olan? Am I othering her or speaking over her?" So, I guess for me it's just about trying to just do better. Anyway, this is messy and complicated, but I really do appreciate your willingness to discuss. Sock, when you decide to defend objectively bad behavior - such as the posting of a person’s personal information on the internet - simply because of the races of the perpetrator and the target, you are part of the problem in race dialogue, not part of the solution, in my opinion. And it has nothing to do with speaking over Olan. It has to do with defending things that really are indefensible - regardless of ethnicity- if you are an ethical person. Some things are just wrong, regardless of the race of the person doing it. I could say a lot more on this, as I have given it quite a bit of thought, but this is the crux of it for me. Thank you for speaking from your perspective. I agree with you that posting of personal information is NOT okay. Again, I don't know all your history and I don't think it's right that Olan or anyone posts personal info here. I want to make it clear that I'm not defending that. My intent was to ask you to reflect on the interactions and some of the comments in this thread, not necessarily on the whole history of your interactions. But, as I have said to others, intent and impact are two different things and I own that. I apologize that my words made it seem like doxxing you was acceptable behavior. It isn't. I will think on the other things you've said about how I am part of the problem in race dialogue, because I think it's important that I reflect as I've asked others to.
|
|
|
Post by FuzzyMutt on May 27, 2020 18:23:13 GMT
This right here. Our observations and outrage are never enough. You talk AT us. You don't discuss. You don't acknowledge what we say. You don't see that we are almost always agreeing with you. Can we experience what you experience as a black woman? Nope. But we try to meet you as closely as we can to the heart of what ever is being discussed. I don't feel like you give us that in return. If your "I've been trying to tell you" response to ellaknits is based on her expression of shock, I'd ask that you consider the alternative. I don't think you want people to get to a place of complacency. I don't think it serves ANYONE for white people to get to a point where they aren't shocked by blatant, horrific displays of racism. We can argue semantics...perhaps the word "shocked" isn't exactly on the nose. But the outrage expressed in her post is obvious. Crystal clear. And it appears those sentiments don't register with you at all. I once upon a thread felt like this toward something Olan said. I was so upset because I generally come from a mixed area and a mixed circle. To think that I wasn't sensitive to issues of race was kind of difficult for me to chew on. Really. I also come at this board from a feeling of kinship with all of you. And I had it in my mind that Olan didn't really want to befriend us but instead put us in our place. And I was so upset about these two things that I posted something similar to what you did above. I went to a good friend of mine and I expressed my frustration. And she put me rightly in my place. Same as Olan. This time it came from a black woman I loved in an friendship where we don't often talk about race because in my mind, it's non-issue. But that day I learned it's not a non-issue for *her*. She sees things in me that I don't even recognize as being part of my privilege. And I cannot possibly wrap my brain around all things that she experiences as a person of color. I offered Olan an apology on that thread. *I* think that experience caused me to have tremendous growth both personally and in my friendship. I still wish I could form a bond with Olan here as I have many peas. But I am going to accept that I cannot control the participation here and I'm going to treat each of you as though your posts here and my reading of them is purposeful and meant to add to my growth. I do not like to see any of you bullied and I despise personal attacks. All of us here have value and are human beings with real feelings on the other side of the keyboard. I'm just saying, maybe we can have some give and take on both sides here. Olan lives an experience most of us don't. Her view, her anger at these things, I assume some fear as person of color in a country where there is significant violence against persons of color, and yet she still comes here and shares things that make us uncomfortable. It makes me uncomfortable. I ran those 2.23 miles in memory of Armaud Arbery. And the whole damn time I did it in silence. Just thinking that my shock is gross. I mean I continue to be shocked over something that just keeps happening over and over again. But what is the alternative? That we just chalk this up to status quo. That's not the answer either. All I know is that I don't often post on these threads or school shootings because they affect me deeply. I can't watch the videos because it will haunt me. I am that sensitive. Now imagine being the mother of a black child. And then, can you watch? All I'm saying is, let's try to give each other some grace. And