|
Wwyd?
Dec 11, 2022 3:01:30 GMT
Post by miranda on Dec 11, 2022 3:01:30 GMT
Curious what you would do in this situation. I have a friend whose adult child in their 30's gives gifts to one parent, but not the other. By this I mean birthday and mother/father day; one of the parents is ignored on these occasions. Christmas they generally give this particular parent a token gift.
The parents are married, raised the kids together, etc. There's no real obvious falling out with one of the parents; mainly your typical one was a fun parent, the other more strict. The gift thing seems like it isn't something new. If you were one of the people in the situation would you say something to the "kid"? I waver back and forth in my thinking on this so I figured maybe i'd see what others think.
Editing to add: Sorry if I was confusing, I'm curious if either the mother or father should address the gift issue (honestly there's a lot more going on than that, it's just holiday time so i'm thinking of it.) Kid tends to make plans, ask for money only through one parent also. I don't know the rest of the family well so I would never say anything.
|
|
|
Post by pantsonfire on Dec 11, 2022 3:06:34 GMT
Gift are not to be expected. So no, I would not say anything.
|
|
|
Post by pantsonfire on Dec 11, 2022 3:08:33 GMT
Also flip the script a bit...
Maybe the adult could is trying to get approval from the parent they buy gifts for.
Also Maybe the one parent said no need to buy me gifts. Save your money.
|
|
|
Post by CardBoxer on Dec 11, 2022 3:10:11 GMT
If I was the one getting the bigger gift I’d say something. Passive aggression isn’t okay, not that I’d say that.
|
|
|
Post by Zee on Dec 11, 2022 3:14:43 GMT
If it's the child of a friend, as you posted, it's not your place or your business to say something.
|
|
|
Post by pjaye on Dec 11, 2022 3:39:03 GMT
Whether it's a friend or you, I think the parent already knows the real reason. At some point the parent has not been a gracious acceptor of a gift from their child...likely when they were still an actual child. They were rude, or dismissive or ungrateful, and they hurt their child deeply to the point where the child is no longer going to put themselves through that again. Children in general love to give their parents gifts, to cause that to breakdown with one parent - means it is that parent's fault, and that parent needs to apologise for whatever happened or find another way to make amends.
The conversation needs to start with, please tell me what I did wrong that you no longer buy me gifts so that I can try to make it up to you. Not "why don't YOU buy me anything?"
|
|
|
Post by voltagain on Dec 11, 2022 7:12:25 GMT
Curious what you would do in this situation. I have a friend whose adult child in their 30's gives gifts to one parent, but not the other. By this I mean birthday and mother/father day; one of the parents is ignored on these occasions. Christmas they generally give this particular parent a token gift. The parents are married, raised the kids together, etc. There's no real obvious falling out with one of the parents; mainly your typical one was a fun parent, the other more strict. The gift thing seems like it isn't something new. If you were one of the people in the situation would you say something to the "kid"? I waver back and forth in my thinking on this so I figured maybe i'd see what others think. If I am not the mother, father, or adultkid then I have NO say. This manifestation of the relationship is about the relationship between "child" and each parent. There is a life time history between the child and each parent. You aren't going to change the way the adultchild now related to the years/decades of treatment. My guess is at some point one parent told the child they were a trerrible gift giver, or was the parent to gift siblings differently with this one being the one to get the short end of the stick.
|
|
Deleted
Posts: 0
Aug 18, 2025 21:35:24 GMT
|
Post by Deleted on Dec 11, 2022 12:57:07 GMT
I wouldn't say anything.
Unless your friend told you the whole story, you don't know the whole story. I no longer buy gifts for my dad or siblings but we buy gifts DH's Mom and siblings because they won't end the stupid gift exchange.
My kids don't buy us gifts. I've told them not to as they're young and broke. I'm not insulted.
|
|
Deleted
Posts: 0
Aug 18, 2025 21:35:24 GMT
|
Wwyd?
Dec 11, 2022 13:00:00 GMT
Post by Deleted on Dec 11, 2022 13:00:00 GMT
Probly not enough information for us here. Maybe it’s all the info you have — in which case I wonder why you’d care enough to post about it.
|
|
|
Post by littlemama on Dec 11, 2022 13:11:36 GMT
The OP did NOT say that she was going to say anything. She asked, if you were one of the parents in the situation, would you say something.
If I were the parent receiving the nicer gift and I truly did not know why this was happening, I might try to find out from my child if there was something I didn't know.
|
|
peabay
Prolific Pea
 
Posts: 9,975
Jun 25, 2014 19:50:41 GMT
|
Wwyd?
