|
Post by Merge on Mar 31, 2025 16:27:36 GMT
So the gist here is that certain male influencers are creating an unattainable ideal through their videos about morning routines and fitness, and despair over not being able to meet that ideal is driving some men to depression or even suicide.
Every woman here is squinting at this, right? Unattainable ideals are apparently only a newsworthy problem when they're hurting men.
Anyway. What was your first exposure to the unattainable ideal women have long been expected to meet? Mine was in elementary school when my mom wouldn't buy me a skirt and top set I wanted because she said the skirt, which was on the shorter side but hardly indecent, would be "unflattering." And thus set up for me a decades-long battle with my genetically thick thighs.
I expect most of us got exposed to the "ideal" by our moms, who got it from their moms, and so on.
|
|
|
Post by crimsoncat05 on Mar 31, 2025 16:36:29 GMT
Every woman here is squinting at this, right? Unattainable ideals are apparently only a newsworthy problem when they're hurting men. HAHAHA!!! my response to them would be 'get used to it' or 'get over yourselves' mine was pretty early, when, in third grade, I had to wear glasses- coupled with a short 'boy haircut' because my mom didn't want to take care of my long, thick hair any longer... I no longer looked the 1970s-80s standard of 'feminine / pretty' and my self-image was forever changed. Also, one instance when I was, maybe... 12-ish? when we were playing kickball and I kicked a home run. Right after that I was called a 'dog' by a boy I really liked (I think he had said I wouldn't be able to kick the home run, and was mad that I did). That incident stuck with me to this day-- and I'm almost 56. I'm sure HE forgot it not long afterward. eta: I'm glad I'm at the age where I don't much care about society's 'beauty ideals' any longer.
|
|
|
Post by jeremysgirl on Mar 31, 2025 16:43:14 GMT
This guy was all over social media a few weeks ago about this video. CNN is late to the party. 😂
I have two things that stick out to me as body shaming by own mother. One is that even as a small child I was never allowed to eat more than one serving of potatoes. A serving mom dishes out. Me and potatoes in any form have had a love affair since I was a small child. My dad's carb preference was also potatoes. And my mom was just adamant that potatoes were not to be indulged in by me.
And secondly another comment stuck out when I was a teen. I was athletic. I played softball and went biking all the time with my good friend whose family did competitive long distance bike rides. I was lifting weights in gym class too. I had some very shapely (muscular) thighs. And I am 5'3" tall. We went shopping for jeans and I had(have) small hips but funding jeans that fit my thighs was a problem plus I was short. And my mother looked at me and said this would be a lot easier if I could just have long skinny legs like her and my sister. My mom is 5'7" and does have the bulk of her height in her legs. My sister is 5'9" and has always been thin and lanky.
The most irritating comment about the ideal woman came from my dad though. When I was pregnant with Chloe I mentioned that I'd be staying home after her birth for the first few years. And my dad said, what about your career? He said women of your generation are capable of taking care of house, children, and working and that I have no reason to walk away from my career. To this day that guy thinks that was a mistake (I was home for 6 years). And never once has shown any empathy for me having to handle it all for my children.
|
|
|
Post by jeremysgirl on Mar 31, 2025 16:50:20 GMT
Oh and I'll just say that I think men of a certain age are very misguided. (By other men) I think a lot of them are doing things to get the ladies. And really the ladies want them to go to therapy and deal with their baggage, help out around the house and do 50% of the childcare. This is what women want and it's far easier to make muscles it seems.
I'll take partnership in the dadbod.
|
|
|
Post by gryroagain on Mar 31, 2025 17:22:58 GMT
We lived on a military base when my oldest was 3-4. One day she piped up to me “wow have you lost weight? You look great!”
For the record I am very thin and always have been, never dieted, exercised as in the military at that time but not excessively. She was getting none of those messages from me, but the other women on our block talked about it all the time. She noticed it made women happy to say that so for her it was something nice to say to her mama 😭
I was crushed. The world is just out to get girls and women I swear. Which does not mean I want men to also suffer that, but toddlers internalizing these messages guy. Toddlers.
|
|
|
Post by Basket1lady on Mar 31, 2025 17:23:25 GMT
Can I put in an argument for the evils of social media on the young?
