|
Post by KelleeM on Jan 2, 2018 16:12:10 GMT
I don’t know if this is a useful thread but seeing as it’s the new year and many of us start dieting, eating healthier, exercising, etc I thought I’d give it a shot.
I’ve done WW, low carb (Dr. Fung), and low calorie diets. I’ve lost a lot of weight more than once. Last year between low cal and low carb I lost about 50 pounds. I went crazy over the holidays and gained some. I’m about 75 pounds from my goal.
Anyone want to share what’s worked for them?
I’m especially interested in hearing from anyone who was overweight or obese for a long time and successfully lost weight and kept it off but I want to hear what everyone has to offer!
|
|
|
Post by KelleeM on Jan 2, 2018 16:27:02 GMT
I’ll start...
I will only be drinking black coffee (it’s my preference anyway) and water. I dislike drinking calories because I enjoy eating too much!
Intermittent fasting has worked well for me. When I’m following my plan I eat my first meal (Greek yogurt, a serving of fruit and a few almonds) at 10 am. Lunch is at noon and I eat a couple of ounces of deli ham or turkey (low salt ham, thin and trim turkey) with raw veggies (Cucumber, cherry or grape tomatoes, celery, carrots...usually two of these) and an apple if I have time. Dinner is at 415-4:45 pm...yes, it’s early but we go to bed early and get up early (I tend to sleep from 8 pm until 3:30 am on weekdays) For dinner I eat protein (usually chicken, beef or pork) veggies and sometimes sweet potato. Dh cooks dinner so my control is limited but I can still make good choices. After dinner I don’t eat again until the next morning at 10:00.
On weekends I do more of the cooking and tend to eat things I really shouldn’t like fried food, rice, pasta, white potatoes, etc. I try really hard to avoid bread. Unfmy dh can eat whatever he wants and doesn’t gain weight. He always has candy around but is good about hiding it from me!
|
|
keithurbanlovinpea
Pearl Clutcher
Flowing with the go...
Posts: 4,313
Jun 29, 2014 3:29:30 GMT
|
Post by keithurbanlovinpea on Jan 2, 2018 17:13:10 GMT
I do a mashup of Weight Watchers, intermittent fasting and following the hunger scale (eating - 2 to +2). I find that I can eat what I want as long as I eat only when hungry, practice portion control and avoid the foods that make my body feel like shit.
I'm a huge believer in no deprivation and that being overweight is about overeating, not about avoiding specific foods.
I also think the mental aspect of weight loss is #1. I love listening to the podcast Losing 100 Pounds with Phit and Phat (Corinne Crabtree) and following her on Facebook. She's quite useful in getting the head game straight.
|
|
|
Post by cmpeter on Jan 2, 2018 17:18:46 GMT
I’ve been doing WW for a little more than a year and lost 70lbs. I managed to only gain .4 over the holidays.
I menu plan on Sundays and shop for the first half of the week. Then on Wed I go back to the store to shop for the next three days. I eat a lot of poultry, seafood and veggies, so I like to buy fresh often. Menu planning is really helpful. I keep all my plans in a small binder and it’s easy to see refer back for old favs and I note the WW points.
I hate exercise but know it’s important. Right before Christmas I re-joined a gym. My goal is to go 5 times a week. I’m including those days in my menu plan. I got a Fitbit for Christmas...it’s definitely motivating me to get up and move. I work a desk job, so it was sad to see my normal step count.
|
|
amom23
Drama Llama

Posts: 5,635
Jun 27, 2014 12:39:18 GMT
|
Post by amom23 on Jan 2, 2018 17:25:11 GMT
My 40's started out great then somewhere in the middle I lost my mind and now am determined to lose the 50# extra that I shouldn't weigh. So this year is about me!
Right after Thanksgiving I started walking daily on the treadmill. Doesn't sound like much, but it was bone ass hard! I kept at it and stumbled upon the Podcast Losing 100lbs with Phit-n-Phat. Total game changer for me. For now I have decided to take advantage of all the free material vs. joining the paid tribe. I am learning how to deal with the mental BS that has caused me to gain weight and hang onto it. No fancy diet plan to adhere to and feel like a failure when you don't. Just some common sense mental support.
