|
Post by papercrafteradvocate on Jul 14, 2020 3:42:52 GMT
I don’t know guys I just don’t know 😞 I’m very confused right now. I’m with you. I do not see anything racist at all That has happened. I do however see emails, Supposedly sent by Tim and Mario, that are 100% unacceptable and should not be overlooked. They’ve stated that the emails are doctored.
|
|
|
Post by Night Owl on Jul 14, 2020 3:47:15 GMT
What did the card look like? Did they take it down because they didn't want to (in their opinion) get political? I don't understand why the card would be a problem, BLM is a good thing and I would think showing diversity would be an asset to Tim Holtz and company.
|
|
scrappermcg
Junior Member
Posts: 88
Jun 1, 2017 6:12:22 GMT
|
Post by scrappermcg on Jul 14, 2020 3:47:39 GMT
We'll never know the truth. Let's make cards. No time for drama!
|
|
pinklady
Drama Llama
Posts: 6,071
Nov 14, 2016 23:47:03 GMT
|
Post by pinklady on Jul 14, 2020 3:47:43 GMT
I’m with you. I do not see anything racist at all That has happened. I do however see emails, Supposedly sent by Tim and Mario, that are 100% unacceptable and should not be overlooked. They’ve stated that the emails are doctored. Agreed. What he didn’t say was that they were 100% not his words. In my opinion, he is using that “Doctored” terminology because those are his and Mario’s words taken out of context, meaning he sent them as a response to something else, not this George Floyd card that the artist took down from the FB group.
|
|
|
Post by fashionista on Jul 14, 2020 3:50:53 GMT
I’m with you. I do not see anything racist at all That has happened. I do however see emails, Supposedly sent by Tim and Mario, that are 100% unacceptable and should not be overlooked. They’ve stated that the emails are doctored. I don’t believe he is racist. I also don’t like people throwing the race card. We have BIG issues in our Nation and racism IS ONE of them. Something did happen. Why block people and why NOT allow them to post comments. I’m still VERY confused. 🥴
|
|
|
Post by gale w on Jul 14, 2020 3:53:37 GMT
What did the card look like? Did they take it down because they didn't want to (in their opinion) get political? I don't understand why the card would be a problem, BLM is a good thing and I would think showing diversity would be an asset to Tim Holtz and company. They didn't take it down. The poster shared it, many group members replied saying it was political or whatever, the original poster removed it. Admins didn't take it down and didn't ask the OP to. The OP told Lara this but she apparently doesn't believe her. I didn't see it, that I know of. I usually scroll through my feed and probably scroll past 50 cards a day that I forget what they looked like.
|
|
pinklady
Drama Llama
Posts: 6,071
Nov 14, 2016 23:47:03 GMT
|
Post by pinklady on Jul 14, 2020 4:03:02 GMT
This is the artwork in question
|
|
|
Post by paperamy on Jul 14, 2020 4:03:49 GMT
But it's more dramatic if she lies in the video and corrects herself where most people watching the video won't see that correction...IG stories only last a day and people aren't going to scroll and read through every comment. If she really wanted to make sure people had the right information, she could add an icard, notate the incorrect information in the description, delete the video and repost with the edit, etc. But the lie front and center and a quiet correction that not everyone is going to see indicates to me that it was probably intentional (since it seems she knew the correct information prior to this video coming out) in order to bolster her claims. She fully admitted it in her second video which is exactly how she said she would correct her wrong information in the comments of tHe first video. The first video was posted yesterday. 4 weeks ago she posted in her Instagram stories that the poster of the art took it down herself. Did she forget that when she filmed the first video?