I will agree that this is something that women have dealt with since time began. But I'd argue that men have had it to some extent as well. Hasn't height always been an issue for men? Men with money have always been able to overcome that deficit, but I'm sure short men and men with less muscular frames also have to cope with it.
As more and more young people delay marriage and committed relationships, I could see how they are prolonging the period of needing to look good to others. So many--both men and women--"play the field" well into their 20s and 30s. That's a long time to maintain a body that is fighting against time. We see it in ourselves with the hunt for wrinkle cream, the makeup, pretty nails, flattering clothes, etc. Life is hard.
|
|
valincal
Drama Llama

Southern Alberta
Posts: 6,225
Jun 27, 2014 2:21:22 GMT
|
Post by valincal on Mar 31, 2025 17:31:43 GMT
I was very lucky in that body shape or size food portions etc. were never mentioned by my mom or dad. And I was happily floating through childhood when an aunt commented that I “still had puppy fat” when I was around 12 years old. So innocuous, but I spent almost 40 years with disordered eating of some sort or another.
I’m so sad for all that wasted time. When I had my own children (two boys), I vowed to never talk about my weight, their weight, anybody’s weight or how much food somebody ate or didn’t eat.
|
|
|
Post by tc on Mar 31, 2025 17:47:43 GMT
I was probably 11 or 12. Hadn't hit puberty yet. The neighborhood ladies were outside chatting while us kids played. My mother was overweight. She was always trying another diet at the time. Her three daugthers were all primarily stick figures - I'm the oldest. The three of us were running around and one of the other neighborhood ladies stopped me and said, "You're so skinny, but so short! You're going to have to watch that as you get older. You probably won't have the height to even out your weight." And I stopped in my tracks and almost started crying because I didn't want to live in the misery that my mother was constantly subjecting herself to. I've probably thought about that statement once a week ever since. That's all it takes to "injure" your relationship with health and self-esteem. But it does make me wonder if this woman had said that to a son rather than a daughter if he would have ever thought about it again?
|
|
|
Post by Merge on Mar 31, 2025 17:48:22 GMT
Can I put in an argument for the evils of social media on the young? I will agree that this is something that women have dealt with since time began. But I'd argue that men have had it to some extent as well. Hasn't height always been an issue for men? Men with money have always been able to overcome that deficit, but I'm sure short men and men with less muscular frames also have to cope with it. As more and more young people delay marriage and committed relationships, I could see how they are prolonging the period of needing to look good to others. So many--both men and women--"play the field" well into their 20s and 30s. That's a long time to maintain a body that is fighting against time. We see it in ourselves with the hunt for wrinkle cream, the makeup, pretty nails, flattering clothes, etc. Life is hard. Oh for sure. But another angle I see hinted at (and sometimes stated outright) is that since women can now have careers and support themselves rather than being dependent on a husband for their livelihood, they can be more choosy about who they marry. I believe that in reality, most women are holding out for men who are ready to be partners rather than only looking for a tall, muscular type, but the manosphere (social media) would have them believe that women are mostly looking for the physical. And I tend to believe there's a certain amount of projection there, as many men tend to be more interested in the physical aspects of their dates than in any other attributes they may have, so they believe women must be the same.
Certain social media extrapolates this to mean that feminism is to blame for all men's woes.
|
|
|
Post by Merge on Mar 31, 2025 17:52:28 GMT
This guy was all over social media a few weeks ago about this video. CNN is late to the party. 😂 I have two things that stick out to me as body shaming by own mother. One is that even as a small child I was never allowed to eat more than one serving of potatoes. A serving mom dishes out. Me and potatoes in any form have had a love affair since I was a small child. My dad's carb preference was also potatoes. And my mom was just adamant that potatoes were not to be indulged in by me. Yes, I got the comments from mom about second helpings and portion sizes, too. So helpful! And then there was the year - sixth grade, I think - that she made me try diet shakes with her. I remember being so hungry all the time. She also made me go on walks with her and put the idea into my head that if I wasn't able to walk a 15 minute mile up some pretty substantial hills, it was just wasted effort.