Olan , you'd be surprised at the amount of growth happening, even when it seems we go kicking and screaming into it. You said this so much better than I could have. I grew up as a military brat in a white family around people of all races and backgrounds. Then dad retired and we moved to my parents' hometown. The only "difference" was whether you were Italian or Greek, worked at the pottery, the mill or were white collar. I joined the military at 18 and left that town. I have cultivated relationships and friendships with people from all over the world, that look different, eat differently, eat the same, and from so many different backgrounds. There's that. When I was in my early 20's, my sister got pregnant and had a beautiful baby boy. I love this kid as if he is my own. He is a couple years older than my son, and he and my son grew up closer than cousins. More like brothers. My nephews dad is black. I didn't think about it much, or often, when he was younger. Every now and then, someone would point out for us, and that always always sucked, but it was "small", and I didn't think my nephew noticed, and I just left it alone. But as he got older, the taunts became bolder, more frequent, and hurtful. Examples: My son was super active and a climber. I used to call him monkey butt. We were in the grocery store, and the boys were looking at cereal and discussing what kind we needed for our camping trip. My nephew tossed a box of lucky charms in the basket, but my son wanted cocoa puffs, so he tried to climb into the cart to remove the lucky charms, and my nephew tried to stop him. I said, you two monkeys better settle your tails. This woman (who perhaps failed to notice the blonde haired blue eyed kid I was looking at!) tore into me, how dare I call "that boy" a monkey. Now. In retrospect, I can tell you it came from a place of my son and nephew were both little boys I loved and I adored, and I would never, ever, do something to hurt either one of them, nor would I treat them differently. But, maybe I should have been more mindful. I don't know. I do believe that my nephew thought nothing of it when they were little. Would I do it today? Probably not. Not because of social pressure, but because they are no longer squirmy little boys, lol they are young men. There was a time when the boys were 12 and 15 ish and we were leaving a skating rink/climbing wall/arcade place, and some older teens in the parking lot were loudly hanging out and joking. Mixed races. One of the kids called another (not sure which) the " word." My nephew said... I didn't know white people were allowed to use that word. The white mom in me kicked in, and I just said, no one should be using that word, no matter what color. The look on his face hurt. I think it was the first significant time that he saw "us" as white and black. Different. In my mind, I don't think anyone should use that word. It's horrible. It stands for alot, especially from my frame of reference. On his dad's side of the family, it's pretty openly used. And you know, in his grandmas living room, I would have called my nephew (and certainly my son) out for using it, but one of his uncles or cousins, no. So, that left me, thinking, alot. I had quite a few discussions with my sister, and we talked about black spaces vs white spaces. My sister is married to a (different) black man, and she says her home is a black space. I love and respect my sister, and I think I understand, but damn, it sure is an evolving understanding. At the risk of sounding super Karen, "I have lots of black friends" and while our conversations sometimes touch on race, we don't have alot of in depth discussions about it. Our friendships are based on other things, and I don't lean on my friends for my frame of reference. Often it's about our kids, our interests, work, books, our lives. And race is (alway) part of that. But I see them as people first, black second. And, I know, some people will take that as careless, or oblivious. I don't mind bending my sisters ear, because, well, she needs to talk about it too. Having a black son she has the same worries about her son as I do, and then some. And his grandma, she has no problem discussing it. More recently, my nephew has dealt with blatant and down right scary racism at school, and it breaks my heart. It's hardened him a bit, and he's definitely disappointed the bigger world isn't like the safe family (both my side and his dads side) he grew up in. He's 20. Very smart, caring and perceptive and obviously he's not just now learning this, but I think it must be horrible to feel such hatred, based on absolutely nothing. And it absolutely infuriates and sickens me that it could just as easily be my smart, kind, beautiful nephew that someone devalued and dehumanized.
|
|
|
Post by Zee on May 27, 2020 18:29:53 GMT
All of you defending Elaine as some kind hearted top tier poster are seeing what you want to see. I guess you all decided I must deserve to be called sick and abusive for no reason and when I returned and ignored her, there she is quoting me and tagging pjaye for whatever reason.
She plays just as many games as she's accusing olan of but she gets a pass.
