|
Post by bc2ca on Oct 13, 2019 0:24:48 GMT
i think I get what she was trying to say. The victim as a nameless person was imagined to be a party girl and a drinker and drunk. Some people stopped with that description and never went further. But on 60 minutes people were able to see her as a person, not just a description. For SOME people perception matters. I think it’s pretty gross how many people are more bothered by this rape now that they see who the victim is. It shouldn’t matter.
|
|
|
Post by freecharlie on Oct 13, 2019 2:54:24 GMT
i think I get what she was trying to say. The victim as a nameless person was imagined to be a party girl and a drinker and drunk. Some people stopped with that description and never went further. But on 60 minutes people were able to see her as a person, not just a description. For SOME people perception matters. I think it’s pretty gross how many people are more bothered by this rape now that they see who the victim is. It shouldn’t matter. no, it shouldn't matter, but people justify things all the time.
|
|
ComplicatedLady
Pearl Clutcher
Posts: 3,037
Location: Valley of the Sun
Jul 26, 2014 21:02:07 GMT
|
Post by ComplicatedLady on Oct 13, 2019 3:16:04 GMT
By hearing Chanel on 60 Minutes and listening to her speaking out, I suspect many people could no longer use the “well, it couldn’t/won’t happen to me or to my kid” blinders. If she was “just a drunken party girl” then it couldn’t happen to them—because they may go to parties but aren’t really party girls. If she “wasn’t the brightest” or “didn’t seem smart” then it couldn’t happen to them—because they make better choices. People who think rape only happens to drunken party girls or to people who make bad decisions had to open their eyes to the realization that rape does happen to bright, articulate, attractive, intelligent, whatever-elitist-adjective-you-want-to-use-to-pretend-you-are-safe-from-rape women.
|
|
|
Post by lesserknownpea on Oct 13, 2019 5:25:24 GMT
i think I get what she was trying to say. The victim as a nameless person was imagined to be a party girl and a drinker and drunk. Some people stopped with that description and never went further. But on 60 minutes people were able to see her as a person, not just a description. For SOME people perception matters. I think it’s pretty gross how many people are more bothered by this rape now that they see who the victim is. It shouldn’t matter. There is a cultural myth about rape victims. They are innocent virgins attacked after chorus practice. Or they’re “loose” women. In which case they don’t count. And they’re all young. Because no one would want to rape an old woman, right? Being a rape victim is a deeply, deeply personal thing. When it is also public, there is so much shame. I’m not saying there should be. But there is. Because of how our culture trains us. I was treated nothing but kindly, and with dignity by everyone I encountered through the process. But it took years of therapy to make the shame go away. You feel like people are talking about the unlikeliness of it. The how. The why. You feel they look at you different. I understand why she wants to recognize the place where good people intervened. The words that said This Should Not Happen. How this young woman finds the strength to do what she is doing is inspiring.
|
|
|
Post by gar on Oct 13, 2019 9:14:03 GMT
her alcohol abuse and its part in this tragedy It only became a tragedy when Brock Turner decided he could do whatever he liked. The alcohol is irrelevant. If not for him it wouldn't be a tragedy whether she'd been drinking or not.
|
|
Deleted
Posts: 0
Apr 25, 2024 19:02:56 GMT
|
Post by Deleted on Oct 13, 2019 9:51:38 GMT
What does that sound like? At first I thought she did not want to take responsibility for her alcohol abuse and its part in this tragedy. So I was more than a little skeptical. I was wrong and I regret it. None of us should be defined by our worst moments. She knows. She knows she was portrayed as "intoxicated, unconscious woman" over and over again in all news coverage of this horrifying rape. And she came forward so that we can all see her as the intelligent articulate woman she is. Not to mention beautiful, and brave.
