No DWTS Thread from 5/11?

I agree! Noah is amazing in every way, but it's time for him to go. He has had a great experience. Engaged...how awesome was that?! But he just can't compete with the other three through no fault of his own.

As far as the other three, they are all wonderful. I'm not sure who I want to win the most. I would be happy with any of them.

I think unfortunately Noah has to go. I think either Riker or Rumer will win.

i agree with yall! Im surprised that I actually like Riker, at first I wasnt a fan but his dancing is captivating and exciting to watch. I also really like Rumer. Nastia is good but just doesnt have the emotion or excitement behind it like the other 2

While Noah has been my favorite all season, and I will be crushed to actually see him go, I do think it's time.  If that is how it goes down I'll be rooting for Rumer or Ryker to take the whole thing, but I have a sneaking suspicion it will be Derek and Nastia, who I am not a fan of at all.

Does anyone else have a crush on Noah like I do? I think he's really hot!!!!

I agree with the OP completely! Respect Noah, think he's awesome but he needs to leave. That being said, I voted Nastia off on our score cards.   I just feel like it will be a shocker plus I cannot stand her. She seems too stuck up and smug. She can dance, yes, but I don't get a really warm and cozy vibe from her.

I LOVE Riker and would like to see him win, but I am a big fan of Rumer's as well. Hope they are the top two!

I honestly do think she was trying not to cry...again.  It really was an emotional night all around and I think she was like "OMG, here I go again!" (meaning crying).  That is just my take on it.  

Besides the actual proposal, Tom Bergeron, with tears in his eyes, asking for a tissue was the best.  I love him.

I would actually like to see Nastia go home next. For me it isn't necessarily about who is the very best dancer, it's a combination of dancing, heart, growth, personality, etc. No, Noah can't do everything his competitors can do due to his disability. But I look at him in terms of what he can do within the confines of his physical issues. I also look at his growth, his heart, everything. My gosh that guy is amazing! Could you imagine what he could have accomplished in this competition if he did have both arms and legs? Every time I see him dancing stiffly with that leg that won't bend, I get all verklempt.

Having said all that though, I really want Rumor to win. But I wouldn't even mind seeing Noah in second.

I'd honestly rather Nastia go than Noah. There is something about that young lady I cannot like.

I like Riker's dancing best, followed by Rumer. But I'd pick Riker over Rumer just because Riker has come so far and he has so much fun that he makes me smile every time he dances.

My favorite dance last night was Nastia's with Len. Usually I find Derek to be too slick, smug and superior. I loved the simplicity and the emotion. Len's swan song.

I don't know how much overlap there is between DWTS peas and Wolf Hall watching peas, but I'm gonna throw this out there anyway. I thought Noah's dance with the bulls had a very "Cardinal Wolsey goes to Hell" vibe. I wonder if Carrie Ann watched Wolf Hall?

Tonight's elimination will probably be between Nastia and Noah. Rooting for Riker for the win! Love his energy, versatility, he is just super entertaining. I don't think Rumer has his range. I would have liked to see her do something soft and romantic, instead of every week being so intense.