|
Post by jeremysgirl on Aug 9, 2024 13:40:16 GMT
I was reading the NYT this morning and I read this article: www.nytimes.com/2024/08/09/opinion/italy-tourists-bologna-mortadella.htmlI had also read articles recently about the residents of Barcelona protesting tourism to the point where they were shooting people with squirt guns. I thought this might be a good topic of discussion here because peas seem to be a little more well-traveled than my immediate circle. I preface this by saying I have never traveled internationally. Well unless you count a couple of times I have gone into Canada but even that, Toronto is as far as I've gotten. I prefer camping and I feel like there are so many places I'd like to see just in the US that I'm not compelled to travel much beyond that. However I had always planned to do a real tour of Italy upon retirement when I can really spend almost a month there. I can understand why Europeans might be prickly about tourism's effects on their culture. But I feel like this is a symptom of both 1) travel becoming more widely accessible to people and 2) the culture itself seems to be cheapening everything as a result of technology. (I realize that might be a controversial opinion, but it is mine.) Anyone want to weigh in on this?
|
|
quiltz
Drama Llama
Posts: 6,850
Location: CANADA
Jun 29, 2014 16:13:28 GMT
|
Post by quiltz on Aug 9, 2024 14:02:25 GMT
I have travelled to many countries in Europe. The article you mentioned is a very good one that describes how tourists are behaving.
I agree that as travel has become more affordable, travel isn't a luxury that it used to be. People used to dress up to fly and the on-board service consisted of china and real silverware. I miss Ward Air and Canadian Pacific Airlines.
Many tourist sites are being damaged as the wear and tear from people who walk and wear down the paths and the fragile buildings are starting to crumble even more.
Each tourist that takes a stone or some small memento contributes to the destruction of a historic site.
|
|
milocat
Drama Llama
Posts: 5,616
Location: 55 degrees north in Alberta, Canada
Mar 18, 2015 4:10:31 GMT
|
Post by milocat on Aug 9, 2024 14:09:57 GMT
Thanks for starting this, I have been thinking this also. It's not just Europe I've seen the comments from North America too, just not protests and demonstrations. I've seen it from Hawaiians and southern BC. Tourists go home, stop coming here. I would imagine the places that are seasonally busy would really suck to have to deal with five times the your population booms in the high season. What would these places do without tourists? Could they just balance out and survive like non-tourist areas?
Tourism has also boomed. I remember when we went on our honeymoon 27 years ago my mom said hopefully you'll be able to go somewhere for your 25th. Within less than 10 years we started going more than just summer vacation. We go a few times a year. We're respectful travellers, I hate when I see garbage at a waterfall, people climbing over barriers, even carvings if it's just in a fence.
|
|
|
Post by jeremysgirl on Aug 9, 2024 14:13:43 GMT
I agree that as travel has become more affordable, travel isn't a luxury that it used to be. People used to dress up to fly and the on-board service consisted of china and real silverware. I miss Ward Air and Canadian Pacific Airlines. The comments on the article are all interesting. And many are similar to yours. Overcrowding is clearly an issue. And God knows I could live without the AirBNB types of rentals. But isn't making travel more affordable a democratization of it? I mean is that a question here? Should travel only be for the wealthy? Maybe if we made it nominally more expensive, people would travel less and that could be a good thing. Many tourist sites are being damaged as the wear and tear from people who walk and wear down the paths and the fragile buildings are starting to crumble even more. Each tourist that takes a stone or some small memento contributes to the destruction of a historic site. This is shameful. Just shameful. Nothing excuses behavior like this. We were in Mammoth Cave, KY in May and I was blown away at the amount of graffiti. It is actually a federal offense to do so and the graffiti actually looked old, so I'm not sure it was recent. But damn, I was like, what would drive someone to do something like that to such a beautiful place?
|
|
|
Post by gar on Aug 9, 2024 14:18:52 GMT
I can’t open the article. As far as I’ve seen the protests in Barcelona in particular are about so many properties are now being used as Airbnb’s that local folk can’t get on the property ladder. Thats aside from the literal heavy footfall that has a detrimental affect on some places.