|
|
pinklady
Drama Llama
Posts: 6,071
Nov 14, 2016 23:47:03 GMT
|
Post by pinklady on Jul 14, 2020 4:07:15 GMT
She fully admitted it in her second video which is exactly how she said she would correct her wrong information in the comments of tHe first video. The first video was posted yesterday. 4 weeks ago she posted in her Instagram stories that the poster of the art took it down herself. Did she forget that when she filmed the first video? Thank you for posting the entire screenshot. I couldn’t add it to my post above without cropping it to make the file size smaller. Yeah, there’s something off with the timeline of all this.
|
|
|
Post by mcjunkin on Jul 14, 2020 4:13:22 GMT
I will say again that the main vibe of that board is art centered, the techniques and the product. Not usually focused on theme or anything like that. No deep philosophical discussions, no current events, etc. Who knows, and I missed it, but the original poster may have not wanted to be responsible for a post that went off the rails so far away from the normal goings on there.
|
|
Deleted
Posts: 0
Nov 25, 2024 12:47:14 GMT
|
Post by Deleted on Jul 14, 2020 4:20:48 GMT
What did the card look like? Did they take it down because they didn't want to (in their opinion) get political? I don't understand why the card would be a problem, BLM is a good thing and I would think showing diversity would be an asset to Tim Holtz and company. They didn't take it down. The poster shared it, many group members replied saying it was political or whatever, the original poster removed it. Admins didn't take it down and didn't ask the OP to. The OP told Lara this but she apparently doesn't believe her. I didn't see it, that I know of. I usually scroll through my feed and probably scroll past 50 cards a day that I forget what they looked like. And there is the problem to me! That none of the admins nor Tim shut down the naysayers to defend this absolutely BEAUTIFUL and POIGNANT card.
|
|
|
Post by mom on Jul 14, 2020 4:37:02 GMT
Im watching the second video. I don't know what the truth is, but I also don't think I want to do business with either party for awhile.
I don't find Lara particularly professional -- especially after seeing her Instagram, but Tim's letter isn't sitting right with me either for some reason.
|
|
|
Post by mcjunkin on Jul 14, 2020 4:39:07 GMT
I won’t link the cardmaker’s instagram, but it is easy enough to find from the screen shots above. On the post with the card in question I cut and pasted the following question she got today, and her answer. Too lazy to screenshot, edit etc.
did you remove your own post of this from the TH FB group, or did an admin remove it? I'm disturbed by all that's being said about your art and I think it is beautiful! I just want the whole story! Sorry it's come to this!🤗
I removed the post on my own. No one asked, or even suggested I remove it. My personal experience with @tim_holtz @mariojrossi and @igirlzoe is that they support, encourage and promote everyone’s art.
ETA: based on pics of current projects she is still using TH products, buying the new releases and tagging him in her posts. She was picked for the Designer Spotlight at SSS per her post on July 3rd. And both TH and Zoe have liked and commented on her posts at least as far back as 2 months ago.
Kinda puts the racist thing to rest. Not the emails yet. But they must not have anything to do with this woman/artist. It does not look like to me she needed this loon fighting her battles for her. What in the world?? No wonder she got blocked.
|
|
|
Post by QueSeraSera on Jul 14, 2020 5:13:02 GMT
For me it doesn’t matter if the poster willingly took down the card. That is not the point! The point is why are the people whining it’s political (it’s not) allowed to post their views to the point they clearly make the poster feel pressured to cave and remove the card.
We can play semantics all day, but that does not sound “voluntary” to me. It sounds like peer pressure. Where were the moderators during all this? Clearly not stopping the anti-BLM posters from pushing their views on other group members. .