All that did was destroy my relationship with food and turn me into a kid who snuck food when no one was looking because I was *hungry.* And also a kid who hated exercise because I was never going to be good enough at it to do myself any good.
|
|
|
Post by jeremysgirl on Mar 31, 2025 18:20:50 GMT
Basket1lady in all of my dating years I have had exactly one friend that was concerned with how tall their boyfriend was. And that my college BFF who happens to be 6'3" tall herself. I have never otherwise heard a single discussion of height among my friends over the years. I just don't buy that height is a big issue.
|
|
|
Post by jeremysgirl on Mar 31, 2025 18:25:50 GMT
Can I put in an argument for the evils of social media on the young? I will agree that this is something that women have dealt with since time began. But I'd argue that men have had it to some extent as well. Hasn't height always been an issue for men? Men with money have always been able to overcome that deficit, but I'm sure short men and men with less muscular frames also have to cope with it. As more and more young people delay marriage and committed relationships, I could see how they are prolonging the period of needing to look good to others. So many--both men and women--"play the field" well into their 20s and 30s. That's a long time to maintain a body that is fighting against time. We see it in ourselves with the hunt for wrinkle cream, the makeup, pretty nails, flattering clothes, etc. Life is hard. Oh for sure. But another angle I see hinted at (and sometimes stated outright) is that since women can now have careers and support themselves rather than being dependent on a husband for their livelihood, they can be more choosy about who they marry. I believe that in reality, most women are holding out for men who are ready to be partners rather than only looking for a tall, muscular type, but the manosphere (social media) would have them believe that women are mostly looking for the physical. And I tend to believe there's a certain amount of projection there, as many men tend to be more interested in the physical aspects of their dates than in any other attributes they may have, so they believe women must be the same.
Certain social media extrapolates this to mean that feminism is to blame for all men's woes.
I agree with this. And it's hard to put it in perspective. It was all over on Twitter. (I left there) And it's now all over threads. If you aren't on platforms like this you may not even realize that this is an ongoing point of contention between younger women and men. And I'll just say that women are being very vocal about it. The men just aren't hearing it. They will chalk it up to that dirty, dirty feminism.
|
|
|
Post by busy on Mar 31, 2025 18:49:23 GMT
Basket1lady in all of my dating years I have had exactly one friend that was concerned with how tall their boyfriend was. And that my college BFF who happens to be 6'3" tall herself. I have never otherwise heard a single discussion of height among my friends over the years. I just don't buy that height is a big issue. I think it's true a lot of women prefer taller men... but I also can't think of any I know personally who otherwise really liked a man and their height was a dealbreaker. I think it's a common excuse that shorter men tell themselves when the real issue was something else. And perhaps some women do tell men they don't want want a second date because they prefer taller guys, but I highly doubt that's the primary reason. Only about 15% of American men are 6', so the math ain't mathing when the online manchildren whine that women won't date anyone under 6'. Even if you attributed the drop in long-term relationships/marriages SOLELY to women refusing to date shorter men, the math doesn't work (and OF COURSE, it's ludicrous to think any meaningful portion of the drop could be due to "being picky about height). It's always the men saying they are "quality men" but women won't date them because they're 5' 9" whose online posts make it very clear there is nothing "quality" about them, and their height has nothing to do with why they're not partnered. Women don't want them because they're entitled, misogynistic losers and women now have the option to be successful and happy on their own instead of being miserable with someone like that.
|
|
|
Post by Linda on Mar 31, 2025 18:57:53 GMT
Basket1lady in all of my dating years I have had exactly one friend that was concerned with how tall their boyfriend was. And that my college BFF who happens to be 6'3" tall herself. I have never otherwise heard a single discussion of height among my friends over the years. I just don't buy that height is a big issue. I think it's true a lot of women prefer taller men... but I also can't think of any I know personally who otherwise really liked a man and their height was a dealbreaker. I think it's a common excuse that shorter men tell themselves when the real issue was something else. And perhaps some women do tell men they don't want want a second date because they prefer taller guys, but I highly doubt that's the primary reason. Only about 15% of American men are 6', so the math ain't mathing when the online manchildren whine that women won't date anyone under 6'. Even if you attributed the drop in long-term relationships/marriages SOLELY to women refusing to date shorter men, the math doesn't work (and OF COURSE, it's ludicrous to think any meaningful portion of the drop could be due to "being picky about height). It's always the men saying they are "quality men" but women won't date them because they're 5' 9" whose online posts make it very clear there is nothing "quality" about them, and their height has nothing to do with why they're not partnered. Women don't want them because they're entitled, misogynistic losers and women now have the option to be successful and happy on their own instead of being miserable with someone like that. my dh is 5'7" and I'm 5'8" - never been an issue for us.