I don’t know what the answer is…I LOVE to travel and have so many more places to see.
And as an aside - there are of course, a million places to see in our own countries but traveling to other countries is about so much more than just seeing things. Being exposed to different cultures and ways of life different to our own opens our minds like nothing else imo.
The selfie culture too has had a dreadful impact sometimes. Stupid ignorant humans desecrating sacred places or damaging ancient statues etc just for a selfie 🤬
|
|
|
Post by jeremysgirl on Aug 9, 2024 14:20:36 GMT
What would these places do without tourists? Could they just balance out and survive like non-tourist areas? This is a very interesting point. I assume that in some ways, these areas have always relied on some form of tourism so I'm not sure that eliminating it is the right answer either. We are trying to plan a move to a more touristy area of Michigan. We are there ourselves at least once a summer. And it does get a bit busy, but not to the point where it would discourage us from wanting to live there. But then I think, what happens if it really increases? I mean that's totally possible.
|
|
Tearisci
Pearl Clutcher
Posts: 3,249
Member is Online
Nov 6, 2018 16:34:30 GMT
|
Post by Tearisci on Aug 9, 2024 14:23:20 GMT
And as an aside - there are of course, a million places to see in our own countries but traveling to other countries is about so much more than just seeing things. Being exposed to different cultures and ways of life different to our own opens our minds like nothing else imo. I agree with this and feel that international travel has changed me in a lot of ways that I just don't get traveling domestically.
|
|
|
Post by jeremysgirl on Aug 9, 2024 14:23:52 GMT
Being exposed to different cultures and ways of life different to our own opens our minds like nothing else imo. What happens when the culture is boxed out? I mean she is talking about students not being able to live in Bologna anymore, there's part of the culture gone. Small, local shops being priced out by chains? There goes a significant part of the culture. This is why I said that I think technology (I'll add capitalism) is cheapening things to the point where culture here is being diluted.
|
|
|
Post by gar on Aug 9, 2024 14:26:19 GMT
Being exposed to different cultures and ways of life different to our own opens our minds like nothing else imo. What happens when the culture is boxed out? I mean she is talking about students not being able to live in Bologna anymore, there's part of the culture gone. Small, local shops being priced out by chains? There goes a significant part of the culture. This is why I said that I think technology (I'll add capitalism) is cheapening things to the point where culture here is being diluted. I don’t know. I value exposure to things I would never come across in the UK but I don’t want to be part of the demise of said cultures. It’s complex for sure.
|
|
|
Post by melanell on Aug 9, 2024 14:28:29 GMT
Even if all tourists were incredibly careful, kind, and respectful, over-tourism would be an issue for some of these European cities and areas with major tourist attractions.
However, I can't help but feel that in general, there are a higher percentage of tourists behaving poorly now than in the past. And I can absolutely understand people living in those places not wanting the crushing over-tourism they are receiving, particularly with people behaving badly.
I, personally, am not interesting in visiting any major cities in Europe because I don't wish to deal with the crushing throngs of people. Dh & I each have our own lists of places to visit, and we try to avoid any major cities at all, no matter what marvelous things the city might offer.
I've seen videos discussing possible fees to enter certain cities to try to cut down on day-trippers, but the prices mentioned seemed too low to matter imo. Many of these places may need to start raising their prices significantly, in hopes of scaring off some of the crowds.
It's unfortunate, of course, for those who would then not be able to afford to go, but it's simply not feasible for such a relatively small list of locations being swamped with such immense crowds all of the time, particularly when these places were never meant to handle so many people at all times.
