Deleted
Posts: 0
Jun 1, 2024 7:52:26 GMT
|
Post by Deleted on Sept 2, 2015 21:07:37 GMT
Hugs scrappyoutlaw.....I get it..... It affects you deeply whether others understand why or not. Big hugs and prayers for your peace and for the peace of this family.
|
|
AmeliaBloomer
Drama Llama
Posts: 6,842
Location: USA
Jun 26, 2014 5:01:45 GMT
|
Post by AmeliaBloomer on Sept 2, 2015 21:12:39 GMT
I think the OP is being beaten up - and (amateur!) psychoanalyzed - unnecessarily. And we sure are reading a lot into the word "need." My take is that she would really like to hear that it wasn't suicide. That would help her, which is neither selfish nor making the death all about her. And if it WAS suicide, the bolded section of anxiousmom's mom's post explains a lot. I would imagine all of us have been touched by suicide. None of us owns this issue or has the best answer simply because we have experience as a family member or friend. And it's also possible that OP's deceased comrade would have liked her to know what happened. No, we can't know that, but we also can't discount it.
|
|
Deleted
Posts: 0
Jun 1, 2024 7:52:26 GMT
|
Post by Deleted on Sept 2, 2015 21:18:11 GMT
What will change if you did know it was suicide? I say this with a hug, have you considered or are you in therapy? I don't know your life experiences and think that what you have shared 'battle buddies' leads me to consider therapy as being beneficial for you. Do you know the family? Perhaps a heartfelt conversation (in time) with the family explaining why you would like to know and what the information would mean to you?? I just don't know if I agree with this, though. I really feel for you, {{hugs}} Annette I really appreciate your concern, but I am a happy and well-adjusted. My experiences in the military were nothing but positive, unfortunately many of my fellow soldiers cannot say the same thing. I think I would feel better if it were not suicide, as weird as it sounds, because it wouldn't have been preventable in the same way suicide can be prevented. I have lost count of how many fellow soldiers I know that have taken their own lives, and each one stings a little bit more. I honestly think I am just sick of getting those phone calls, it's my first thought when I hear someone has passed. Unfortunately I did not know his family, and I suppose I should respect their privacy and let it be. I really don't think it can always be prevented. I do understand the wanting to know why. I found out yesterday a high school classmate passed away. I'm younger than 40 and quite a few have died. I guess it's just trying to understand especially when they are your age.
|
|
|
Post by LiLi on Sept 2, 2015 22:00:51 GMT
Suicide cannot always be prevented. I know from experience. Both my own and my families. Please respect their privacy. A loss is hard enough with someone prying. I disagree with your first statement, but that's a different conversation for another thread. Please tell me where I have done or said anything that is prying. I came on a forum to find out if I can get the information BECAUSE I will not approach the family. I did not post any identifying information. I seriously don't understand why there seems to be an idea that I am invading the family's privacy because I want to find out more information about what happened to my friend WITHOUT their knowledge or asking them directly. If it's public record, then no privacy is being breached. IMHO you are prying by trying to find information, even if it is public, behind their backs. Information that they would probably prefer to keep private. Or else they would have shared it in a public way. IE: obit or Facebook or wherever. They can't make a death record private, but that doesn't mean they want people prying to find it. It isn't like you need it for genealogy or research. You are trying to find information about someone that their loved ones decided not to share to make yourself feel better. This isn't about you. I am sorry for your loss. I know I am being harsh, this touched a nerve.
|
|
Rainbow
Pearl Clutcher
Where salt is in the air and sand is at my feet...