Dec 11, 2022 13:16:25 GMT
Post by peabay on Dec 11, 2022 13:16:25 GMT
How does the parent feel about that? I wouldn't intervene if they aren't bothered by it.
|
|
|
Post by Rainy_Day_Woman on Dec 11, 2022 13:47:33 GMT
I kind of do this with my parents. My dad is ridiculously hard to buy for, most of his hobbies are very specific and he buys everything he wants. Anything he might want that he wouldn't immediately buy himself is probably out of price range for me.
I share more hobbies with my mom, so I have better ideas for gifts, and she has more varied interests. It definitely looks like I buy thoughtful, elaborate and more interesting gifts for my mom, and my Dad gets a token gift card to his local diner.
That said, as far as I know, no one is bothered by it. I wish I could pull off a cool gift for my Dad, but I am pretty resigned at this point.
|
|
|
Post by miranda on Dec 11, 2022 14:13:26 GMT
Whether it's a friend or you, I think the parent already knows the real reason. At some point the parent has not been a gracious acceptor of a gift from their child...likely when they were still an actual child. They were rude, or dismissive or ungrateful, and they hurt their child deeply to the point where the child is no longer going to put themselves through that again. Children in general love to give their parents gifts, to cause that to breakdown with one parent - means it is that parent's fault, and that parent needs to apologise for whatever happened or find another way to make amends. The conversation needs to start with, please tell me what I did wrong that you no longer buy me gifts so that I can try to make it up to you. Not "why don't YOU buy me anything?" I truly don't think this has to do with any past gift exchange, but you're correct there should be a conversation between the parties involved as to what has made the situation what it is and how it might be better resolved (and by that I mean the relationship in general.) The OP did NOT say that she was going to say anything. She asked, if you were one of the parents in the situation, would you say something. If I were the parent receiving the nicer gift and I truly did not know why this was happening, I might try to find out from my child if there was something I didn't know. This was my thought as well if I were the parent receiving the nicer gift or having my birthday acknowledged while the other parent was ignored i'd probably have a conversation about it in private to see why it was happening. Honestly after reading responses I realize how dysfunctional it all is that no one bothers to sit down and have a conversation about it.
|
|
anaterra
Pearl Clutcher
Posts: 4,282
Location: Texas
Jun 29, 2014 3:04:02 GMT
|
Wwyd?
Dec 11, 2022 15:07:05 GMT
via mobile
Post by anaterra on Dec 11, 2022 15:07:05 GMT
This could be my dh n mil... his parents are in their 90s.. they dont drive... live in a small country town... we take them to the city to go to dr or grocery shop...
My fil just wants scrach off tickets... he loves them n doesn't have a lot of disposable income... so that's what we get him... for every holiday...
My mil.... woahhh she is not a gracious reciever... doesn't want live plants (cuz she will kill them) no flowers because they aggravate her nose... same with candles, scentsy and other smelly things... no to throw blankets or robes or house shoes...she likes what she has... no jewelry she only wears her wedding ring, doesnt like necklaces and never had her ears pierced... we got her all new bath towel sets, didnt like them cuz they were to fluffy.. even though hers are really old... got her some new dry food containers because the Tupperware was hard for her to open now... these are the clear ones you pop the center... ehhh they are ok... got her a digital frame with tons of different pictures already on it... to high tech for her (we loaded it before giving it).. nothing food... because none of it is as good as she makes... even if i take something that i baked or cooked.. she has fil rate it vs hers... insane lol... she really is impossible to buy for... and she gets her feelings hurt if she doesn't get a gift... but she is not pleased with anything...
When i ask her what she wants.. she says dont get me anything... so i don't but i feel bad because i love her and i don't want to hurt her feelings... but blahhh its a horrible cycle
|
|
Rhondito
Pearl Clutcher
MississipPea
Posts: 4,950
Jun 25, 2014 19:33:19 GMT
|
Post by Rhondito on Dec 11, 2022 15:19:58 GMT
Is this just you wondering what's going on, or do you know for sure it's a mystery for the parents?
|
|
|
Wwyd?
Dec 11, 2022 15:32:28 GMT
via mobile
Post by ~summer~ on Dec 11, 2022 15:32:28 GMT
No I would not say something to a person in their 30s.