This whole thread for me is about learning to open your eyes to what's going on around you and not about defending Elaine's honor. Bye.
|
|
|
Post by mom on May 27, 2020 18:40:04 GMT
All of you defending Elaine as some kind hearted top tier poster are seeing what you want to see. I guess you all decided I must deserve to be called sick and abusive for no reason and when I returned and ignored her, there she is quoting me and tagging pjaye for whatever reason. She plays just as many games as she's accusing olan of but she gets a pass. This whole thread for me is about learning to open your eyes to what's going on around you and not about defending Elaine's honor. Bye. Well....Elaine has only been kind to me. When my dad was battling breast cancer, she took the time to help me understand what was happening and how I could best help him. I don't give two fucks what tier Pea she is - she showed me kindness in a time that I could not breath and was afraid. I will defend her every damn day when someone posts her address on a public message board. And yep. I saw it with my own eyes when it happened because I reported it to admin.
|
|
|
Post by Zee on May 27, 2020 18:42:23 GMT
All of you defending Elaine as some kind hearted top tier poster are seeing what you want to see. I guess you all decided I must deserve to be called sick and abusive for no reason and when I returned and ignored her, there she is quoting me and tagging pjaye for whatever reason. She plays just as many games as she's accusing olan of but she gets a pass. This whole thread for me is about learning to open your eyes to what's going on around you and not about defending Elaine's honor. Bye. Well....Elaine has only been kind to me. When my dad was battling breast cancer, she took the time to help me understand what was happening and how I could best help him. I don't give two fucks what tier Pea she is - she showed me kindness in a time that I could not breath and was afraid. I will defend her every damn day when someone posts her address on a public message board. And yep. I saw it with my own eyes when it happened because I reported it to admin. I don't agree with revealing personal info. Not what I'm talking about. I mean her character. She's a hypocrite. Tag and quote me and complain about others doing the same, she's a fake.
|
|
|
Post by Zee on May 27, 2020 18:45:52 GMT
I don't have anything against you at all. Doesn't mean we'll always agree, but I won't tell you you're a sick abusive fuck who needs mental help. @fuzzymutt sorry you felt you needed to delete but I'm sure it was for the best
|
|
|
Post by jeremysgirl on May 27, 2020 19:04:34 GMT
All of you defending Elaine as some kind hearted top tier poster are seeing what you want to see. I guess you all decided I must deserve to be called sick and abusive for no reason and when I returned and ignored her, there she is quoting me and tagging pjaye for whatever reason. She plays just as many games as she's accusing olan of but she gets a pass. This whole thread for me is about learning to open your eyes to what's going on around you and not about defending Elaine's honor. Bye. I obviously missed something. And I don't even want to wade into whatever it was. But I will say I have an autistic son who was 16 when diagnosed. And I have a very hard time with the fact that he is not so accepting of his diagnosis. And Elaine helped me find local resources for him in my community when I didn't even know where to turn. And she listened to me talk about how frustrated I am over his unwillingness to accept help. And she talked kindly to me over my guilt in not recognizing it sooner. So if you want to think badly of me because of my opinion that Elaine has shown me incredible kindness, you can. But I choose to see that all of us have moments where we are less than kind. And all of us have moments where our white privilege night not be in check. We are multifaceted people and human. We make mistakes. It's how you recover from them that matters. And I will always try to repay kindness shown to me during my darkest times.
|
|
|
Post by Zee on May 27, 2020 19:07:42 GMT
All of you defending Elaine as some kind hearted top tier poster are seeing what you want to see. I guess you all decided I must deserve to be called sick and abusive for no reason and when I returned and ignored her, there she is quoting me and tagging pjaye for whatever reason. She plays just as many games as she's accusing olan of but she gets a pass. This whole thread for me is about learning to open your eyes to what's going on around you and not about defending Elaine's honor. Bye. I obviously missed something. And I don't even want to wade into whatever it was. But I will say I have an autistic son who was 16 when diagnosed. And I have a very hard time with the fact that he is not so accepting of his diagnosis. And Elaine helped me find local resources for him in my community when I didn't even know where to turn. And she listened to me talk about how frustrated I am over his unwillingness to accept help. And she talked kindly to me over my guilt in not recognizing it sooner. So if you want to think badly of me because of my opinion that Elaine has shown me incredible kindness, you can. But I choose to see that all of us have moments where we are less than kind. And all of us have moments where our white privilege night not be in check. We are multifaceted people and human. We make mistakes. It's how you recover from them that matters. And I will always try to repay kindness shown to me during my darkest times. That's a nice story. Can't say my experience is the same. You agree with calling someone mentally ill because you're stressed out in your own life, that's your choice. The same grace is not equally shared on this board.