Posts: 4,103
Jun 26, 2014 5:57:41 GMT
|
Post by Rainbow on Sept 2, 2015 22:16:19 GMT
I disagree with your first statement, but that's a different conversation for another thread. Please tell me where I have done or said anything that is prying. I came on a forum to find out if I can get the information BECAUSE I will not approach the family. I did not post any identifying information. I seriously don't understand why there seems to be an idea that I am invading the family's privacy because I want to find out more information about what happened to my friend WITHOUT their knowledge or asking them directly. If it's public record, then no privacy is being breached. IMHO you are prying by trying to find information, even if it is public, behind their backs. Information that they would probably prefer to keep private. Or else they would have shared it in a public way. IE: obit or Facebook or wherever. They can't make a death record private, but that doesn't mean they want people prying to find it. It isn't like you need it for genealogy or research. You are trying to find information about someone that their loved ones decided not to share to make yourself feel better. This isn't about you. I am sorry for your loss. I know I am being harsh, this touched a nerve. You don't know ANYTHING about the family or what they want/decided. You are GUESSING. I don't think there is anything wrong with trying to find out what happened to someone with which she was close. It is a natural feeling/action. She isn't bothering the family, so why don't you just leave her alone?
|
|
|
Post by LiLi on Sept 2, 2015 22:20:13 GMT
IMHO you are prying by trying to find information, even if it is public, behind their backs. Information that they would probably prefer to keep private. Or else they would have shared it in a public way. IE: obit or Facebook or wherever. They can't make a death record private, but that doesn't mean they want people prying to find it. It isn't like you need it for genealogy or research. You are trying to find information about someone that their loved ones decided not to share to make yourself feel better. This isn't about you. I am sorry for your loss. I know I am being harsh, this touched a nerve. You don't know ANYTHING about the family or what they want/decided. You are GUESSING. I don't think there is anything wrong with trying to find out what happened to someone with which she was close. It is a natural feeling/action. She isn't bothering the family, so why don't you just leave her alone?She said in the original post they decided not to share. I didn't just pull it out of my ass. Why didn't you quote the whole thing? She asked a question and I answered! Here is what she said, "Please tell me where I have done or said anything that is prying." I wasn't picking on her. Sheesh.
|
|
Rainbow
Pearl Clutcher
Where salt is in the air and sand is at my feet...
Posts: 4,103
Jun 26, 2014 5:57:41 GMT
|
Post by Rainbow on Sept 3, 2015 1:09:23 GMT
You don't know ANYTHING about the family or what they want/decided. You are GUESSING. I don't think there is anything wrong with trying to find out what happened to someone with which she was close. It is a natural feeling/action. She isn't bothering the family, so why don't you just leave her alone? She said in the original post they decided not to share. I didn't just pull it out of my ass. Why didn't you quote the whole thing? She asked a question and I answered! Here is what she said, "Please tell me where I have done or said anything that is prying." I wasn't picking on her. Sheesh. She said "I know the family would share if they wanted to." Perhaps they will, or not. Either way you don't need to be so nasty to her. This is someone she cared about. And if you have a problem with the quote button, perhaps you can work with proboards to fix it.
|
|
Deleted
Posts: 0
Jun 1, 2024 7:52:26 GMT
|
Post by Deleted on Sept 3, 2015 1:26:13 GMT
Sorry for your loss scrappyoutlaw. I totally understand wanting to know, and the suicides that have happened in my circle had nothing to do with PTSD - I think it's pretty normal to wonder what happened to people when they die suddenly.
That said, when the family says less than nothing about what happened, that's been my indicator that it was suicide. Later the details were shared, but in the moment, I think the families were shocked and also felt guilt and/or some of the stigma, and so they didn't share the cause right away. I was really impressed with Heidi Swapp's announcement about her son, because the loss is bad enough without also feeling guilty or ashamed.
Anyway, no, there's not really a way to find out except from someone who knows. Complete lack of information is certainly a big hint, though. 17 people are going to post now describing situations where that's not the case and suggesting you not make assumptions - but this has been my experience. Of course be prepared that if the person who tells you what happened was someone who was intimately involved, you might get a lot more details than you want. It's hard to tell someone who is grieving, "TMI".
Again, I'm so sorry for your loss.
|
|
|
Post by annabella on Sept 3, 2015 2:05:24 GMT
I'm like you, I like to know cause of death when someone goes young, I don't understand why it's so private. It seems the trend these days is to not mention it in obituaries which to me is the most important detail of a death announcement.
|
|
|
Post by AussieMeg on Sept 3, 2015 2:18:46 GMT
I get it too. 100 people can post on this thread that you should butt out and MYOB, but that’s not going to help you. You can’t help how you feel, and if you feel that you “need” to know, I will take your word for it.