|
|
|
Post by ~summer~ on Mar 31, 2025 19:02:36 GMT
Ok I’ll sheepishly raise my hand and admit height is a big deal to me - sorry guys!
|
|
|
Post by Linda on Mar 31, 2025 19:05:15 GMT
I was put on my first diet just before I turned 3...I had spent time (with my mum) visiting my grandparents in America and apparently was a bit spoiled by Granny...so when we got home, mum put me on a diet. I suspect (as a parent myself) that what actually happened is I had hit one of those growth spurts where kids get a little chubby before getting taller. But my mum was always on a diet ...even the week before she died at 84, she was still talking about losing just 5 more lbs - and cleaning out her house I found a dessert cookbook Granny had given her after college inscribed "to Jean who is always on a diet". I also found a photo of me at almost 4 that mum labelled as 'she's very sturdy' (a term I grew up with as a euphemism for chubby/not thin).
I suspect it's not unexpected that I've always struggled with both my weight and self-image and also with food.
|
|
|
Post by busy on Mar 31, 2025 19:08:22 GMT
Ok I’ll sheepishly raise my hand and admit height is a big deal to me - sorry guys! I think I only dated one guy who was under 6' and DH is 6' 3". Height matters to me too. There's nothing wrong with having preferences! But I just don't think it's the "problem" that some men make it out to be. The shorter guys who are loudly proclaiming they want to be married but no women are interested because they're not 6'... there are PLENTY of women out there who don't care about height. Height isn't the reason why no one is interested.
|
|
|
Post by jeremysgirl on Mar 31, 2025 19:52:31 GMT
Ok I’ll sheepishly raise my hand and admit height is a big deal to me - sorry guys! I think I only dated one guy who was under 6' and DH is 6' 3". Height matters to me too. There's nothing wrong with having preferences! But I just don't think it's the "problem" that some men make it out to be. The shorter guys who are loudly proclaiming they want to be married but no women are interested because they're not 6'... there are PLENTY of women out there who don't care about height. Height isn't the reason why no one is interested. That's what I was trying to say. There may be a woman here or there who has height as a dealbreaker but the vast majority IME (anecdotal) is that most women just don't care. Yet there seems to be a contingent of men who honestly believe that this is the reason they aren't partnered.
|
|
|
Post by ~summer~ on Mar 31, 2025 20:00:11 GMT
Ok I’ll sheepishly raise my hand and admit height is a big deal to me - sorry guys! I think I only dated one guy who was under 6' and DH is 6' 3". Height matters to me too. There's nothing wrong with having preferences! But I just don't think it's the "problem" that some men make it out to be. The shorter guys who are loudly proclaiming they want to be married but no women are interested because they're not 6'... there are PLENTY of women out there who don't care about height. Height isn't the reason why no one is interested. 100%!
|
|
The Great Carpezio
Pearl Clutcher
Something profound goes here.
Posts: 3,165
Jun 25, 2014 21:50:33 GMT
|
Post by The Great Carpezio on Mar 31, 2025 20:14:34 GMT
I do think it is harder for short men. I don't think it is a dealbreaker for most women if a man is similar in height, but I do think a lot of women prefer men taller than themselves and/or of at least average height.
One of my twins is 5'5 and if he is lucky, will grow another inch or so. He is also very slim. I think it will be harder for him. He is pretty chill with it, but I do worry down the line for him if he decides to pursue romantic partners. He it still taller than the average women in the US.
The other is 5'8-something and might make it to 5'10 if he is lucky (based on last ped visit). He is of an average build and athletic medium (meaning not ripped LOL). I think it will be easier for him, but he still isn't tall, but he will at least be taller than the majority of women.
That said, I think there are many more things in this day and age that make a man attractive and a good partner than height, but there is no doubt that it is harder for short men. Hopefully, my boys will have those traits, and they will find a complementary partner.