I have figured out that eliminating milk/ice cream decreases bloating and stomach aches. Reducing sugar and carbs helps reduce hot flashes. And drinking tons of water helps keep my skin clean and less dry.
|
|
|
Post by Merge on Jan 2, 2018 17:26:30 GMT
I had some success with low carb/IF last year. Derailed a bit over the holidays. I looked over the new WW plan last week and liked its emphasis on protein and veggies/fruits, with some fat. There are a lot of nice, filling things to eat for zero points. I'm starting that today and, when school starts next week, will also go back to a 16:8 IF window most days. I don't personally know anyone IRL who has lost a lot of weight (50+ lbs) and kept it off without surgery. I'm not willing to do surgery. I'm working on being healthier and losing some weight, but if I'm never skinny, so be it. I'd rather be a little fat than have surgery.  My 14 year old is also doing WW with me for the first time. She is struggling with her weight and doctor has recommended a healthy weight loss program. So I'm supporting her in that. I'm glad WW is more balanced and reasonable than it was when I started out - way back in the days of "exchanges." That was super hard to follow. This seems very reasonable.
|
|
|
Post by scrapmaven on Jan 2, 2018 17:31:23 GMT
Kellee, I think the #1 thing is to love yourself and be gentle w/yourself as you go through this process. I hate the diet industry w/a passion. I think it's a multi-billion dollar scam; however, Weight Watchers does offer a sensible program that makes sense. If your insurance covers it or if you can afford it a great nutritionist combined w/therapy can help you diet while learning to make gradual changes so that you are not feeling so overwhelmed or deprived. That's how I lost my weight years ago. We addressed the psychological and physical issues around food. Dieting doesn't mean you can't have xxxxx forever. It means learning to incorporate xxxxx into your diet in moderation and on occasion. You can do this. You've done it. You're doing it slowly and that's a major key to keeping it off.
|
|
Anita
Drama Llama

Posts: 5,891
Location: Kansas City -ish
Jun 27, 2014 2:38:58 GMT
|
Post by Anita on Jan 2, 2018 17:35:05 GMT
I lost over 70 lbs about ten years ago by counting calories and walking. I was keeping it off pretty well until I went back to school. Then I damaged my foot and was unable to walk normally for almost three years. Now I need to re-lose about 40 pounds, but it's harder thanks to age. I am trying something new this time, and that is giving up sugar. I've heard too many things about what it does to your body, so I am going to try my best to go without it for a year just to see what happens with my health and weight.
|
|
|
Post by donna on Jan 2, 2018 17:41:02 GMT
My son was a personal trainer for several years and would encourage his clients to do “meal prep”. We even did it in our home. It takes a little planning but makes life a lot easier. There is a lady on YouTube called Mind Over Munch who has some wonderful ways to meal prep. We also got some great meal prep containers from Amazon.
|
|
|
Post by KelleeM on Jan 2, 2018 17:50:55 GMT
These posts are awesome...this is exactly what I was hoping this thread could do!
I had started listening to the Phit and Phat podcast and need to get back to it. I’m sure I read about it here. My employer is going to provide free WW for all employees starting next week. I’m anxious to read about their changes since I did it last (7 years ago, I think).
My knees have been bothering me for the past couple of weeks and I thinking it’s diet related...sugar and white stuff (bread, pasta, rice) are the big things I’ve been eating that I know I need to cut out again. I hope that will help the knee pain.
|
|
|
Post by KelleeM on Jan 2, 2018 17:54:52 GMT
Merge I am also anti surgery. It’s not the right answer for me although I know it is for many people. I will never be skinny but want to be healthy. In order to qualify for lower health insurance rates I have to have biometric screening done every year. This past year my BMI was more than 10% lower than the previous year which was a win for me because my weight is way beyond the healthy range they set.
|
|
|
Post by SallyPA on Jan 2, 2018 17:58:42 GMT
I joined WW last fall. I was very successful on low carb as far as weight loss, but I enjoy healthy carbs like oatmeal and fruit and whole grains too much for low carb to be sustainable for me (it is for many people tho!). So WW has been a perfect fit for me as far as enjoying those and learning portion control. Im not in love with the new freestyle program, but I'm working to find my groove.
|
|
|
Post by alexa11 on Jan 2, 2018 18:02:50 GMT
I think consistency is the key- whatever "plan" you do. I know you have to change it up a bit when your body gets used to what you're doing. I do intermittent fasting, along with low carb-lazy keto. I had sugar over the holidays and felt like crap- so not worth it. I work out several days a week, but need to switch that up- kind of in a rut. I still have that 5 lbs that won't budge or if it does it comes right back...
|
|
keithurbanlovinpea
Pearl Clutcher
Flowing with the go...