|
|
|
Post by FuzzyMutt on May 27, 2020 19:11:43 GMT
I don't have anything against you at all. Doesn't mean we'll always agree, but I won't tell you you're a sick abusive fuck who needs mental help. @fuzzymutt sorry you felt you needed to delete but I'm sure it was for the best It was. It's nice to not feel alone though.
|
|
|
Post by papercrafteradvocate on May 27, 2020 19:20:07 GMT
All of you defending Elaine as some kind hearted top tier poster are seeing what you want to see. I guess you all decided I must deserve to be called sick and abusive for no reason and when I returned and ignored her, there she is quoting me and tagging pjaye for whatever reason. She plays just as many games as she's accusing olan of but she gets a pass. This whole thread for me is about learning to open your eyes to what's going on around you and not about defending Elaine's honor. Bye. Nope. Not true at all. I have read, re-read (and had originally posted) in that thread many times and it was Olan herself who said the words that Elaine did not say. To make matters worse, olans continued posting on the (untrue) claim got more embellished as she posted. I’m not so much defending Elaine the person, as defending the actual posts as they were written on that thread. In that thread, even Olan herself acknowledged that Elaine never said the words that she (Olan) was claiming Elaine said... It’s not the first time that Olan changed the words of what someone take said or assigned words or changed the meaning of what someone said onto some who never said such a thing (In fact, I believe it happened 3 different times with 3 different people in that same thread). It’s a matter of being honest—of which Olan has bullied Elaine over for 3 years—-for something Elaine did not say, but Olan herself inserted words/meaning into something that was not said.
|
|
|
Post by jeremysgirl on May 27, 2020 19:22:06 GMT
I obviously missed something. And I don't even want to wade into whatever it was. But I will say I have an autistic son who was 16 when diagnosed. And I have a very hard time with the fact that he is not so accepting of his diagnosis. And Elaine helped me find local resources for him in my community when I didn't even know where to turn. And she listened to me talk about how frustrated I am over his unwillingness to accept help. And she talked kindly to me over my guilt in not recognizing it sooner. So if you want to think badly of me because of my opinion that Elaine has shown me incredible kindness, you can. But I choose to see that all of us have moments where we are less than kind. And all of us have moments where our white privilege night not be in check. We are multifaceted people and human. We make mistakes. It's how you recover from them that matters. And I will always try to repay kindness shown to me during my darkest times. That's a nice story. Can't say my experience is the same. You agree with calling someone mentally ill because you're stressed out in your own life, that's your choice. The same grace is not equally shared on this board. I don't think that's OK at all. I'm quite shocked actually. I don't think mental illness is a joking matter either. Could you please direct me? ETA: Was this recent? I cannot imagine how I would miss such a thing.
|
|
|
Post by Zee on May 27, 2020 19:31:53 GMT
That's a nice story. Can't say my experience is the same. You agree with calling someone mentally ill because you're stressed out in your own life, that's your choice. The same grace is not equally shared on this board. I don't think that's OK at all. I'm quite shocked actually. I don't think mental illness is a joking matter either. Could you please direct me? ETA: Was this recent? I cannot imagine how I would miss such a thing. It was last year. And I'm bringing it up now because while I've left her alone since I came back here, she decided not to do the same.
|
|
|
Post by jeremysgirl on May 27, 2020 19:40:25 GMT
I don't think that's OK at all. I'm quite shocked actually. I don't think mental illness is a joking matter either. Could you please direct me? ETA: Was this recent? I cannot imagine how I would miss such a thing. It was last year. And I'm bringing it up now because while I've left her alone since I came back here, she decided not to do the same. Well I'm sorry. I don't think mental illness is a joking matter. To say I'm disappointed is an understatement.
|
|
|
Post by shevy on May 27, 2020 19:43:53 GMT
@missjen :
MissJen, I have a friend on Facebook who is black and reading her posts has educated me time and time again. in the 10+ years I've known her, I've thanked her for posting articles and information that educated me. But in 2016 she posted something that shook me. It's not her job to educate me as a white woman on the black person's struggles. And I really thought about it and like you was confused; how am I supposed to learn when I don't know what some of the issues are to begin with?