From watching the 2nd video, that appears to be Lara’s point.She is a horrible and incendiary communicator but on this point I get what she’s trying to say. I can’t believe I’m starting to agree with Lara who admittedly is looking increasingly unstable as this draws on.
|
|
Deleted
Posts: 0
Nov 25, 2024 12:47:14 GMT
|
Post by Deleted on Jul 14, 2020 5:22:04 GMT
For me it doesn’t matter if the poster willingly took down the card. That is not the point! The point is why are the people whining it’s political (it’s not) allowed to post their views to the point they clearly make the poster feel pressured to cave and remove the card. We can play semantics all day, but that does not sound “voluntary” to me. It sounds like peer pressure. Where were the moderators during all this? Clearly not stopping the anti-BLM posters from pushing their views on other group members. . From watching the 2nd video, that appears to be Lara’s point.She is a horrible and incendiary communicator but on this point I get what she’s trying to say. I can’t believe I’m starting to agree with Lara who admittedly is looking increasingly unstable as this draws on. Agreed. Tim mentions "solidarity" in his statement. Letting his commenters talk down that beautiful card, to the point where the poster removed it, instead of standing behind the art and sentiment is NOT standing in solidarity with #BLM. Not even a LITTLE BIT.
|
|
|
Post by gale w on Jul 14, 2020 5:25:19 GMT
For me it doesn’t matter if the poster willingly took down the card. That is not the point! The point is why are the people whining it’s political (it’s not) allowed to post their views to the point they clearly make the poster feel pressured to cave and remove the card. We can play semantics all day, but that does not sound “voluntary” to me. It sounds like peer pressure. Where were the moderators during all this? Clearly not stopping the anti-BLM posters from pushing their views on other group members. . From watching the 2nd video, that appears to be Lara’s point.She is a horrible and incendiary communicator but on this point I get what she’s trying to say. I can’t believe I’m starting to agree with Lara who admittedly is looking increasingly unstable as this draws on. I want to clarify that I did not see the post with the card (that i remember) and definitely did not see any of the replies. I don't know if people were saying it was political or anything else. Only that someone suggested that some comments may have made her want to take it down. I was just speculating based on some posts/replies by others (both on fb and instagram) and should have said that in my post. I've been in the group for quite a while and don't ever remember any kind of drama or controversy there.
|
|
|
Post by mcjunkin on Jul 14, 2020 5:26:30 GMT
For me it doesn’t matter if the poster willingly took down the card. That is not the point! The point is why are the people whining it’s political (it’s not) allowed to post their views to the point they clearly make the poster feel pressured to cave and remove the card. We can play semantics all day, but that does not sound “voluntary” to me. It sounds like peer pressure. Where were the moderators during all this? Clearly not stopping the anti-BLM posters from pushing their views on other group members. . From watching the 2nd video, that appears to be Lara’s point.She is a horrible and incendiary communicator but on this point I get what she’s trying to say. I can’t believe I’m starting to agree with Lara who admittedly is looking increasingly unstable as this draws on. Genuinely asking if anyone saw all this go down in the FB group in real time? Do we know which comments were deleted and which ones were left before the post was taken down? Is is it possible they were deleting anti-BLM posters and political whiners as well? To me, that would make a difference. Deleting any comments from either side that deviated from the normal course of the board. Don’t know if that was the case. Could be that there were just so many comments, and this Ink Road chick seems very persistent, that the original poster just wanted to avoid the cluster it was turning in to. I know I would not want this Lara to speak on my behalf, or use me or my artwork to make any of her points or further any of her causes
|
|
|
Post by mom on Jul 14, 2020 5:28:45 GMT
Here's my question ------
The card maker has been addressing taking down the card (apparently. I haven't looked for her online). If Tim (or Mario or Zoey) e-mailed her the 'bitter' comment or any rude comment, why isn't she talking about it now? Apparently people know who she is (I dont). She should be able to easily confirm or deny the emails. They were sent to her, yes?