But if the relentless crowds destroy some of the landmarks, or cause them to be closed to the public, then no one will get to visit them in that situation, either.
|
|
|
Post by **GypsyGirl** on Aug 9, 2024 14:37:55 GMT
I can’t open the article. Here is a gift link. See if this works for you.
|
|
|
Post by jeremysgirl on Aug 9, 2024 14:41:43 GMT
I, personally, am not interesting in visiting any major cities in Europe because I don't wish to deal with the crushing throngs of people. Can anyone who travels extensively comment? I tend to be a quiet vacation type of person. I like to get out in the middle of nowhere, unplug and relax type of traveler. I can tell you I've been almost forced into Disney twice and crowds is one of the main reasons why I hated it. Dh & I each have our own lists of places to visit, and we try to avoid any major cities at all, no matter what marvelous things the city might offer. You sound a lot like Jeremy and I. As much as I'd love to experience other cultures (read: OMG, food!), and I do see the benefit to it, I often wonder if I am going to be surrounded by more people speaking English than the native language, if I'm really getting to experience the culture at all.
|
|
|
Post by jeremysgirl on Aug 9, 2024 14:42:12 GMT
I can’t open the article. Here is a gift link. See if this works for you. Thank you! I can never figure out how to do that right!
|
|
|
Post by Zee on Aug 9, 2024 14:46:40 GMT
I also like to camp and like you have plenty to still see here to keep me busy, and I haven't done much international travel.
I don't care that much about it to go somewhere where I'd be pelted with water bottles, so I'll refrain from darkening doorsteps in Italy. But I would very much like to visit Greece one day. DH and I are pretty quiet people, respectful, but I know not all tourists are like that unfortunately.
The loudest and most obnoxious tourists I've ever come across have been Italians, ironically. The quietest and most respectful, Japanese.
|
|
pantsonfire
Drama Llama
Take a step back, evaluate what is important, and enjoy your life with those who you love.
Posts: 6,273
Jun 19, 2022 16:48:04 GMT
|
Post by pantsonfire on Aug 9, 2024 14:49:13 GMT
Okay here is my 2 cents, quickly.
If there is anything to be blamed it is money.
Not tourists.
Not your food.
Not ease of access to travel.
Not cheap airfare.
Money.
Be mad at the locals who sold their homes to Air BNB, who sold their shops to corporations, who sold their markets to grocery store chains.
Why are tourists being blamed? We are all free to travel and experience places. Well except North Korea.
Yes there are shitty tourists. Even in America. I mean shoot 3 German tourists used paintball guns and ruined Joshua Tree this past week. Like come on!! So really it's not just Americans.
Money talks and obviously those residents needed the money. And if the sold, were they really that tied down to their old ways and traditions??
|
|
|
Post by **GypsyGirl** on Aug 9, 2024 14:50:16 GMT
Thank you! I can never figure out how to do that right! You're welcome! It took me a while to figure it out. Once you click on the Gift Article link, then you have to click on Copy Link in the popup box, NOT the link in your browser address bar. That's what kept messing me up.
|
|
|
Post by peasapie on Aug 9, 2024 14:52:56 GMT
I lived in NYC for many years and to be honest usually found tourists to be problematic to the general population. New Yorkers use the streets the way others use their freeways - we’re walking quickly because that’s how most of us travel. Tourists are (of course, it’s their vacation) exiting a store and stopping mid sidewalk to look around, crowding in to popular areas like Times Square and the theater district, and sometimes being downright rude. I always had to remind myself to be patient with visitors and I’ve helped with directions etc many times. I just wish travelers would remember they are visiting someone else’s home and to be polite and thoughtful. I try to do this myself when I travel.
|
|
|
Post by ntsf on Aug 9, 2024 14:56:57 GMT
I think some of it is the ability to go internationally on a whim, without much planning or advance knowledge.. and some is the instagram culture.