And as for Brock Turner? throwawaythekey (Like *that's* gonna happen.) Layce I find the bolded way of thinking despicable,especially from a woman. That way of thinking is part of the problem. Ask yourself do the first deserved to be raped but the other doesn't? Rape is Rape doesn't matter how you are dressed, whether you are compos mentis or whether he's your boyfriend or your husband, it is still rape unless you give consent. Men who rape are not only rapist but are also cowards to rape an unconscious person. Good job that the two young men that found her didn't think the same way as Brock Turner, the media or you did.
|
|
Deleted
Posts: 0
Apr 25, 2024 19:02:56 GMT
|
Post by Deleted on Oct 13, 2019 13:34:50 GMT
What does that sound like? At first I thought she did not want to take responsibility for her alcohol abuse and its part in this tragedy. So I was more than a little skeptical. I was wrong and I regret it. None of us should be defined by our worst moments. She knows. She knows she was portrayed as "intoxicated, unconscious woman" over and over again in all news coverage of this horrifying rape. And she came forward so that we can all see her as the intelligent articulate woman she is. Not to mention beautiful, and brave.
And as for Brock Turner? throwawaythekey (Like *that's* gonna happen.) Layce I find the bolded way of thinking despicable,especially from a woman. That way of thinking is part of the problem. Ask yourself do the first deserved to be raped but the other doesn't? Rape is Rape doesn't matter how you are dressed, whether you are compos mentis or whether he's your boyfriend or your husband, it is still rape unless you give consent. Men who rape are not only rapist but are also cowards to rape an unconscious person. Good job that the two young men that found her didn't think the same way as Brock Turner, the media or you did. We, even women, have this deeply rooted belief (put there by men) that some women "deserve it".
|
|
inkedup
Pearl Clutcher
Posts: 4,837
Jun 26, 2014 5:00:26 GMT
|
Post by inkedup on Oct 13, 2019 16:33:43 GMT
I am glad to see she is actually an articulate, intelligent woman. Not necessarily the drunken party girl her circumstances seemed to portray her as after all. I do remember this story and the disgusting assault and thinking, I mean, holy shit. What kind of out-and-out unabashed alcoholic binge-drinking does it take to hit that kind of critical mass? She is raising awareness and bringing some positive results out of her circumstances by being brave enough to come forward. Write a book. Speaking engagements. I hope it helps her to heal and to help others as well. And I hope she is not promoting one's right to go out and deliberately get absolutely shitfaced and avoid all consequences. How many of us could support that agenda? Drink responsibly. Layce No one, not even "drunken party girls', deserves to be raped. It's crazy that your takeaway from her being assaulted was that her circumstances made her seem like someone who deserved to be raped. Ugh.
|
|
|
Post by Layce on Oct 13, 2019 17:47:18 GMT
Some of you have deliberately misinterpreted my posts and are beating me up for what you refer to as blaming the victim. Nowhere have I said she deserved it or that she did anything to provoke it. For heaven's sake. I am clearly on her side, in her court. I am not going to repeat myself to prove it. And excuse me, irrelevant? Everything that occurred that night is relevant. And it doesn't translate to blaming or shaming the victim. All I'm saying is, remove the alcohol abuse from this scenario and that rape would not have occurred. Even the victim knows that. And it still should never have happened. An aggressive, drunken college student took advantage of an intoxicated, unconscious woman and raped her! That is never okay! Clearly, some of you are unfamiliar with rape statistics. Particularly, campus rape statistics. The connection between alcohol abuse and sexual assault is real. And *all* campuses should be counseled on this accordingly, either as part of student orientation or some other requirement of college admission. But I digress. I guess I could provide one link to support these statistics, which I fully expect some of the more ignorant of you to go on to diss as irrelevant. LinkFlame away, I've nothing else to say. Layce
|
|
Deleted
Posts: 0
Apr 25, 2024 19:02:56 GMT
|
Post by Deleted on Oct 13, 2019 18:24:28 GMT
Some of you have deliberately misinterpreted my posts and are beating me up for what you refer to as blaming the victim. Nowhere have I said she deserved it or that she did anything to provoke it. For heaven's sake. I am clearly on her side, in her court. I am not going to repeat myself to prove it. And excuse me, irrelevant? Everything that occurred that night is relevant. And it doesn't translate to blaming or shaming the victim. All I'm saying is, remove the alcohol abuse from this scenario and that rape would not have occurred. Even the victim knows that. And it still should never have happened. An aggressive, drunken college student took advantage of an intoxicated, unconscious woman and raped her! That is never okay! Clearly, some of you are unfamiliar with rape statistics. Particularly, campus rape statistics. The connection between alcohol abuse and sexual assault is real. And *all* campuses should be counseled on this accordingly, either as part of student orientation or some other requirement of college admission. But I digress. I guess I could provide one link to support these statistics, which I fully expect some of the more ignorant of you to go on to diss as irrelevant. LinkFlame away, I've nothing else to say. Layce You can't say that with certainty. Women get raped by stone cold sober men every day somewhere. Brock Turner was only just over twice the legal limit.....most, if not all people, know what they're doing with that level of alcohol in their blood especially someone like BT who was used to drinking alcohol from a much younger age. He was an experienced drinker who had already been been arrested on that campus previous to that night for underage drinking. Non of us are ignorant as you put it. We're a bunch of women who happen to believe that rape is abhorrent under any circumstance.