Do both parents give gifts to the adult child, or only one?
|
|
|
Post by maryland on Dec 11, 2022 16:37:27 GMT
Maybe the parent that doesn't get a gift has told the kids that they don't need anything and would prefer the kids saved their money or maybe gave a donation to a charity of the parent's choice.
My husband got me a monthly donation to the local animal shelter because I really don't need anything and I love animals! I have asked my kids to instead of spending money on a gift for me, to instead help me put my pictures on my hard drive and help me order pictures. I never get that though, haha! They would rather buy me something then have to explain tech stuff to me!
|
|
|
Post by crazy4scraps on Dec 11, 2022 16:41:46 GMT
I kind of do this with my parents. My dad is ridiculously hard to buy for, most of his hobbies are very specific and he buys everything he wants. Anything he might want that he wouldn't immediately buy himself is probably out of price range for me. I share more hobbies with my mom, so I have better ideas for gifts, and she has more varied interests. It definitely looks like I buy thoughtful, elaborate and more interesting gifts for my mom, and my Dad gets a token gift card to his local diner. That said, as far as I know, no one is bothered by it. I wish I could pull off a cool gift for my Dad, but I am pretty resigned at this point. My kid could write this. My DH buys whatever he wants when he feels like it so when traditional gift giving situations arise there is nothing affordable left to get him. I’m the much easier person to shop for because my likes are varied, I’m happy with small/inexpensive but thoughtful things, and I don’t typically buy everything I want when I want even though I generally could. I just don’t. So it would be very easy for my kid to find a pile of fun presents for me but DH would end up getting socks or candy IYKWIM. It doesn’t mean she loves one or the other more or less. Some people are just impossible to shop for especially for someone with limited funds.
|
|
FuzzyMutt
Pearl Clutcher
Posts: 2,644
Mar 17, 2017 13:55:57 GMT
|
Wwyd?
Dec 11, 2022 16:51:37 GMT
via mobile
msliz likes this
Post by FuzzyMutt on Dec 11, 2022 16:51:37 GMT
I haven’t read all the responses, but the ones I did read, there is something that I feel may not have been thought of.
My parents raised us together, and there are no hard feelings or underlying tea. But if someone close enough to “know” about the situation, but not close enough to know why were to observe, I’m a lot like this with my parents. Why?
Over the years, my parents were single income (dads) but mom carved pretty much all gifts, Christmas fund for gifts etc out of her grocery allotment. To be fair, money was tight for a lot of those years, but we had groceries and that may be the only place fat could be carved.
Since those years, they both have plenty of pocket money. If they want something, they buy it. But there’s a difference. For mom, it’s blowing $20 at the dollar store. For dad, if he needs new hunting boots or wants them, it’s the $300 dollar boots. Mom buys $12 shoes at Walmart (she could buy anything she wants. Dad doesn’t care.) Dad is very specific in his wants and when he wants it, he buys it. Period. I’ve tried for so many years to buy him very very nice gifts (he buys blue and black checked wool shirts…. I have bought from the same stores, up branded, done all I can to buy what he likes, he never wears or uses anything. At all. This is the same observation for my siblings as well. It very much seems like “using the good China mentality in some sort of way.
Same with mom. If I went out and bought her nice, supportive, well made shoes, in the style she likes, she’d never touch them. I’ve tried giving gift cards to Macy’s or something so she could pick something out, they literally never get used!
Buying for them is so frustrating. Years ago I figured something out that worked for my mom… it no longer works. So we are back to the hoarding of gifts (hoarding is a whole other story.)
I would love love love to just not exchange, but the siblings are not on board. Anyway, back to topic. Dad is a hunter and gun collector. He has one very specific local store that he likes. I usually do a relatively small credit or apply money if he has something on layaway/pre release.)
Mom? Last year she got a new iPad. A couple years ago, a new couch and lift chair. I’ve purchased computers, and had the carpet replaced in the living room.
The difference is that dad treats himself (nothing wrong with that!) and is very very specific. Mom will put up with something that really needs to be retired, wayyy too long and never treats herself. But usually, it’s something big. Somewhat unnecessary. Also, it’s usually something dad doesn’t care about.
I don’t dislike my dad, I don’t love my mom more. It just makes no sense to buy dad more crap to add to the pile. Conversely, when mom’s life (unfortunately) centers on the internet, and photos of the family, I want her to have a nice computer. I also want her to be comfortable in her living room.