So one of the things that she suggested is to find some POC on social media and follow them. Don't comment on anything, but read everything. Investigate for myself what those people are saying and educate myself. After many years of doing that, then I can start slowly commenting with my educated information. And if I am handslapped or corrected, don't take it personally, use it as a lesson to grow.
And you know what? She was right. I've learned so much, but not even nearly enough. So I keep investigating when I have the ability to do so, my twitter and IG are full of POC in various occupations and roles in the community and I read every chance I get. I like or heart some statements and take photos of others so I can add them to the things I read about.
|
|
Olan
Pearl Clutcher
Enter your message here...
Posts: 4,053
Jul 13, 2014 21:23:27 GMT
|
Post by Olan on May 27, 2020 20:39:47 GMT
It was last year. And I'm bringing it up now because while I've left her alone since I came back here, she decided not to do the same. Well I'm sorry. I don't think mental illness is a joking matter. To say I'm disappointed is an understatement. Which is her MO. I stand by everything I’ve said or done here at 2peas so I won’t say Elaine pushed me to do it or even explain the circumstances but in our interactions it’s clear what her intent is every time. No one is going to make me feel guilty for placing Elaine’s name behind the words she said to me. I don’t live for the opinions of women who think what Elaine said to me is excusable or okay. She isn’t blameless. It is not at all a stretch to think if Elaine encounters a black woman who doesn’t behave in a way she thinks is appropriate that her reaction wouldn’t be to hurl some hurtful insult or call the police. Her treatment of me is indicative of this. She would probably be the first white woman who refuses to apologize bahaha 😂 I will repeat this again...calling a black woman crazy in the course of a disagreement is just like telling police a black man is threatening you because he asked you to leash your dog. You want to change the way someone views them so the audience immediately sided with you. Again I’m a long time pea I know how popularity contests shake out here and I’m 100% fine with this. Never change. I just want to preserve that it actually happened in the way that it did. Posting history will never lie.
|
|
|
Post by jeremysgirl on May 27, 2020 21:15:16 GMT
Well I'm sorry. I don't think mental illness is a joking matter. To say I'm disappointed is an understatement. Which is her MO. I stand by everything I’ve said or done here at 2peas so I won’t say Elaine pushed me to do it or even explain the circumstances but in our interactions it’s clear what her intent is every time. No one is going to make me feel guilty for placing Elaine’s name behind the words she said to me. I don’t live for the opinions of women who think what Elaine said to me is excusable or okay. She isn’t blameless. It is not at all a stretch to think if Elaine encounters a black woman who doesn’t behave in a way she thinks is appropriate that her reaction wouldn’t be to hurl some hurtful insult or call the police. Her treatment of me is indicative of this. She would probably be the first white woman who refuses to apologize bahaha 😂 I will repeat this again...calling a black woman crazy in the course of a disagreement is just like telling police a black man is threatening you because he asked you to leash your dog. You want to change the way someone views them so the audience immediately sided with you. Again I’m a long time pea I know how popularity contests shake out here and I’m 100% fine with this. Never change. I just want to preserve that it actually happened in the way that it did. Posting history will never lie. Yes thank you. I've gone right down this rabbit hole today. I had a pm that sent me looking. I'm not a controversial sort of person in my real life. I'm also very protective of my mental health. So when a thread derails I generally get off as quickly as I can. I know I live a life with rose colored glasses. Some of it is because I'm part hippie. And some of it is a matter of protection because I'm a very sensitive soul. I didn't know quite how to recover on this. I could have tucked my tail and slunk right out of here. But I'm not going to do that. I'm just going to say what's on my mind and heart and if people want to fight with me or think less of me then I'm going to be ok with that. It wasn't right to suggest you were crazy in this very thread. That isn't fair. It's harmful to imply that someone isn't thinking clearly in a way meant to demean. That's the intention I took from that post here. Second, it also wasn't right to suggest that you are a stereotypical angry black woman. That whole stereotype is racist and unjustified. I think that was out of line too. And I will credit @blitzburgirl she suggested to me that maybe just like with racism, we choose not to see what's in front of us until it affects us. And that when it doesn't touch our lives maybe we get too comfortable in our blindness. True. I own that I project my own experience onto everything I comment on here. But I need to open up my eyes and read a little more carefully and be a little more sensitive. And that's all I've got to say.