Posts: 4,313
Jun 29, 2014 3:29:30 GMT
|
Post by keithurbanlovinpea on Jan 2, 2018 18:06:13 GMT
I had some success with low carb/IF last year. Derailed a bit over the holidays. I looked over the new WW plan last week and liked its emphasis on protein and veggies/fruits, with some fat. There are a lot of nice, filling things to eat for zero points. I'm starting that today and, when school starts next week, will also go back to a 16:8 IF window most days. I don't personally know anyone IRL who has lost a lot of weight (50+ lbs) and kept it off without surgery. I'm not willing to do surgery. I'm working on being healthier and losing some weight, but if I'm never skinny, so be it. I'd rather be a little fat than have surgery.  My 14 year old is also doing WW with me for the first time. She is struggling with her weight and doctor has recommended a healthy weight loss program. So I'm supporting her in that. I'm glad WW is more balanced and reasonable than it was when I started out - way back in the days of "exchanges." That was super hard to follow. This seems very reasonable. I lost 45 pounds almost 11 years ago and have not gained it back. In fact, this year I lost an additional 6-8 pounds. It's possible to lose weight and maintain. Easy? No, but not impossible
|
|
|
Post by monklady123 on Jan 2, 2018 18:08:46 GMT
I'll have to check out that podcast that several of you mentioned, the Phit and Phat one. I'm determined to get back into shape now that the holidays are over. I really went overboard with sweets this year. Ugh. Pie, cheesecake, etc. Double ugh. The thing I don't like about WW is the long list of "free" foods....no points which is good, but they do have calories. And if you eat enough of the "free" foods you've added quite a few calories without taking them into account. So for me it works better to count calories. I haven't decided yet what approach I'm going to take. I was doing great on the fasting thing back when the group here first started, but I couldn't sustain it once school started. I just couldn't run around after kids and not eat something. And it was too difficult to figure a fasting window when my lunch time varies so much. If I'm in kindergarten the lunch is 10:40, and 5th grade is 12:30. That's a pretty big window, especially since I can't eat dinner until 6:30 or 7:00 if I want to eat with my husband. One thing I KNOW I need to do is exercise. I hate to exercise.  I know the key is finding something we like to do for exercise. i've never found that yet. I did join our local community center which has a good gym, so now I just need to get there. Which is the problem because I don't have time to go there before school, and I don't have the desire to go there afterwards. Yeah, excuses excuses. I just need a new mindset and I haven't figured out how to get that yet.
|
|
|
Post by jumperhop on Jan 2, 2018 18:12:43 GMT
The Dr suggested I put my DS on a low carb diet. This seems impossible for a teenager with a household with carb eaters he stared today and honestly I am feeling a little overwhelmed. Luckily my DS seems really excited which is motivating me. I think I will do Atkins with lean proteins. Two weeks of 20 carbs per day then start adding more fruits and cottage cheese into his diet. Any low carb advice would be appreciated. Jen
|
|
|
Post by alexa11 on Jan 2, 2018 18:18:21 GMT
Any low carb advice would be appreciated. Keep your healthy fats up so your energy doesn't bottom out.
|
|
stittsygirl
Pearl Clutcher
Posts: 3,664
Location: In the leaves and rain.
Jun 25, 2014 19:57:33 GMT
|
Post by stittsygirl on Jan 2, 2018 18:21:48 GMT
If I shouldn’t eat it I don’t buy it. It’s easier for me to walk away from it at the grocery store than it is to walk away from it in my fridge or on my pantry shelf. I’ve learned I’m one that can’t count calories, carbs, etc. because it makes me obsess over the food I’m eating. IF is easier for me to do, and then I just eat as healthy as I can during the hours I eat. I can go about 10-12 hours, but any longer than that I start to feel it in my brain. I don’t deny myself treats, but I will usually wait until I have a good reason to indulge, such as a birthday or something. Protein is my friend. Sugar and other refined carbs aren’t. I definitely feel it when I’ve had too many carbs. I just hurt all over now. I eat a lot of eggs though. And shrimp. I’ve lost 60 lbs. and I have kept it off pretty easily over the past year (200 to 140 now). I’m fortunate to have a job that keeps me very busy on my feet for 10 hours a night though, but that’s only for seven days at a time. During my week off I try to get 4-6 miles on the treadmill in every night. I walk/jog to all sorts of music videos on my iPad, and vary the speed and incline of my treadmill workout based on the beat of the song I’m watching the video for (fast song - high speed/low incline, slow song - slow speed/high incline). I put the videos on shuffle, so I get a different workout every time. Varying the intensity and incline levels like that works much better for me than just walking/jogging at one speed the whole time, and it makes the time go by faster than just listening to music alone. I’m also working with a trainer to attain another goal. It’s not good for weight loss but it is helping me become stronger. I did lose a lot of weight and then gained it all back several years ago. I know where I failed there and I’m determined that won’t happen again  .
|
|
The Birdhouse Lady
Prolific Pea
 
Moose. It's what's for dinner.