I have traveled a lot overseas.. and most seem to concentrate on only a few sites, and not spread out to learn about where they are and what the culture is like there.
|
|
|
Post by jeremysgirl on Aug 9, 2024 15:06:45 GMT
If there is anything to be blamed it is money. Not tourists. Not your food. Not ease of access to travel. Not cheap airfare. Money. I'll agree and disagree. It is money. But I also think that cheap airfare and ease of travel is another issue. (It's still out of my budget or I should say, I'd likely get 5-6 camping trips out of one European vacation so camping is a much better value dollar for dollar for *us*. And that is on top of our preference to relax and "get away from it all.") I also agree with you on the point that locals are selling out their own culture. There's no reason they can't make policies to limit short term rentals and such. And choosing to sell to a chain, is questionable practice too (although I'm not sure it is entirely driven just by money, but also a cheapening amongst themselves of their own cultural ties.)
|
|
|
Post by gar on Aug 9, 2024 15:07:25 GMT
I can’t open the article. Here is a gift link. See if this works for you. Thank you 😊
|
|
|
Post by epeanymous on Aug 9, 2024 15:29:56 GMT
Thing is you could write a similar article about small shops closing and big chains entering and the erosion of local culture about a lot of small American towns that aren’t touristy at all. Some of what the author describes is simply modernity. One of my favorite museums is the Museum of London because it takes you through the dozens of Londons that London has been. It looks completely different now than even when I first visited, with the skyscrapers and the London Eye. There is also a lot of competition for space that is simply inevitable in light of growing populations. Italy’s population doubled in the past century. There is simply a lot more competition for space in places that are nice to live, both retail and residential.
So to some extent a lot of that op-ed strikes me as yelling at the changes brought by time and growth in the ways people have done since the dawn of time, just dressed up as “these darn foreigners” (which is definitely something as well). I am also deeply skeptical that 100 years ago none of the moneyed traveling class would pick up pebbles or act like idiots while traveling, because I’ve read the memoirs of those folks and they definitely were acting like idiots. It also strikes me as ahistorical smugness, as if cities haven’t always had things on offer portrayed as local specialties that were 100% aimed at tourists.
So I guess I had things to say. I am sure I am partly responding to the classism here — my family could not afford travel when I was growing up (I enrolled at my university without seeing it first and could not afford to study abroad because I needed to work part-time during college), and the idea that the problem ia low-rent rubes strikes me as pretty gross. It is funny, because I do think some things, like short-term rentals, are a genuine issue that there are policy tools to solve), but frankly that op/ed didn’t make me sympathetic (and I say this as someone who lives right by the space needle!)
|
|
|
Post by scrapmaven on Aug 9, 2024 15:31:16 GMT
I grew up in a US tourist spot. When I was a child it was just a place for the locals and occasional tourists when special events would happen. Then it changed into a full time tourist town. The biggest complaints the locals have in that area is the tourist behavior on the road. They go 25 mph on the fwy, because they're sightseeing rather than paying attention to the 65mph signs. They block traffic and stop on a dime when they see something interesting. They crowd the streets and don't have respect for the locals. People go to work in that town and need to get places. Follow the traffic signs and don't assume that everyone can read your mind. It's a beautiful area, parts of it, just breathtaking, but trash and disrespect play a role in the environment. I wouldn't touch the lake w/my hands. The hotel rates are astronomical. Over the years the tourist spots started to take over the local spots. People, when you travel remember that you are visiting someone else's house. Be courteous, be alert, pick up your trash and for goodness sake don't hold up traffic or cause near misses, because you aren't paying attention. If you don't know where to go then pull over and find out. On another note, my bff lives in Lisbon. I'll ask him about the general attitude twd tourists. When he would visit before his move he seemed to indicate that everyone was very welcoming twds him. Granted he lives in an area w/a lot of expats.
ETA: Dh just gave me a different perspective. He reminded me that when it became a tourist town people grumbled and groused about traffic and other stuff, but they were very happy w/the tourist income.
|
|
|
Post by jeremysgirl on Aug 9, 2024 15:33:38 GMT
Thing is you could write a similar article about small shops closing and big chains entering and the erosion of local culture about a lot of small American towns that aren’t touristy at all. Some of what the author describes is simply modernity. Modernity is a better term for what I was trying to get at, technological progress is cheapening culture. And yes, I agree, everywhere. So I guess I had things to say LOL! This cracked me up. Say it, say it!