|
|
|
Post by papercrafteradvocate on May 27, 2020 22:00:10 GMT
Well I'm sorry. I don't think mental illness is a joking matter. To say I'm disappointed is an understatement. Which is her MO. I stand by everything I’ve said or done here at 2peas so I won’t say Elaine pushed me to do it or even explain the circumstances but in our interactions it’s clear what her intent is every time. No one is going to make me feel guilty for placing Elaine’s name behind the words she said to me. I don’t live for the opinions of women who think what Elaine said to me is excusable or okay. She isn’t blameless. It is not at all a stretch to think if Elaine encounters a black woman who doesn’t behave in a way she thinks is appropriate that her reaction wouldn’t be to hurl some hurtful insult or call the police. Her treatment of me is indicative of this. She would probably be the first white woman who refuses to apologize bahaha 😂 I will repeat this again...calling a black woman crazy in the course of a disagreement is just like telling police a black man is threatening you because he asked you to leash your dog. You want to change the way someone views them so the audience immediately sided with you. Again I’m a long time pea I know how popularity contests shake out here and I’m 100% fine with this. Never change. I just want to preserve that it actually happened in the way that it did. Posting history will never lie. Once again. She NEVER said the words/made the statement that you’ve been trying for the last 3 years to attach to her. YOU said it. YOU took what she said and made it something else. YOU need to step up and take responsibility for that. YOU acknowledged in the thread that she did not say what you are saying she did. This has ZERO to do with a “popularity contest” and 100% to do with you being dishonest about what was actually written, and by who...and yes—posting history does not lie—everyone can read the thread you are harping on.
|
|
|
Post by papercrafteradvocate on May 27, 2020 22:06:17 GMT
From 3 yrs ago...thread in question... Your reading comprehension is equal to Trump's. Please find one single sentence that I have ever uttered, here or anywhere else, that supports your miscomprehension of my words about the reality of the horrors of the mistreatment of African Americans in the USA. You, regardless of whether you are white, black, or purple, have been a royal &itch to me, including recent comments about my taste in clothing. I have little respect for you because of your words/behavior, I don't care what ethnicity, gender, religion, or sexual orientation you are. You have been nasty to a number of people here, without provocation from me and others. Be a grown woman and own it. I've been no more nasty than any other pea but because I am a black woman my vocalness about issues important to me make me a "royal bitch". elaine you typed that with the way that I speak on this board you would not be surprised if I was mistreated by police. You didn't say that it was warranted but I believe that was understood. If you believe I have a poor attitude but it still would be unfair for police to treat me unfairly you would have said that. You did not. I pointed about that many other white people (I did not say all like @papercraftadvocate read) have a similar views. People seem to think it only happens in Chicago or where communities are mostly black. They still deserve proper policing but we know that it doesn't just happen in those areas. Again a lot of people feel like you've expressed....That if only black people behaved differently (In my case I'm assuming less like a bitch) somehow the police would treat us differently. I disagree with you. It would be a death wish to speak with disrespect to an officer as a black woman. I would venture to guess no one does this. With that sad fact aside your perception of me is guided in large part because I am a black woman. I'm no more or no less angry or surly than any other pea here. We also know that white criminals can behave any way they'd like and still receive better treatment than black criminals. Black people have been placated for a long time with this idea that if you are respectful and not a criminal you shouldn't have any problems interacting with police but then men in stalled cars and with licenses to carry are shot with no justice you realize that isn't the truth. I think a lot of white people are like elaine and believe that the mistreatment of black people is warranted and could be prevented if black people behaved differently. I can't even believe you wrote this! I can believe Elaine, and many, many other peas', (myself included) only perception of you is that you play victim better than anyone on the board. Your attitude, NOT YOUR SKIN COLOUR is why they feel they way they do. Nothing more. SMH I have no doubt regarding the findings