|
Post by disneypal on Aug 15, 2023 7:32:30 GMT
Personal experience:
My neighbor had a HUGE and I mean HUGE tree that was right on out fence line but in her yard . That tree has worried me for years and when it stormed and was windy, I would actually pray for my house to be protected from that tree. It was a constant worry.
I discussed with her and even offered to pay half, if she’d have it removed but she said she didn’t want to remove it.
Well…a month ago, we had a storm (neighbors were not home at the time) and not even a bad storm, just rain. That tree had enough and fell. Thank the Lord, it didn’t fall on my house, however it did fall on her house. I felt so bad for her, but at the same time was relieved my house was ok. Come to find out, her insurance would not pay for it because they told her 2 years earlier to have it removed and she didn’t. I feel horrible for her. She said it costed $12,000 to have it removed. Also, after it fell, we could see it was all rotted on the inside.
Of course, she had someone come remove it, it took 16 hours for the tree removal. About 1/2 of her house is smashed and she said the ceiling on one side all fell in so the only see the beams. I haven’t seen any work or contractors come to the house and it’s still covered with tarps. Not sure what is going on (maybe trying to get insurance to pay or perhaps she doesn’t have the money to repair it??)
I say all this to tell you - if you are concerned, do not hesitate one moment to have it removed. It will take away your worries and may save your home and possibly your lives. Trust me, you will have no regrets removing it, but you may have regrets later on that you didn’t.
|
|
|
Post by piebaker on Aug 15, 2023 13:37:53 GMT
We took down a four trunk, 60 year old tree slowly over three years in order to remove a pool. It was an expensive headache that was keeping me up worrying during storms.
I was relieved in the end as its removal protected our neighbor's house and fence, sheds in both our yards, powerlines, our house and pool, and there was much less fall cleanup and tons more natural light.
|
|
|
Post by melanell on Aug 15, 2023 15:42:47 GMT
We are in the process of taking one big old maple down right now. It has dead branches, it's splitting at the base, has bark issues, & ants. The arborist told us maples to to showcase issues on the outside only after there is significant damage inside, so it's likely worse than it even looks. Yep. Maples sometimes don't look too bad (big old ones) but once you start cutting, you see what a hot mess is going inside. My husband hates cutting maples, as they tend to snap back and that can be very dangerous. Yes, and this maple is located in a tricky spot, so the poor guys working on ours will have their work cut out for them.
|
|
|
Post by monklady123 on Aug 15, 2023 15:52:56 GMT
Yep. Maples sometimes don't look too bad (big old ones) but once you start cutting, you see what a hot mess is going inside. My husband hates cutting maples, as they tend to snap back and that can be very dangerous. Yes, and this maple is located in a tricky spot, so the poor guys working on ours will have their work cut out for them. Ours is difficult also. It's in the back of the yard and our plots are small and narrow-ish. So the big discussion now is how and where to put a crane. One guy said they could do it without a crane but that will be an even bigger deal.
|
|
|
Post by melanell on Aug 15, 2023 16:26:00 GMT
Yes, and this maple is located in a tricky spot, so the poor guys working on ours will have their work cut out for them. Ours is difficult also. It's in the back of the yard and our plots are small and narrow-ish. So the big discussion now is how and where to put a crane. One guy said they could do it without a crane but that will be an even bigger deal. Oh dear! Well, ours is right at the road, so there's no narrow yards to deal with, but they'll be right on a bend in the road all day, which will make me nervous for them. I think they can do some work from the driveway, but not all.
|
|
craftymom101
Pearl Clutcher
Posts: 3,789
Jul 31, 2014 5:23:25 GMT
|
Post by craftymom101 on Aug 15, 2023 20:09:07 GMT
I know a few people who've had trees taken down because of their size, tree health, etc. None of them regretted spending the money on it. Better to spend the $ on tree removal than house repair if the tree falls on your house (or neighbor's house). In most places it falling on a neighbor’s house won’t have any financial impact on you. The only thing that you are responsible for is the guilt. Unless you know the tree is dead or dying. Our neighbor’s tree fell on our house ripping down the brand new gutters and taking down a good hunk of fence. Neighbor replace our shared fence, but they didn’t have to. Gutters were on us and our insurance . Fortunately our roof was fine and no one was hurt. It depends on where you live. In my county, if a tree on my property falls on my neighbor's house, I am financially responsible for the damage. I am also required to obtain a tree removal permit to remove any tree over 2.5 DBH (diameter at breast height) on my property and maintain a certain number of trees on my property, (5 trees, all native). You might want to call your local County or City Hall to verify you can remove the tree.
|
|
|
Post by mikklynn on Aug 17, 2023 13:22:08 GMT
If it has to be cabled to keep standing, let it go. My neighbors tried this on a big tree and it just delayed the inevitable.
|
|