|
|
quiltz
Drama Llama
Posts: 6,850
Location: CANADA
Jun 29, 2014 16:13:28 GMT
|
Post by quiltz on Aug 9, 2024 15:34:55 GMT
We are trying to plan a move to a more touristy area of Michigan. We are there ourselves at least once a summer. And it does get a bit busy, but not to the point where it would discourage us from wanting to live there. But then I think, what happens if it really increases? I mean that's totally possible. I live near Niagara Falls, a huge tourist attraction and thus, close to 3 border crossings, USA-CDA. I stay off the highways on most weekends, simply because of the tourist traffic. Many people (looking at you Toronto - GTA) have a drivers licence but don't own a car. They rent a car for a week/end. They are totally unaware of the features of the car, windshield wipers, blinkers, other buttons that they are distracted when driving. Then the road is very busy and they forget the speed limit and either go very fast or very slow, are unaware of the different lanes (hello truckers) and of course, construction. Usually the people are talking in the car and they forget their exit or they get the road number mixed up with the exit number and chaos happens. There is only 1 major highway into/out of Niagara Region. If there is a collision, the lineup starts, the service roads become clogged and it is nasty. But if the relentless crowds destroy some of the landmarks, or cause them to be closed to the public, then no one will get to visit them in that situation, either. The many barricades that have been installed due to people not reading caution signs has ruined some experiences. People think that they can hike down the Niagara Glen to the Niagara River in flip flops and careless footwear. They slip and hurt themselves or worse, fall into the water and are swept away into the whirlpools. This happens, unfortunately many times. Then it is up to the local fire department, EMS, police to do search & rescue or recovery. The cost is passed down to the local taxpayer, not the person who requires help. Sometimes people are fined but not often enough.
|
|
|
Post by jeremysgirl on Aug 9, 2024 15:35:42 GMT
People, when you travel remember that you are visiting someone else's house. Be courteous, be alert, pick up your trash and for goodness sake don't hold up traffic or cause near misses, because you aren't paying attention. If you don't now where to go then pull over and find out. Yes, for sure. I've even seen campers leave some big messes at times and you would think they would be super inclined to conservation, environmentalism, etc.
|
|
|
Post by Darcy Collins on Aug 9, 2024 15:42:14 GMT
The Barcelona incident in particular came up around here as we're scheduled to go there next March. I'll preface all this to say, I LOVE TRAVEL. Love, love, love it. My parents were not much for traveling and went on my first airplane ride when I was 16 and got a passport in my early 20s and fell in love. I've traveled extensively - in both popular and remote locations. Italy is a place I've gone several times and hope to go back as it's just amazing. I absolutely feel for the impact of two things in particular - one was mentioned in the article, short term rentals which really skew real estate prices and cruise ships which really skews restaurants and retail.
We saw the cruise ship impact a ton in Greece. We're not much for cruising, but went for this trip and some of the worst of cruising was definitely felt. It's pretty much impossible to beat the crowds. We spent 4 days in Athens prior to the cruise, and could pretty easily navigate the heat and crowds (even though it was summer) as we weren't limited to the 9-5 cruise ship scheduled.
I'd say the same about our trips to all the big tourist destinations. We've done Rome, London, Paris etc all during peak or semi-peak seasons as that's when the kids were off school and could navigate just fine with some preplanning. If you're getting off a ship with thousands of others to see a handful of places in a handful of hours it's going to be rough - and that's one of the issues Barcelona in particular is experiencing. It's been popular for quite some time, but European cruises have definitely become more popular so some of these places are seeing the impacts that places in the Caribbean and Mexico have seen for decades. Way too many crappy tourist shops near ports and restaurants only doing business for lunch if that.
Several articles have mentioned that this was one of the worst seasons for Greece's hotels and restaurants for their most popular islands as travelers with longer itineraries were avoiding the cruise crowds. So hotels and restaurants were suffering despite the hordes trying to take their selfie next to the iconic architecture and then getting back on their ships and bitching about the crowds.
The short term rentals are also really rough for locals (which is why some cities in the US and internationally) limit or forbid it. You have housing stock sitting empty a lot of the time for overpriced short term rentals and that has a huge impact on neighborhoods - I get it and do understand locales needing to navigate how to prevent their cities from become wastelands outside of a handful of weeks/months.