|
|
|
Post by SockMonkey on Oct 13, 2019 18:43:30 GMT
And I hope she is not promoting one's right to go out and deliberately get absolutely shitfaced and avoid all consequences. How many of us could support that agenda? Drink responsibly. Layce Fuck, and I cannot stress this enough, 100% of the way off.
|
|
|
Post by busy on Oct 13, 2019 18:44:06 GMT
Some of you have deliberately misinterpreted my posts and are beating me up for what you refer to as blaming the victim. Nowhere have I said she deserved it or that she did anything to provoke it. For heaven's sake. I am clearly on her side, in her court. I am not going to repeat myself to prove it. And excuse me, irrelevant? Everything that occurred that night is relevant. And it doesn't translate to blaming or shaming the victim. All I'm saying is, remove the alcohol abuse from this scenario and that rape would not have occurred. Even the victim knows that. And it still should never have happened. An aggressive, drunken college student took advantage of an intoxicated, unconscious woman and raped her! That is never okay! Clearly, some of you are unfamiliar with rape statistics. Particularly, campus rape statistics. The connection between alcohol abuse and sexual assault is real. And *all* campuses should be counseled on this accordingly, either as part of student orientation or some other requirement of college admission. But I digress. I guess I could provide one link to support these statistics, which I fully expect some of the more ignorant of you to go on to diss as irrelevant. LinkFlame away, I've nothing else to say. Layce When you think multiple people are “intentionally misinterpreting” what you said, I’d encourage you to consider that perhaps the problem is with how you stated your position and not how others interpreted it.
|
|
|
Post by SockMonkey on Oct 13, 2019 18:45:51 GMT
Some of you have deliberately misinterpreted my posts and are beating me up for what you refer to as blaming the victim. Nowhere have I said she deserved it or that she did anything to provoke it. For heaven's sake. I am clearly on her side, in her court. I am not going to repeat myself to prove it. And excuse me, irrelevant? Everything that occurred that night is relevant. And it doesn't translate to blaming or shaming the victim. All I'm saying is, remove the alcohol abuse from this scenario and that rape would not have occurred. Even the victim knows that. And it still should never have happened. An aggressive, drunken college student took advantage of an intoxicated, unconscious woman and raped her! That is never okay! Clearly, some of you are unfamiliar with rape statistics. Particularly, campus rape statistics. The connection between alcohol abuse and sexual assault is real. And *all* campuses should be counseled on this accordingly, either as part of student orientation or some other requirement of college admission. But I digress. I guess I could provide one link to support these statistics, which I fully expect some of the more ignorant of you to go on to diss as irrelevant. LinkFlame away, I've nothing else to say. Layce When you think multiple people are “intentionally misinterpreting” what you said, I’d encourage you to consider that perhaps the problem is with how you stated your position and not how others interpreted it.
|
|
Deleted
Posts: 0
Apr 25, 2024 19:02:56 GMT
|
Post by Deleted on Oct 13, 2019 18:52:25 GMT
All I'm saying is, remove the alcohol abuse from this scenario and that rape would not have occurred. How do you know that? What people are trying to explain to you is that alcohol isn't the problem, men who sexually assault women are the problem. That's all.
|
|
|
Post by SockMonkey on Oct 13, 2019 18:53:58 GMT
All I'm saying is, remove the alcohol abuse from this scenario and that rape would not have occurred. How do you know that? What people are trying to explain to you is that alcohol isn't the problem, men who sexually assault women are the problem. That's all. Remove THE RAPIST from the situation and that rape would not have occurred.