of the study. Which is incredibly depressing and wrong. And, I would also add that one's interpersonal communication style also impacts how one is treated, regardless of race. If the OP speaks to people IRL as she does here, I would not be surprised if she received less-than-polite responses/treatment in return. Please prove to me anywhere where I have EVER said black people deserve disrespect or mistreatment? You will be searching a looong time sister, You don't even know me, have never seen a photo of me. Your assumptions are fucking laughable. It would be a death wish to speak with disrespect to an officer as a black woman. I would venture to guess no one does this. With that sad fact aside your perception of me is guided in large part because I am a black woman. I'm no more or no less angry or surly than any other pea here. We also know that white criminals can behave any way they'd like and still receive better treatment than black criminals. Black people have been placated for a long time with this idea that if you are respectful and not a criminal you shouldn't have any problems interacting with police but then men in stalled cars and with licenses to carry are shot with no justice you realize that isn't the truth. I think a lot of white people are like elaine and believe that the mistreatment of black people is warranted and could be prevented if black people behaved differently. Your reading comprehension is equal to Trump's. Please find one single sentence that I have ever uttered, here or anywhere else, that supports your miscomprehension of my words about the reality of the horrors of the mistreatment of African Americans in the USA. You, regardless of whether you are white, black, or purple, have been a royal &itch to me, including recent comments about my taste in clothing. I have little respect for you because of your words/behavior, I don't care what ethnicity, gender, religion, or sexual orientation you are. You have been nasty to a number of people here, without provocation from me and others. Be a grown woman and own it. I have no doubt regarding the findings of the study. Which is incredibly depressing and wrong. And, I would also add that one's interpersonal communication style also impacts how one is treated, regardless of race. If the OP speaks to people IRL as she does here, I would not be surprised if she received less-than-polite responses/treatment in return. It would be a death wish to speak with disrespect to an officer as a black woman. I would venture to guess no one does this. With that sad fact aside your perception of me is guided in large part because I am a black woman. I'm no more or no less angry or surly than any other pea here. We also know that white criminals can behave any way they'd like and still receive better treatment than black criminals. Black people have been placated for a long time with this idea that if you are respectful and not a criminal you shouldn't have any problems interacting with police but then men in stalled cars and with licenses to carry are shot with no justice you realize that isn't the truth. I think a lot of white people are like elaine and believe that the mistreatment of black people is warranted and could be prevented if black people behaved differently.
|
|
|
Post by FuzzyMutt on May 27, 2020 23:53:26 GMT
From 3 yrs ago...thread in question... I've been no more nasty than any other pea but because I am a black woman my vocalness about issues important to me make me a "royal bitch". elaine you typed that with the way that I speak on this board you would not be surprised if I was mistreated by police. You didn't say that it was warranted but I believe that was understood. If you believe I have a poor attitude but it still would be unfair for police to treat me unfairly you would have said that. You did not. I pointed about that many other white people (I did not say all like @papercraftadvocate read) have a similar views. People seem to think it only happens in Chicago or where communities are mostly black. They still deserve proper policing but we know that it doesn't just happen in those areas. Again a lot of people feel like you've expressed....That if only black people behaved differently (In my case I'm assuming less like a bitch) somehow the police would treat us differently. I disagree with you. I can't even believe you wrote this! I can believe Elaine, and many, many other peas', (myself included) only perception of you is that you play victim better than anyone on the board. Your attitude, NOT YOUR SKIN COLOUR is why they feel they way they do. Nothing more. SMH I have no doubt regarding the findings of the study. Which is incredibly depressing and wrong. And, I would also add that one's interpersonal communication style also impacts how one is treated, regardless of race. If the OP speaks to