My siblings know this, because for a lot of years we commiserated about buying for dad. Other people nebbing in what gifts I give may not understand.
|
|
|
Post by SockMonkey on Dec 11, 2022 18:27:47 GMT
I feel like there's a lot of missing context but the fact that it keeps happening and nobody is addressing it...? They have some communication issues and probably other stuff going on. I'm guessing gifts are the least of their problems.
|
|
Gem Girl
Pearl Clutcher
......
Posts: 2,686
Jun 29, 2014 19:29:52 GMT
|
Post by Gem Girl on Dec 11, 2022 20:35:44 GMT
I wouldn't say anything. Unless your friend told you the whole story, you don't know the whole story. I no longer buy gifts for my dad or siblings but we buy gifts DH's Mom and siblings because they won't end the stupid gift exchange. My kids don't buy us gifts. I've told them not to as they're young and broke. I'm not insulted. Even then, you'd only know 1 side of the story.
|
|
Gem Girl
Pearl Clutcher
......
Posts: 2,686
Jun 29, 2014 19:29:52 GMT
|
Post by Gem Girl on Dec 11, 2022 20:38:13 GMT
My mil.... woahhh she is not a gracious reciever... ... she really is impossible to buy for... and she gets her feelings hurt if she doesn't get a gift... but she is not pleased with anything... When i ask her what she wants.. she says dont get me anything... so i don't but i feel bad because i love her and i don't want to hurt her feelings... but blahhh its a horrible cycle Malignant narcissists are pretty good at setting up this no-win scenario. Just saying I've seen this from them, not that it explains your situation. Either way, good luck. It sucks the fun right out of gift giving.
|
|
gina
Pearl Clutcher
Posts: 3,461
Jun 26, 2014 1:59:16 GMT
|
Wwyd?
Dec 12, 2022 0:53:21 GMT
Post by gina on Dec 12, 2022 0:53:21 GMT
No, I would never ask one of my children why they weren't buying me a gift.
|
|
|
Post by mom on Dec 12, 2022 1:20:26 GMT
Whether it's a friend or you, I think the parent already knows the real reason.At some point the parent has not been a gracious acceptor of a gift from their child...likely when they were still an actual child. They were rude, or dismissive or ungrateful, and they hurt their child deeply to the point where the child is no longer going to put themselves through that again. Children in general love to give their parents gifts, to cause that to breakdown with one parent - means it is that parent's fault, and that parent needs to apologise for whatever happened or find another way to make amends. The conversation needs to start with, please tell me what I did wrong that you no longer buy me gifts so that I can try to make it up to you. Not "why don't YOU buy me anything?" I agree. Perhaps the parent doesn't realize that something in the past happened, but for this to be an on going issue (vs. a 'one sucky year' experience) there has to be a reason. I'd bet communication is a big issue in this family as well. But to answer your question, what would I do? Unless this is specifically about you and you just dont want to admit it, then I would do nothing. This is between the adult child and the parent.
|
|
|
Wwyd?
Dec 12, 2022 2:22:00 GMT
Post by bc2ca on Dec 12, 2022 2:22:00 GMT
I'm curious if either the mother or father should address the gift issue (honestly there's a lot more going on than that, it's just holiday time so i'm thinking of it.) Kid tends to make plans, ask for money only through one parent also. I don't think they should necessarily do anything, but if one of my kids was changing the way they normally behaved toward their dad (or I) and I didn't know what was going on, I would ask if they wanted to talk about it. FWIW, I spent a lot more time and money finding my mom fun and unique gifts over the years because dad would get annoyed AF if we didn't stick to his very specific list. Exciting things like socks, gardening gloves, spade, etc. I learned the difference between a spade and shovel that year. MIL was beside herself when she found out I was giving him gardening gloves and spent weeks trying to convince me dad was being polite with his frugal list and really wanted to be spoiled. Mom was always the go-to to make plans or ask any favors.
|
|
|
Post by miranda on Dec 12, 2022 3:00:02 GMT
No I would not say something to a person in their 30s. Do both parents give gifts to the adult child, or only one? Yes gifts to the kid on holidays and birthday are given from both parents as a couple. Like Mom & Dad buy kid xyz for his birthday from mom & dad Maybe the parent that doesn't get a gift has told the kids that they don't need anything and would prefer the kids saved their money or maybe gave a donation to a charity of the parent's choice. My husband got me a monthly donation to the local animal shelter because I really don't need anything and I love animals! I have asked my kids to instead of spending money on a gift for me, to instead help me put my pictures on my hard drive and help me order pictures. I never get that though, haha! They would rather buy me something then have to explain tech stuff to me! The parent not getting the gift is hurt by the kids actions so no they haven't said to not buy them a gift. On one parents birthday the kid buys a nice gift, the other he ignores the occasion. Same with mothers/fathers day. So on the basis that one parent is hurt, I was curious if as the other parent you'd say something? Honestly if it were me and I was receiving the gift, I might just ask kid to save his money and not gift me as a way to diffuse the situation if I couldn't have a better conversation about it. It isn't a new issue and as everyone has said there has to be more issues within the family.