|
|
Deleted
Posts: 0
Apr 25, 2024 19:02:56 GMT
|
Post by Deleted on Oct 13, 2019 19:21:31 GMT
Yep. Statistically, rapists are the no 1 cause of all rapes.
|
|
|
Post by SockMonkey on Oct 13, 2019 19:37:48 GMT
This happened to pop up on my FB timeline today. I don't run on the awesome trail behind my house anymore, because it'd mean running alone, and frankly, I'm too scared. www.runnersworld.com/women/a29356446/women-run-without-fear"In a recent Runner’s World survey, a massive 84 percent of women said they have experienced some kind of harassment while running that left them feeling unsafe. That includes physical actions like groping, or being followed or flashed, as well as subtler forms like catcalls, honks, and lewd comments."It's not alcohol. It happens when we go to a party. It happens when we walk down a street. It happens when we go for a bike ride or a run. It happens when we walk to our cars. It happens in our own homes. It happens when we are drunk. It happens when we are sober. The commonality here is men who have been socialized to believe they can do whatever they want with and to women's bodies. And if you're a woman who blames alcohol for rape, you are participating in that continued socialization. So fucking stop it. Our lives depend on it.
|
|
|
Post by gar on Oct 13, 2019 20:12:19 GMT
Some of you have deliberately misinterpreted my posts and are beating me up for what you refer to as blaming the victim. Nowhere have I said she deserved it or that she did anything to provoke it. For heaven's sake. I am clearly on her side, in her court. I am not going to repeat myself to prove it. And excuse me, irrelevant? Everything that occurred that night is relevant. And it doesn't translate to blaming or shaming the victim. All I'm saying is, remove the alcohol abuse from this scenario and that rape would not have occurred. Even the victim knows that. And it still should never have happened. An aggressive, drunken college student took advantage of an intoxicated, unconscious woman and raped her! That is never okay! Clearly, some of you are unfamiliar with rape statistics. Particularly, campus rape statistics. The connection between alcohol abuse and sexual assault is real. And *all* campuses should be counseled on this accordingly, either as part of student orientation or some other requirement of college admission. But I digress. I guess I could provide one link to support these statistics, which I fully expect some of the more ignorant of you to go on to diss as irrelevant. LinkFlame away, I've nothing else to say. Layce A-clue-istic - having no clue whatsoever. A wonderful made up word I heard years ago but never has it been more appropriate. Layce you still don't get it do you. Shame on you, and as busy said - if this many people 'misunderstand' what you're saying, it might be time to look with an open mind at exactly what you are saying.
|
|
huskergal
Pearl Clutcher
Posts: 2,975
Jun 25, 2014 20:22:13 GMT
|
Post by huskergal on Oct 13, 2019 21:32:50 GMT
I was drunk and around drunk guys more than once in my life. I was never raped, because fortunately, none of the guys were rapists. Alcohol doesn't matter.
|
|
Just T
Drama Llama
Posts: 5,541
Jun 26, 2014 1:20:09 GMT
|
Post by Just T on Oct 13, 2019 22:15:25 GMT
All I'm saying is, remove the alcohol abuse from this scenario and that rape would not have occurred. How do you know this?? I'm going to be as nice as I can, but the things you are saying piss me off. I was nearly raped at a party in college. By a guy who was not drunk. I was drinking, but I wasn't drunk. I was not a party girl by any stretch of the imagination. I was actually the girl who really didn't like beer and would "nurse" the same beer all night. I have no doubt this guy would have raped me if a friend hadn't walked in the room. NO way could I have stopped him, even if I hadn't had a single drop of alcohol. I was a tiny thing, probably weighed not much more than 100 pounds. He was a strong, big guy, Division 1 college basketball player. I could barely breathe with him on top of me, much less fight him off. I never told anyone about this. Not even my husband. Wanna know why??? Because I was so ashamed, thought it was my fault. I should not have been drinking. I shouldn't have kissed a guy while we were dancing. Yada yada yada. I never told a living soul about this, here or anywhere else, until the Brett Kavanaugh fiasco. Brock Turner was a RAPIST. People who are not rapists do not rape girls who are passed out drunk on a sidewalk. People who are not rapists get help for the girl, maybe help her back to her dorm, or look at her cell phone and call a friend to come get her. A guy who is going to rape a passed out drunk girl on a sidewalk is going to rape, or attempt to rape, someone else at some point. For you to say she needs to take responsibility for the role her alcohol abuse played in her rape is disgusting.