Posts: 7,589
Location: Alaska -The Last Frontier
Jun 30, 2014 17:15:19 GMT
|
Post by The Birdhouse Lady on Jan 2, 2018 18:46:25 GMT
I will be following this thread.
I have started a clean eating program with my daughter. I gained about 15 pounds last year with the stress from my daughters health issue.
So far I have had a headache for close to 24 hours. I know it is my body detoxing from all the crap I have been feeding it. It will get better and this will be a lot easier.
|
|
|
Post by Merge on Jan 2, 2018 18:59:30 GMT
Low carbers, make sure that in addition to eating enough fat, you're also getting plenty of electrolytes. That will help a lot with the 'carb flu.'
|
|
maryannscraps
Pearl Clutcher
Posts: 4,948
Aug 28, 2017 12:51:28 GMT
|
Post by maryannscraps on Jan 2, 2018 19:08:30 GMT
I read an interesting article in the NYT this morning NYT on resolutions. I'm going to have to think about how to apply to my eating habits. I lost about 25 lbs the second half of 2016, and would like to continue with what I was doing. I was eating lower carb, and vaguely following the South Beach Diet. I wasn't super strict, but it made a huge difference from where I was before. I need to add a different exercise -- I decided I didn't like my gym anymore, and I wasn't using it, so I cancelled the membership. I'm doing some HIIT and Yoga videos, but need to be more consistent. I love to walk, but not in 0-degree weather!
|
|
Deleted
Posts: 0
Aug 18, 2025 21:33:09 GMT
|
Post by Deleted on Jan 2, 2018 19:15:33 GMT
I had some success with low carb/IF last year. Derailed a bit over the holidays. I looked over the new WW plan last week and liked its emphasis on protein and veggies/fruits, with some fat. There are a lot of nice, filling things to eat for zero points. I'm starting that today and, when school starts next week, will also go back to a 16:8 IF window most days. I don't personally know anyone IRL who has lost a lot of weight (50+ lbs) and kept it off without surgery. I'm not willing to do surgery. I'm working on being healthier and losing some weight, but if I'm never skinny, so be it. I'd rather be a little fat than have surgery.  My 14 year old is also doing WW with me for the first time. She is struggling with her weight and doctor has recommended a healthy weight loss program. So I'm supporting her in that. I'm glad WW is more balanced and reasonable than it was when I started out - way back in the days of "exchanges." That was super hard to follow. This seems very reasonable. Do you belong to WW online? I'd like to see what their current plan is like but I don't want to make a major investment, so not sure how to do that. I have two friends who each lost 100 lbs within the past 5 years; one had surgery, one did not. Both exercise a lot, every day. That means walking for one, running for the other. I think that has to be key to getting it off and keeping it off. I've been too sedentary over the past six months and 10 lbs has crept up on me. I know I need to get my keyster moving.