|
|
|
Post by Bridget in MD on Dec 12, 2022 13:30:16 GMT
No I would not say something to a person in their 30s. Do both parents give gifts to the adult child, or only one? Yes gifts to the kid on holidays and birthday are given from both parents as a couple. Like Mom & Dad buy kid xyz for his birthday from mom & dad Maybe the parent that doesn't get a gift has told the kids that they don't need anything and would prefer the kids saved their money or maybe gave a donation to a charity of the parent's choice. My husband got me a monthly donation to the local animal shelter because I really don't need anything and I love animals! I have asked my kids to instead of spending money on a gift for me, to instead help me put my pictures on my hard drive and help me order pictures. I never get that though, haha! They would rather buy me something then have to explain tech stuff to me! The parent not getting the gift is hurt by the kids actions so no they haven't said to not buy them a gift. On one parents birthday the kid buys a nice gift, the other he ignores the occasion. Same with mothers/fathers day. So on the basis that one parent is hurt, I was curious if as the other parent you'd say something? Honestly if it were me and I was receiving the gift, I might just ask kid to save his money and not gift me as a way to diffuse the situation if I couldn't have a better conversation about it. It isn't a new issue and as everyone has said there has to be more issues within the family. If I was getting gifts and DH, the father of my kids, was not, I would ask my kids what is going on. Esp if it has been a pattern. Bc this is blatant. I would probably also make the decision to say "you don't need to get me a gift either". Depending on the answer, I may reconsider the gifts to the adult child I gave as well. I don't want to be complacent in some hurtful game (ie, the kid is making a point to gifting to me but not dad).
|
|
|
Post by Embri on Dec 12, 2022 13:51:43 GMT
When i ask her what she wants.. she says dont get me anything... so i don't but i feel bad because i love her and i don't want to hurt her feelings... but blahhh its a horrible cycle Experiences?
Harder in a post-Covid world, but many older folks don't want extra things to clutter up their homes. They're trying to downsize, not get more stuff. Offering them services sometimes is the answer, like landscaping, housekeeping, movie tickets, local attractions, spa/salon, or even just "I'll take you out for the day to any place you want to go."
And then there are those people who just aren't satisfied with anything. Not much you can do beyond maybe a gift certificate or cash and try not to let it linger in your mind. Their only joy is telling everyone else how wrong this or that is, which is pitiable.
In the OP's proposed situation, I wouldn't interfere. There's always a reason why a child chooses to reject a parent. Sometimes those reasons are justified, sometimes not, but there's always a reason.
|
|
Rhondito
Pearl Clutcher
MississipPea
Posts: 4,950
Jun 25, 2014 19:33:19 GMT
|
Wwyd?
Dec 12, 2022 15:17:33 GMT
Post by Rhondito on Dec 12, 2022 15:17:33 GMT
Is this just you wondering what's going on, or do you know for sure it's a mystery for the parents? The parent not getting the gift is hurt by the kids actions so no they haven't said to not buy them a gift. On one parents birthday the kid buys a nice gift, the other he ignores the occasion. Same with mothers/fathers day. So on the basis that one parent is hurt, I was curious if as the other parent you'd say something? Honestly if it were me and I was receiving the gift, I might just ask kid to save his money and not gift me as a way to diffuse the situation if I couldn't have a better conversation about it.It isn't a new issue and as everyone has said there has to be more issues within the family. You didn't answer my question, but from your statement above I'm going to surmise that you don't know what's going on in this family. I'd be willing to bet the parent who is not getting gifts knows exactly why and isn't sharing with the other parent out of guilt.
|
|
|
Wwyd?
Dec 12, 2022 17:08:27 GMT
Post by workingclassdog on Dec 12, 2022 17:08:27 GMT
The OP did NOT say that she was going to say anything. She asked, if you were one of the parents in the situation, would you say something. If I were the parent receiving the nicer gift and I truly did not know why this was happening, I might try to find out from my child if there was something I didn't know.  (I do wish people can read what the poster said instead of telling the pea not to get involved.)
|
|