While there's no doubt there's a lot to see in the US - one of the things I love about travel IS the other cultures. It gets your out of your bubble if you let it. Unfortunately too many people are trying to stay in their bubble while traveling and just capture a few pictures for their instagram account.
|
|
|
Post by scrapcat on Aug 9, 2024 15:57:40 GMT
I think social media/influencer culture have turned tourism into something different. Also the threat of terrorism has changed major cities, imo. And then the pandemic has changed a lot of things too, in the instance of local business/mom & pop business.
I saw that about Barcelona, but then also wonder what they think will happen to their small businesses, cafes, jobs, if no one visits? I would imagine some sort of regulations on airbnbs could help.
I have the luxury of traveling when it is not crowded, and am so thankful for that. We generally go in September which is a great time to still enjoy good weather, but less crowds. We also do not spend a ton of time in the major cities, and look for things that interest us in other parts that are not as "touristy". I love being a tourist and taking it all in. I do not like the endless, cookie cutter, branded stores they put in every major city now.
The good thing of social media is users sharing small business and local spots, even like food trucks, but then of course it becomes more popular and mainstream, and maybe not as authentic because they are trying to keep up with demand.
I always research stationery shops and book shops and have found the most incredible spots and experiences through that. Those memories stick with me too. We also look for hole in the wall places or dive bars.
I also detest cruises. They invade a town for a day and take all the resources and rush thru everything just so they can make it back to the ship before departing. When I am planning a trip, I check the cruise ship schedules to try to avoid when they are in port. We'll go visit a different town or something away from those crowds.
But the tourism districts/cities have catered to this type of activity, so the problem isn't with the tourists, it's with the people making those policies, most likely gov't officials & corporations. Regulations would help and maybe grants to help local businesses stay afloat, esp thru tough times.
I also don't necessarily call it a "vacation" when we go to Europe, I call it a trip. Vacation is for the islands/beach/r&r.
|
|
|
Post by jeremysgirl on Aug 9, 2024 16:02:51 GMT
We saw the cruise ship impact a ton in Greece. We're not much for cruising, but went for this trip and some of the worst of cruising was definitely felt. It's pretty much impossible to beat the crowds. A cruise has always struck me as being Disney World on water in terms of the herds of people. LOL! You'd never get me on one. Hahaha...
|
|
|
Post by gar on Aug 9, 2024 16:08:49 GMT
but then also wonder what they think will happen to their small businesses, cafes, jobs, if no one visits? I would imagine some sort of regulations on airbnbs could help. There must be a happy medium between ‘no one’ and overwhelming crowds.
|
|
|
Post by malibou on Aug 9, 2024 16:10:38 GMT
We travel, A lot. Up until this summer, we have never travelled abroad in summer. We are a family that is crowd adverse. 😁 That said, ds graduated college this year and asked for a southern European road trip for his gift. He made all arrangements. ❤
Holy cats, travelling in summer is not for sissies! Crowds of people everywhere, most of whom seemed to have no idea where they were going, which led to ever so much milling about, which caused confusion and delay. Definitely the more touristy a spot was the worse the behavior of tourists was. Much of it is failure to be courteous and massively overblown senses of entitlement. I will say that the locals were all very tolerant and kind and helpful.
I got a giggle from all the online advice about how Americans shouldn't wear shirts advertising American things because it screams American tourist. I saw loads of shirts advertising all things American and made a point to get close enough to find out if they were indeed American. I think we only found 2 instances where they were American. 😁
Prague and Dubrovnik were the hardest in terms of the amount of tourists. And we saw bad behavior from all manner of tourists there. Dubrovnik and Split are both in the process of limiting cruise ships because it is just too many people.
Not going to lie, I am always glad when people guess we are Dutch rather than American. We typically just go with it, unless an actual conversation might ensue. And I have no idea why people in Europe always think we are Dutch. But we do take care not to appear as Americans.
|
|