The thing about misogyny--it hurts men too. It creates binary expectations that are harmful for both men and women.
|
|
|
Post by ScrapbookMyLife on Mar 31, 2025 20:22:11 GMT
Just my humble opinion:
I think in general and in regards to everything and anything.....there is too much judgement. Everyone has their own "ideal expectation" of how life in general should be, and anyone who is outside of that parameter is judged. It happens with everything >> looks, weight, how one is living their life, where someone lives, what someone drives, what someone wears, what people children do, etc.... I think way too many people.....follow the crowd, jump on a bandwagon, live inside a society deemed box of expectations, judge everything by the proverbial "keeping up with the Jones", rushing to get whatever the latest trend items is, etc... instead of doing what they like or love. I did that for many years and was miserable. I thought if I was more like the others, that would make my own Mother like or love me. I thought if I conformed to the society deemed expectations, it would help me be "normal". I have never fit the realm of normal. I repressed myself for decades, because I worried about what other people thought of me and how I lived my life, I told myself I had to be who and what I was expected to be. I tried to keep up with the proverbial Jones Family. I tried to have a home and life that was similar to everyone else. Deep inside I was unhappy and miserable. It sucked, trying to be who and what someone else expected me to be.
The second best thing I've done for myself is >> do not worry about what other people think. Divorce was the best thing I've ever done for myself.
If someone wants to judge me, because I am a little overweight, I scrapbook (crazy how many people think this is a waste of time), my car is older, I live in a small studio apt, I use expensive eye cream, I read a lot, I stay up to the wee hours - then sleep until noon whenever I can, I have become more of a homebody, I love 80's hair bands and classic rock, I am on my own path, I don't like drop-in visitors.......if others don't like me or how I live MY life, then they can feel free to excuse themselves from my life.
So many people are focused on pleasing others, meeting expectations, conforming to society expectations, etc... that they aren't being their true selves. They are being or doing what others expect. No one should have to put pressure om themselves to keep up or fit in with other people.
It's not easy to go own your own path. It's different. It's unexpected. For some reason that bothers other people. Personally speaking, breaking away from others expectations and society expectations.....it felt so freeing for me. I no longer worry about whether others like me or not. As long as I am happy and content with myself and my life, that is all that matters.
If other people want to follow an influencer, a friend, a neighbor, a colleague, society, etc... If others want or need to be similar to someone else. If others need to conform to something. Then good for them. That way of life is not for me.
|
|
|
Post by Basket1lady on Mar 31, 2025 20:28:43 GMT
If we are basing this discussion on how men feel based on social media, I don't see a lot of social media/influencers who are women talking about what a great father a man has the potential to be. I do see a lot of posts about how a guy has to make at least $100,000, $200,000, or even a recent one who said $500,000. He has to be 6', he can't drive a Toyota, he can't send me Instagram Reels... the list goes on. And I don't follow a single make up/skin care/clothing influencer. I follow less than 50 "people" and it's puppies, dog training, authors, and a few midwest comedians.
I don't know of any young women or men who believe this garbage. But if the algorithms are sending this nonsense to my feeds, I can't image what young people are seeing you may be in more of that age demographic.
|
|
|
Post by pantsonfire on Mar 31, 2025 21:25:52 GMT
3rd grade, last year I was allowed to play Little League baseball. Coaches son spit on my cleats and said girls don't belong in baseball. He ad to run laps. A lot of laps. E also sat out a few games. He was mad that a girl got a pitching position and he didn't.
Anyways my parents were tired of the talk among the adults and wouldn't let me play again. They wanted to protect me from the hate.
I must say the women in my life have all been positive. I had one female gymnastics coach that was a bitch but whatever. I didn't let her mouth get to me (basically a scaredy cat can't be a gymnast and I'd never get over the floor beam and be able to do my routine on the regular beam because of my special awareness issues and afraid of falling and getting hurt again.)
Anyways, I have always been attacked by men.
Sophomore science teacher told my mom girls don't belong in honors chem especially being so young. Yes she gave him an earful and honestly it hurt and made me question my abilities and knowledge.
I took it the following year and have over a 110% in the class. But that is when I started to doubt girls could be in sciences (I am a Gen Xer).
Having to prove I am capable has been an ongoing battle even in medical care for the kids. Doctors thinking I don't know shut because I don't have a white coat. Being told I'm going to kill my child and his death will be on my hands.
Even in my business classes being molded by female professors of how to dress and act around male execs. Gross.