|
|
|
Post by mcjunkin on Jul 14, 2020 5:31:36 GMT
For me it doesn’t matter if the poster willingly took down the card. That is not the point! The point is why are the people whining it’s political (it’s not) allowed to post their views to the point they clearly make the poster feel pressured to cave and remove the card. We can play semantics all day, but that does not sound “voluntary” to me. It sounds like peer pressure. Where were the moderators during all this? Clearly not stopping the anti-BLM posters from pushing their views on other group members. . From watching the 2nd video, that appears to be Lara’s point.She is a horrible and incendiary communicator but on this point I get what she’s trying to say. I can’t believe I’m starting to agree with Lara who admittedly is looking increasingly unstable as this draws on. Agreed. Tim mentions "solidarity" in his statement. Letting his commenters talk down that beautiful card, to the point where the poster removed it, instead of standing behind the art and sentiment is NOT standing in solidarity with #BLM. Not even a LITTLE BIT. But do we know that those comments were not being removed too? I have seen no one but Lara speak to that. Where are all the screenshots from the kerfuffle? Someone always has screenshots, LOL.
|
|
Deleted
Posts: 0
Nov 25, 2024 12:47:14 GMT
|
Post by Deleted on Jul 14, 2020 5:43:03 GMT
Here's my question ------ The card maker has been addressing taking down the card (apparently. I haven't looked for her online). If Tim (or Mario or Zoey) e-mailed her the 'bitter' comment or any rude comment, why isn't she talking about it now? Apparently people know who she is (I dont). She should be able to easily confirm or deny the emails. They were sent to her, yes? I don't believe the "bitter" comment had anything to do w/this current issue. It was dated 6/21. It was an email from someone who contacted Lara about Tim's shitty response to that emailer's message. I think that's what's making this confusing. Lara seems to be combining responses from several issues w/o clearly delineating what the order of communications were.
|
|
|
Post by mcjunkin on Jul 14, 2020 5:43:46 GMT
Here's my question ------ The card maker has been addressing taking down the card (apparently. I haven't looked for her online). If Tim (or Mario or Zoey) e-mailed her the 'bitter' comment or any rude comment, why isn't she talking about it now? Apparently people know who she is (I dont). She should be able to easily confirm or deny the emails. They were sent to her, yes? I don’t think so. I think someone else is also involved. Lara says “here is one of the emails I received from someone who is scared of both of you...”. The woman supposedly has been threatened for even speaking to Lara. That is the email she shows at the end about TH refusing to acknowledge the black craft community (words used in the email).
|
|
|
Post by mom on Jul 14, 2020 5:52:31 GMT
Here's my question ------ The card maker has been addressing taking down the card (apparently. I haven't looked for her online). If Tim (or Mario or Zoey) e-mailed her the 'bitter' comment or any rude comment, why isn't she talking about it now? Apparently people know who she is (I dont). She should be able to easily confirm or deny the emails. They were sent to her, yes? I don’t think so. I think someone else is also involved. Lara says “here is one of the emails I received from someone who is scared of both of you...”. The woman supposedly has been threatened for even speaking to Lara. That is the email she shows at the end about TH refusing to acknowledge the black craft community (words used in the email). Ahh ok. I missed that. All of this just makes my brain hurt.
|
|
|
Post by mcjunkin on Jul 14, 2020 6:07:01 GMT
We do not see header for the email she was forwarded from the scared person. No date. No subject.
Tim’s bitter response is onJune 21. We see the header now, but the subject is blotted out. (Why?) But you can see it says something...Tim’s Design Team.
Mario’s email header has the date of July 7 with the subject of TROLL.
Card in question was posted on Insta on May 31. Not sure when it was put on the FB page.
Lara’a timeline makes no sense. Looks like creatively editing the email convos.
