peggs
Shy Member
Posts: 15
Feb 14, 2018 17:55:24 GMT
|
Post by peggs on Sept 30, 2020 14:49:09 GMT
I'm looking to buy a full set of inks - most likely mini size. I have Hero Arts inks that I use primarily right now (and tons of varying random inks) but would love a full set. Especially colors with various shades so I can use layering stamps. Not sure if I need coordinating cardstock. Is that important to have?
So I'm thinking of:
Pinkfresh Studio Altenew Catherine Pooler The Stamp Market Concord & 9th
Anyone use the above brands and feel strongly for one brand versus another?
|
|
camcas
Pearl Clutcher
Posts: 4,156
Jun 26, 2014 3:41:19 GMT
|
Post by camcas on Oct 1, 2020 10:15:46 GMT
I have some Altenew and some hero arts minis- they are ok. I just invested in a full set of pinkfresh minis because I love love their colours. I seem to buy most of their releases as I love their aesthetic So then it seemed “sensible” to invest in their inks!!! They just arrived today so I haven’t really had time to play but the colours are great and I like the fact they are packed in sets of 4 from each colour family so they will work well with layering stamps. I particularly like the blues .
|
|
|
Post by scrappinheather on Oct 1, 2020 11:33:46 GMT
I really like ink that matches paper too so if your choices I would probably go with concord and 9th. I have the altenew minus and love them for flower layers but they feel a bit on the dry side. I still love the colors though. I have most of the Catherine pooler minis and I love how juicy they are but I mainly use them for sentiments. You can’t press down with them as they are too juicy. I ended up with a full set of minis with a few regular from taylored expressions. I love that the cardstock and envelopes to match are inexpensive. However, not sure if I love the formulation so I’m not sure I’m much help :-)
|
|
|
Post by joblackford on Oct 1, 2020 14:00:34 GMT
I follow a couple of people who primarily use the Catherine Pooler inks and they seem very versatile and the colors are great (for my tastes). Ardyth Percy-Robb on YouTube uses them for swiping, pouncing through stencils, ink blending, spritzes water or shimmer spray on them. They also work really well with bigger solid stamps because they are very juicy (Justine Hovey has videos about that). I’m in the process of collecting the minis. I like that they’re not cubes, which I find awkwardly small.
Depending on how you use inks they might be a good fit. Ardyth doesn’t worry about matching cardstock - she just blends or swipes ink direct to white cardstock to create a matching piece/frame.
She also demonstrated blending them together to create secondary and tertiary colors. I think she also showed how you can use them for layering stamps - if I’m remembering correctly you can overstamp and get a darker tone without needing another ink pad. I’d have to check that to be certain, but I think that’s right. I don’t use layering stamps much so that’s less important to me, but nice if it does work that way.
|
|
mxgirl71
Shy Member
Posts: 17
Apr 25, 2019 20:49:41 GMT
|
Post by mxgirl71 on Oct 1, 2020 17:36:13 GMT
Gina K. and My Favorite Things also have great inks. And both have coordinating cardstock if you decide to go that route. Gina K also has matching envelopes.
|
|
lindas
Pearl Clutcher
Posts: 4,306
Jun 26, 2014 5:46:37 GMT
|
Post by lindas on Oct 1, 2020 18:17:14 GMT
I have Concord & 9th and Altenew. The Altenew do seem a bit dry but are good for layering stamps. I like the Concord & 9th for stamping but there aren’t enough color variations to make them good for layering. I also have a few GinaK minis which I really like.
|
|
JustTricia
Pearl Clutcher
Posts: 2,850
Location: Indianapolis
Jul 2, 2014 17:12:39 GMT
|
Post by JustTricia on Oct 2, 2020 20:10:33 GMT
I went with Altenew as I wanted them for layering and I was having difficulty figuring out which inks layered well together. Altenew idiot-proofed it for me. I can understand why people say they are drier but honesty never thought about it until reading these comments here.
I do have a few Gina K and love them as well.