people IRL as she does here, I would not be surprised if she received less-than-polite responses/treatment in return. Please prove to me anywhere where I have EVER said black people deserve disrespect or mistreatment? You will be searching a looong time sister, You don't even know me, have never seen a photo of me. Your assumptions are fucking laughable. Your reading comprehension is equal to Trump's. Please find one single sentence that I have ever uttered, here or anywhere else, that supports your miscomprehension of my words about the reality of the horrors of the mistreatment of African Americans in the USA. You, regardless of whether you are white, black, or purple, have been a royal &itch to me, including recent comments about my taste in clothing. I have little respect for you because of your words/behavior, I don't care what ethnicity, gender, religion, or sexual orientation you are. You have been nasty to a number of people here, without provocation from me and others. Be a grown woman and own it. It would be a death wish to speak with disrespect to an officer as a black woman. I would venture to guess no one does this. With that sad fact aside your perception of me is guided in large part because I am a black woman. I'm no more or no less angry or surly than any other pea here. We also know that white criminals can behave any way they'd like and still receive better treatment than black criminals. Black people have been placated for a long time with this idea that if you are respectful and not a criminal you shouldn't have any problems interacting with police but then men in stalled cars and with licenses to carry are shot with no justice you realize that isn't the truth. I think a lot of white people are like elaine and believe that the mistreatment of black people is warranted and could be prevented if black people behaved differently. Well. I guess Olan could see into the future. Articulate, kind Mr Cooper could have totally been a victim, only asking that the dog be leashes. Or Mr Floyd. I don’t have a damn word for that. I’m sorry. The insinuation that black people are supposed to be some form of .... subservient, (and pretending pride and righteousness is not acceptable for them) is bullshit. And you know what? Olan can be annoying and singularly focused, but she’s right here. It is NOT ok.
|
|
|
Post by papercrafteradvocate on May 28, 2020 0:56:31 GMT
From 3 yrs ago...thread in question... Well. I guess Olan could see into the future. Articulate, kind Mr Cooper could have totally been a victim, only asking that the dog be leashes. Or Mr Floyd. I don’t have a damn word for that. I’m sorry. The insinuation that black people are supposed to be some form of .... subservient, (and pretending pride and righteousness is not acceptable for them) is bullshit. And you know what? Olan can be annoying and singularly focused, but she’s right here. It is NOT ok. I don’t disagree with that at all. It’s the other part.
|
|
MerryMom
Pearl Clutcher
Posts: 2,566
Jul 24, 2014 19:51:57 GMT
|
Post by MerryMom on May 28, 2020 1:48:24 GMT
Can you imagine what it would look like if there was some reciprocity in the grace that black people have shown white people decade after decade? What happens when black people run out of forgiveness? Olan, I waited to respond to you so I could think carefully about my words. I have worked in child protective services for 28 years. I have seen things that most people could not imagine. I have seen the tremendous evil perpetrated on children. I have interviewed men that have murdered children, men that “ justified” the sexual abuse of INFANTS because babies like to suck on things, mothers who beat their child to near death, I’ve had to remove children from the nastiest homes but they still cry for their moms, and I’ve had to tell children that their mom died from an overdose. I’ve also seen parents overcome significant substance abuse and worked through the trauma they’ve inflicted on their children. I’ve worked with and for all the children and families I’ve served of all races to the best of my abilities. I’ve have seen the best and worst (and points in between) in people of all races and ethnicities. I have no doubt that you have experienced many things on a daily basis that I cannot begin to fathom. I HAVE seen kindness and grace extended by people of different races. No race or ethnic group has a monopoly on kindness. Olan, you don’t need to respond to my post.
|
|
|
Post by lesserknownpea on May 28, 2020 2:02:32 GMT
MerryMom thank you for the incredibly draining and heartbreaking work you do on behalf of innocent children.
|
|
Olan
Pearl Clutcher
Enter your message here...
Posts: 4,053
Jul 13, 2014 21:23:27 GMT
|
Post by Olan on Jun 7, 2020 1:31:05 GMT
|
|
Deleted
Posts: 0
Nov 23, 2024 10:50:45 GMT
|
Post by Deleted on Jun 10, 2020 14:27:46 GMT
|
|