Still does not explain Mario’s out of character dumb f comment, but not as cut and dry as Lara would make it seem. And it was not to Lara, so the threat to not work was not aimed at her stamp company, right?
|
|
|
Post by QueSeraSera on Jul 14, 2020 6:31:14 GMT
We do not see header for the email she was forwarded from the scared person. No date. No subject. Tim’s bitter response is onJune 21. We see the header now, but the subject is blotted out. (Why?) But you can see it says something...Tim’s Design Team. Mario’s email header has the date of July 7 with the subject of TROLL. Card in question was posted on Insta on May 31. Not sure when it was put on the FB page. Lara’a timeline makes no sense. Looks like creatively editing the email convos. Still does not explain Mario’s out of character dumb f comment, but not as cut and dry as Lara would make it seem. And it was not to Lara, so the threat to not work was not aimed at her stamp company, right? You make very good points. True a lot does appear to be coming from Lara. I’m going back to the quiet sidelines now. 😬
|
|
|
Post by fashionista on Jul 14, 2020 6:42:46 GMT
Lara sounds like she’s doing this for CLOUT not for BLM.
|
|
flatfish
Full Member
Posts: 158
May 26, 2019 3:17:27 GMT
|
Post by flatfish on Jul 14, 2020 7:24:20 GMT
I work for a doctor’s office and anything can be altered or “doctored” now days. Reason a pharmacy or online companies will call our office to verify a prescription. So reading photos of text messages or emails have to be taken with a grain of salt.
|
|
|
Post by papercrafteradvocate on Jul 14, 2020 9:07:04 GMT
What did the card look like? Did they take it down because they didn't want to (in their opinion) get political? I don't understand why the card would be a problem, BLM is a good thing and I would think showing diversity would be an asset to Tim Holtz and company. The person who posted the card also was the one who took it down in her own volition—TH, M, & Z did not ask her to ir pressure yet yo, and she has since stated that she didn’t feel pressured to remove it—she just did.
|
|
|
Post by papercrafteradvocate on Jul 14, 2020 9:15:54 GMT
They’ve stated that the emails are doctored. Agreed. What he didn’t say was that they were 100% not his words. In my opinion, he is using that “Doctored” terminology because those are his and Mario’s words taken out of context, meaning he sent them as a response to something else, not this George Floyd card that the artist took down from the FB group. Maybe. But I cannot believe that they used the language/terminology as posted—it does not as kind at all like something he’d do or his brand would send out—in this day of social media especially. Not to mention I find it absolutely ridiculous that TH would have threatened anyone with affiliates—SSS a completely independent company (rumor has it now that SSS didn’t reorder her products prior to all this happening). I find it a stretch that any brand would threaten that—in writing—and the supposed email being sent to the card maker—who had nothing to gain/do with that. The entire wording of the email is like a jr high mean girls thing, not an email from a long standing business. And because TH actions have been opposite of what the ugly (doctored) messages state. They did not ditch Zoe as the email stated. My spidey senses are leaning towards this is retaliation on Lara’s part because SSS did not want to reorder her products (her newest release wasn’t that good/was meh). Also, given that she has in her preorder BLM stamps (where she’s clearly used artwork that wasn’t original) she could be drawing attention so people check out her stamps.
|
|
|
Post by papercrafteradvocate on Jul 14, 2020 9:20:57 GMT
They’ve stated that the emails are doctored. I don’t believe he is racist. I also don’t like people throwing the race card. We have BIG issues in our Nation and racism IS ONE of them. Something did happen. Why block people and why NOT allow them to post comments. I’m still VERY confused. 🥴 She accused/labeled him of being racist (as has the OP of this thread) by pulling it out of thin air. TH, M, & Z never did or said anything that constitutes being racist (or even privilege). This Lara just attached that label to him because members of a group they are admins of made comments about another card maker posting a card honoring George Floyd, so the card maker deleted it herself. Subsequently, when you delete your own post in Facebook, all the comments that are from the list also get deleted. So Lara is claiming that they deleted them trying to silence people. Lara sounds crazy.
|
|
|
Post by papercrafteradvocate on Jul 14, 2020 9:21:59 GMT
She fully admitted it in her second video which is exactly how she said she would correct her wrong information in the comments of tHe first video. The first video was posted yesterday. 4 weeks ago she posted in her Instagram stories that the poster of the art took it down herself. Did she forget that when she filmed the first video? She’s rewriting the narrative...🙄🙄🙄
|
|