|
|
|
Post by busy on Oct 13, 2019 22:25:39 GMT
Brock Turner was a RAPIST. People who are not rapists do not rape girls who are passed out drunk on a sidewalk. People who are not rapists get help for the girl, maybe help her back to her dorm, or look at her cell phone and call a friend to come get her. A guy who is going to rape a passed out drunk girl on a sidewalk is going to rape, or attempt to rape, someone else at some point. For you to say she needs to take responsibility for the role her alcohol abuse played in her rape is disgusting. Again for those in the cheap seats. Just T I'm sorry about what happened to you and thankful your friend walked in before it got worse. Thank you for sharing your story and it was 100% NOT your fault in any way. *hugs*
|
|
Just T
Drama Llama
Posts: 5,541
Jun 26, 2014 1:20:09 GMT
|
Post by Just T on Oct 13, 2019 22:34:05 GMT
@just T I'm sorry about what happened to you and thankful your friend walked in before it got worse. Thank you for sharing your story and it was 100% NOT your fault in any way. *huga* Thank you. It's so strange, even after all these years(it happened in 1983), I still do have feelings of doing something wrong. It is just so ingrained in women that men rape because of the way we are dressed (I was wearing jeans and a turtleneck sweater, by the way, LOL), we drank too much, we flirted, blah blah blah, so what do we expect? I spent a few days with my 25 year old son this weekend, who is a very sweet, loving guy, who treats the girls he dates so well. He didn't know about the Brock Turner case, or if he did, we have never talked about it. After reading this thread from the beginning, it has been on my mind. I asked him, hypothetically, what he would do if he was in college and found a drunk girl passed out on the sidewalk. He said, "Is this a serious question, Mom??" And then, "I would find a way to help her." Then, I told him about the Brock Turner case, and he thought I was lying. He had to look it up on his phone. And then, he was pissed off and said he hoped the guy was in prison for a long time, and I told him NOPE. Sorry I digressed here. This is a hot button for me.
|
|
Deleted
Posts: 0
Apr 25, 2024 19:02:56 GMT
|
Post by Deleted on Oct 13, 2019 23:20:46 GMT
@just T I'm sorry about what happened to you and thankful your friend walked in before it got worse. Thank you for sharing your story and it was 100% NOT your fault in any way. *huga* Thank you. It's so strange, even after all these years(it happened in 1983), I still do have feelings of doing something wrong. It is just so ingrained in women that men rape because of the way we are dressed (I was wearing jeans and a turtleneck sweater, by the way, LOL), we drank too much, we flirted, blah blah blah, so what do we expect? I spent a few days with my 25 year old son this weekend, who is a very sweet, loving guy, who treats the girls he dates so well. He didn't know about the Brock Turner case, or if he did, we have never talked about it. After reading this thread from the beginning, it has been on my mind. I asked him, hypothetically, what he would do if he was in college and found a drunk girl passed out on the sidewalk. He said, "Is this a serious question, Mom??" And then, "I would find a way to help her." Then, I told him about the Brock Turner case, and he thought I was lying. He had to look it up on his phone. And then, he was pissed off and said he hoped the guy was in prison for a long time, and I told him NOPE. Sorry I digressed here. This is a hot button for me. Thank you for sharing your story. And this story. I have goosebumps. We can and are doing better and our sons will be better. But we must speak out against this 'certain girls deserve it' attitude - every time we encounter it.
|
|
Just T
Drama Llama
Posts: 5,541
Jun 26, 2014 1:20:09 GMT
|
Post by Just T on Oct 13, 2019 23:37:54 GMT
Thank you for sharing your story. And this story. I have goosebumps. We can and are doing better and our sons will be better. But we must speak out against this 'certain girls deserve it' attitude - every time we encounter it. Thank you. Yes, we do need to speak out against the "girls deserve it" attitude. It saddens/sickens me that in 2019, there are still people, women especially, who STILL try to put some of the blame on the woman when they are raped or assaulted.
|
|