I have four full size Catherine Pooler inks. I do not like using them at all. They layer nicely; the colors are great; but they are SOOOO juicy I feel like I’m wasting a bunch of ink on the edges of my block, all over the stamp platform, and my fingers. I’m sure the minis would be better as there would be less excess pad but I like the other inks I have enough to not need to branch out.
|
|
|
Post by mrsp on Oct 2, 2020 23:53:42 GMT
I have Gina K, The Stamp Market and the Concord & 9th inks. I use them all—the stamp market and Concord &9th inks are foam, similar to the Catherine Pooler inks but I think the CP inks have thicker foam. There was a bit of a learning curve for me with the foam inks, but it wasn’t too hard for me to get used to using them.
|
|
|
Post by marg on Oct 3, 2020 20:48:15 GMT
I own The Stamp Market inks - the original batch of colours - and like the inks a lot but the colour palette is limited.
I have a bunch of Catherine Pooler mini inks and they are great, very juicy as another commenter said. I do think her foam is thicker, too.
I like having a full palette of a company's inks, too. I really want the Concord & 9th, too. Ugh, I'm an addict.
|
|
|
Post by curiouscrafter on Oct 3, 2020 21:05:05 GMT
I have the full set of concord/9th with the paper packs to match - and LOVE THEM! The colors are so vibrant, although not enough in one color family to do mono-chromatic stamping...
Which is why I just bought the full set of PinkFresh. They don't have matching paper though. I have only used the blue set so far (as I literally just got them), but so far, they are working great for me.
|
|
|
Post by curiouscrafter on Oct 3, 2020 21:06:47 GMT
Also - I bought both full sets on sale, so it didn't hit the pocketbook quite as hard. Unless you are in a hurry, I would wait for a sale and buy the bundle.
|
|
|
Post by scrapbookmomof4 on Oct 4, 2020 15:11:54 GMT
I like Concord and 9th ink pads because they have matching card stock but the card stock is a little thin. I also like Altenew because they have a lot of colors. I think they are a hybrid pad. I also like Gina K. ink. Her card stock matches and it's heavier and she also has envelopes to match. I watched her live yesterday and she has a coupon code for 15% off ink. The code is liveink15 and I finished up my collection last night. There is so many to choose from.
|
|
Deleted
Posts: 0
Nov 24, 2024 21:48:23 GMT
|
Post by Deleted on Oct 6, 2020 4:22:29 GMT
I don't have any from Pinkfresh Studio or The Stamp Market, so I can't speak to either of those. I do have full sets of the Catherine Pooler full size ink pads (disclosure: I got most of them free when I was part of her design team for a couple of years) and the full set of Concord & 9th full size ink pads. I have about 75% of the Altenew inks in the cube size. CPD
- Pro: Her ink pads are super juicy and stamp beautifully!
- Pro: I prefer firm foam ink pads over linen/felt and that's what hers are.
- Pro: Her inks do not transfer when switching between colors. For example, you could stamp something with one of her purple inks, give the stamp a quick clean then ink up and stamp something with one of her yellow inks. There will be no transfer or pulling up of the purple ink from the stamp into the yellow ink which isn't always the case with some other brands of ink.
- Con: The one big down side for me was always the lack of coordinating cardstock. I would do the swiping and ink blending like Ardyth when we were on the DT together because that's what we had to do if we wanted coordinating cardstock. Since resigning from the DT, I just don't want to have to constantly be inking up white cardstock when I want to add a color layer.
- Con: I'm not a fan of the actual form factor of her ink pad case. They just feel very light weight compared to other brands on the market. I also seem to get ink all over them no matter what I do.
- Con: Her Midnight (archival black) ink pad is SUPER staining. I've used archival black from other companies that stain slightly, but hers stains COMPLETELY. I've yet to find any cleaner that will remove her Midnight ink from a photopolymer stamp.
C&9- Pro: Super juicy and stamp beautifully!
- Pro: Firm foam ink pad (my preferred style)
- Pro: Color labels are available for marking the ends of the case making it easy to find the color your want quickly.
- Pro: High quality solid core coordinating cardstock is available.
- Con: Since they only introduced their ink line a few months ago, they have a more limited selection of colors available compared to the other brands. I have no doubt they will likely expand the range in the future, but for now, there are only 22 colors available. For someone who isn't interested in a vast selection of ink colors, this could easily be a Pro for them.