A similar situation in a way…… a few months ago a school friend of my DD committed suicide. Whilst the family let people know that it was suicide, they did not disclose “how” he did it. DD and I were talking about it, and I said to her that it really doesn’t make any difference how he did it. But she said that not knowing was actually worse for her and her friends, because they all kept imagining all the worst possible things and it was really preying on their minds. I know it’s not the same as your situation, but I think the feelings of “needing” to know something that the family was not prepared to disclose are the same.
(((Hugs))) to you.
|
|
Deleted
Posts: 0
Jun 1, 2024 7:52:26 GMT
|
Post by Deleted on Sept 3, 2015 2:31:03 GMT
My DH has PTSD after his service and I completely get your need to know. In my husband's case, even though he is healthy now, there is always a sliver of fear when I hear of a Vet who couldn't go on. I get it. (hugs)
|
|
|
Post by hop2 on Sept 3, 2015 2:50:50 GMT
Death certificates are public record, meaning anyone can order one (birth certs are NOT put loc record). That said, in this instance, I think you need to discuss this with your therapist (based on your ptsd/battlebuddies comments, I'm assuming you are seeing someone). If the family chooses not to release cause of death, or doesn't yet know the cause, you need to respect that and deal with the underlying reasons that make you think you need to know. When my fil passed away, rumors of suicide immediately surfaced in the town where he lived. It was not suicide, but cause of death was not available for 13 weeks after he passed away, so I'm sure there are still people in that town who believe he committed suicide. That sort of talk was extremely hurtful to the entire family. Not every where here you must be a blood relative unless the death was a long time ago. The laws are local ( city / municipality ) laws here and are slightly different in each place, but a death certificate is not publuc record here. OP it will depend on where the person died and the laws in that place. Look up the website in the town/city ( or county in some places ) the death occurred and there should be directions on how to apply for one, and what is required. Sorry for your loss
|
|
|
Post by RiverIsis on Sept 3, 2015 4:27:13 GMT
My guess is that it varies from state to state. I had a friend that was murdered and the press were all over it when her death certificate was released/filed by the state because the police had said so little until that time.
My thoughts are with you. A dear friend of mine is a counselor on base for soldiers.
|
|
|
Post by mama2three on Sept 3, 2015 11:19:54 GMT
I can go to the Hall of Records and get a death certificate for about ten dollars and it states cause of death. I'm in So Cal and have done this many times as I am a genealogist. Try the Hall of Records for your county. This is not universal. Some places make it very difficult, even when you're related and have a need for the certificate to deal with creditors. The local town hall required that I prove my relationship and knowledge of the date, time and circumstances before they'd release my father's certificate. I had to fill out a log stating why I needed it and then they told me they had 10 days to provide the copies and I'd have to come back - the office was in a different state and a pain to get to. And I needed the certificate to close accounts and such. OP, I'm sorry for the loss of your friend, and I understand the desire for closure, but I think you should let it go.
|
|
|
Post by LiLi on Sept 3, 2015 22:09:34 GMT
She said in the original post they decided not to share. I didn't just pull it out of my ass. Why didn't you quote the whole thing? She asked a question and I answered! Here is what she said, "Please tell me where I have done or said anything that is prying." I wasn't picking on her. Sheesh. She said "I know the family would share if they wanted to." Perhaps they will, or not. Either way you don't need to be so nasty to her. This is someone she cared about. And if you have a problem with the quote button, perhaps you can work with proboards to fix it. scrappyoutlaw if you felt I was nasty, I am sorry I came off that way. I do realize I was strongly opinionated, but I meant no nastiness to you at all. I have strong feelings about the subject too. Again, sorry for your loss. Rainbow My quote feature works just fine. Either way, you don't need to be so nasty to me.
|
|