Yeah
|
|
|
Post by melanell on Mar 31, 2025 23:11:19 GMT
Oh and I'll just say that I think men of a certain age are very misguided. (By other men) I think a lot of them are doing things to get the ladies. And really the ladies want them to go to therapy and deal with their baggage, help out around the house and do 50% of the childcare. This is what women want and it's far easier to make muscles it seems. I'll take partnership in the dadbod. I agree. And I think it's the same for both heterosexual men as for heterosexual women. Women have these things they feel they need to achieve to attract men, but it's other women putting those ideals into their heads. And it's the same for the men. In both cases people are taking their cues from the wrong people. They're also forgetting to look around and see all the paired up people around them. Couples come in all shapes, sizes, and overall looks, and they often don't share the same look as one another.
|
|
|
Post by mom on Mar 31, 2025 23:29:36 GMT
Ok I’ll sheepishly raise my hand and admit height is a big deal to me - sorry guys! Same. While I don't know that it would be 100% a deal breaker if DH was short, I do feel confident in saying I would not have agreed to go out with him initially had he been short. My first husband was shorter than I was - by just a little - and it was a huge issue that I would rather avoid at all costs going forward. So I married a man who is taller than me enough that it doesn't matter what heels I wear!
|
|
|
Post by dewryce on Apr 1, 2025 1:32:05 GMT
One that stands out the most was my first day of 6th grade, just moved, and I was walking down the aisle leaving the bus and a popular 8th grader came up behind me and said I had fantastic legs but they’d be better if I shaved. I think I was 10. Later that year we were discussing genes and one of the things we looked at were hair on knuckles. Only 2 girls had it so that was great.
My Dad is to blame for the others in trying to build my sister up. He even told me I had thunder thighs (not even close) and that I had competition with my younger sister (very underweight) coming on the scene.
|
|
|
Post by Embri on Apr 1, 2025 1:32:31 GMT
There are absolutely women out there who are intently focused on physical appearance and financial earnings of a potential partner. They also tend to be equally focused on their own appearance, because they know someone who values social standing is going to expect it in return. There's nothing wrong with such an arrangement (trophy husband/wife) assuming both parties are in alignment.
However to present that as the defacto standard that women are looking for? Absolutely not. I'd say number one priority is someone who isn't a physical, emotional nor financial threat. Then someone who's willing to be a partner, in whichever way they both prefer to split responsibilities. Shared values. Kindness, emotional maturity, reliability. A partner has to be a net positive over being single; giving up the freedom to do whatever you want, whenever you want, with fewer obligations and compromises. Looks come a very distant eighth+ place. They may make a good first impression but they're not what's going to seal the deal.
|
|
|
Post by dewryce on Apr 1, 2025 1:48:57 GMT
Ok I’ll sheepishly raise my hand and admit height is a big deal to me - sorry guys! I think I only dated one guy who was under 6' and DH is 6' 3". Height matters to me too. There's nothing wrong with having preferences! But I just don't think it's the "problem" that some men make it out to be. The shorter guys who are loudly proclaiming they want to be married but no women are interested because they're not 6'... there are PLENTY of women out there who don't care about height. Height isn't the reason why no one is interested. Agreed. I also think that if given the choice between a misogynistic a-hole who is 6’5” and good looking and a lovely man who treats her well, but is average looking and 5’10”, the very large majority of women are going to choose the second man to enter into a long term relationship with. The problem is, the guys want the woman who would chose the good looking tall man instead because they are likely vain themselves and prioritize their own looks over more substantial qualities.
|
|
|
Post by Merge on Apr 1, 2025 2:34:58 GMT
Interesting discussion, all. I do get the impression online that a fair number of average looking young men feel owed a hot supermodel type and are frustrated when those women want someone whose looks match their own. I’m sure that happens in the other direction as well, but I don’t see it much.
|
|
|
Post by Embri on Apr 1, 2025 5:55:13 GMT
Interesting discussion, all. I do get the impression online that a fair number of average looking young men feel owed a hot supermodel type and are frustrated when those women want someone whose looks match their own. I’m sure that happens in the other direction as well, but I don’t see it much. Part of it is the only metrics these red pilled boys are looking at are attractiveness & agreeableness. They feel entitled to a sex doll, and don't want a whole person with thoughts, feelings, or heaven forbid opinions.
|
|