Altenew- Pro: Wide range of gorgeous color options
- Pro: "Families" of four inks are available which is awesome for using with layering stamp sets
- Pro: They offer watercolor sets and alcohol markers to match their inks (note: only select colors, not the full line)
- Con: Linen ink pad (not my preferred firm foam style)
- Con: They do not have coordinating cardstock for their full line of ink colors
As a final note, if you've ever used Stampin' Up ink pads, CPD and C&9 ink pads are very similar in style to the SU ink pads. With any of the firm foam ink pads, you just need to give the stamp a very gentle tap onto the ink pad. You don't need to push down hard or twist the stamp on the ink pad like you would do with a linen or felt ink pad.
Of the three sets I own that you asked about, my preference would probably be the Concord & 9th inks even though they have a more limited palette right now. They are the style of ink pad I prefer and have the coordinating cardstock available. If you don't care about having coordinating cardstock, you definitely can't go wrong with the CPD inks and she has more than double the colors available from C&9.
|
|
|
Post by curiouscrafter on Oct 6, 2020 15:51:04 GMT
I like Concord and 9th ink pads because they have matching card stock but the card stock is a little thin. I also like Altenew because they have a lot of colors. I think they are a hybrid pad. I also like Gina K. ink. Her card stock matches and it's heavier and she also has envelopes to match. I watched her live yesterday and she has a coupon code for 15% off ink. The code is liveink15 and I finished up my collection last night. There is so many to choose from. This is true of Concord/9th cardstock, but it’s what I like about it as I use it as card fronts and dies, not the cards itself, so it doesn’t add a ton of bulk.
|
|
Deleted
Posts: 0
Nov 24, 2024 21:48:23 GMT
|
Post by Deleted on Oct 6, 2020 21:26:51 GMT
This is true of Concord/9th cardstock, but it’s what I like about it as I use it as card fronts and dies, not the cards itself, so it doesn’t add a ton of bulk. Same here! I almost always use Neenah 110# for my card base, so I only use colored cardstock for layers or for die cutting and prefer the 80# weight cardstock for that.
|
|
Deleted
Posts: 0
Nov 24, 2024 21:48:23 GMT
|
Post by Deleted on Oct 7, 2020 5:59:01 GMT
Most of the inks are made by the same manufaturer so I go by color not brand. There are a few brands I prefer over others however. For layering stamps I prefer Altenew. I have a lot of MFT inks, Lawn Fawn inks, etc. I don't care for catherine pooler inks because they are too juicy and make a mess for me but i do like her colors. I do have a list of my fave inks here if you are interested: kathleendriggers.com/kats-favorite-inks-inking-tools-products/
|
|
peggs
Shy Member
Posts: 15
Feb 14, 2018 17:55:24 GMT
|
Post by peggs on Oct 10, 2020 17:00:14 GMT
Thanks all for your responses - I think this is making it harder for me to decide! I really appreciate your opinions. I think I may need to invest in more than one brand.
|
|
peggs
Shy Member
Posts: 15
Feb 14, 2018 17:55:24 GMT
|
Post by peggs on Oct 10, 2020 17:00:56 GMT
Most of the inks are made by the same manufaturer so I go by color not brand. There are a few brands I prefer over others however. For layering stamps I prefer Altenew. I have a lot of MFT inks, Lawn Fawn inks, etc. I don't care for catherine pooler inks because they are too juicy and make a mess for me but i do like her colors. I do have a list of my fave inks here if you are interested: kathleendriggers.com/kats-favorite-inks-inking-tools-products/Oh just reading your post now - soooo thorough and helpful!
|
|
peggs
Shy Member
Posts: 15
Feb 14, 2018 17:55:24 GMT
|
Post by peggs on Oct 10, 2020 17:02:56 GMT
This is true of Concord/9th cardstock, but it’s what I like about it as I use it as card fronts and dies, not the cards itself, so it doesn’t add a ton of bulk. Same here! I almost always use Neenah 110# for my card base, so I only use colored cardstock for layers or for die cutting and prefer the 80# weight cardstock for that. When I started stamping years ago I did use Neenah 110# but felt it was heavy for stamping on. I need to see how the 80# is because that would be perfect for stamping.
|
|
Deleted
Posts: 0
Nov 24, 2024 21:48:23 GMT
|
Post by Deleted on Oct 10, 2020 17:11:31 GMT
When I started stamping years ago I did use Neenah 110# but felt it was heavy for stamping on. I need to see how the 80# is because that would be perfect for stamping. I know some crafters using the 110# for everything, but I only use it for card bases or for stacking die cuts. For stamping and such, I use the 80# version. I buy each by the ream on Amazon.
|
|