|
|
|
Post by Merge on Jan 2, 2018 19:35:51 GMT
I had some success with low carb/IF last year. Derailed a bit over the holidays. I looked over the new WW plan last week and liked its emphasis on protein and veggies/fruits, with some fat. There are a lot of nice, filling things to eat for zero points. I'm starting that today and, when school starts next week, will also go back to a 16:8 IF window most days. I don't personally know anyone IRL who has lost a lot of weight (50+ lbs) and kept it off without surgery. I'm not willing to do surgery. I'm working on being healthier and losing some weight, but if I'm never skinny, so be it. I'd rather be a little fat than have surgery.  My 14 year old is also doing WW with me for the first time. She is struggling with her weight and doctor has recommended a healthy weight loss program. So I'm supporting her in that. I'm glad WW is more balanced and reasonable than it was when I started out - way back in the days of "exchanges." That was super hard to follow. This seems very reasonable. Do you belong to WW online? I'd like to see what their current plan is like but I don't want to make a major investment, so not sure how to do that. I have two friends who each lost 100 lbs within the past 5 years; one had surgery, one did not. Both exercise a lot, every day. That means walking for one, running for the other. I think that has to be key to getting it off and keeping it off. I've been too sedentary over the past six months and 10 lbs has crept up on me. I know I need to get my keyster moving. Yes, I joined online. You can join for a month for $20 to see how it works and how you like it. What I can tell you for free is that chicken breast, turkey breast (plain cooked, not deli meats), whole eggs, and plain, nonfat greek yogurt are all 0 points, in addition to all fruits and vegetables (including peas and corn but not potatoes). Beans and lentils are also 0 points. That gives you a lot of stuff to eat for nothing! LOL Then you get fewer points per day than you used to, to be spent on items that need to be more limited. I notice that high sugar or refined carb items are higher in points than they used to be. High fat items like oil seem to be about the same as before. This seems to be trending the right way to me, guiding you to choose low-glycemic foods overall. I can see how someone who eats too much fruit might get into trouble and need to watch their intake, but I'm not a huge fruit eater anyway. And of course, they tell you to pay attention to feelings of fullness when eating your zero point foods, and not just eat mindlessly or until you are stuffed. That's a good habit to get into no matter what eating plan you follow. Exercise is a big issue for me. One I'm still working on.  My goal for this month is consistency rather than pushing for a certain amount of time or number of miles.
|
|
|
Post by colleen on Jan 2, 2018 20:03:24 GMT
One thing I KNOW I need to do is exercise. I hate to exercise.  I know the key is finding something we like to do for exercise. i've never found that yet. I did join our local community center which has a good gym, so now I just need to get there. Which is the problem because I don't have time to go there before school, and I don't have the desire to go there afterwards. Yeah, excuses excuses. I just need a new mindset and I haven't figured out how to get that yet. Finding exercise that works for you is SO hard. I like walking because I can do it with or without other people and pretty much anywhere. I think, as someone said above, consistency is key. I just do it now, like brushing my teeth. I have recently added Pilates three or four times a week and I really enjoy it. I also want to say that I think exercise is not key to weight loss (at least not for me), but is essential to maintaining my weight.
|
|
tuesdaysgone
Pearl Clutcher
Posts: 4,832
Jun 26, 2014 18:26:03 GMT
|
Post by tuesdaysgone on Jan 2, 2018 20:51:56 GMT
I'm back on WW because I know it works. My weight loss goals are modest (10 to 12 pounds) but still a struggle for me. I KNOW the right things to do and how to eat (don't we all?!), but I guess I need the accountability. This thread is a great idea KelleeM and makes me miss Brandy who did such an inspiring job keeping us motivated to live healthy.
|
|
|
Post by KelleeM on Jan 2, 2018 20:59:54 GMT
I'm back on WW because I know it works. My weight loss goals are modest (10 to 12 pounds) but still a struggle for me. I KNOW the right things to do and how to eat (don't we all?!), but I guess I need the accountability. This thread is a great idea KelleeM and makes me miss Brandy who did such an inspiring job keeping us motivated to live healthy. I miss Brandy too! I’m Facebook friends with her (I also don’t live too far from her and have met her in person). She is an awesome motivator!
|
|
keithurbanlovinpea
Pearl Clutcher
Flowing with the go...
Posts: 4,313
Jun 29, 2014 3:29:30 GMT
|
Post by keithurbanlovinpea on Jan 2, 2018 21:10:03 GMT
I had some success with low carb/IF last year. Derailed a bit over the holidays. I looked over the new WW plan last week and liked its emphasis on protein and veggies/fruits, with some fat. There are a lot of nice, filling things to eat for zero points. I'm starting that today and, when school starts next week, will also go back to a 16:8 IF window most days. I don't personally know anyone IRL who has lost a lot of weight (50+ lbs) and kept it off without surgery. I'm not willing to do surgery. I'm working on being healthier and losing some weight, but if I'm never skinny, so be it. I'd rather be a little fat than have surgery.  My 14 year old is also doing WW with me for the first time. She is struggling with her weight and doctor has recommended a healthy weight loss program. So I'm supporting her in that. I'm glad WW is more balanced and reasonable than it was when I started out - way back in the days of "exchanges." That was super hard to follow. This seems very reasonable. Do you belong to WW online? I'd like to see what their current plan is like but I don't want to make a major investment, so not sure how to do that. I have two friends who each lost 100 lbs within the past 5 years; one had surgery, one did not. Both exercise a lot, every day. That means walking for one, running for the other. I think that has to be key to getting it off and keeping it off. I've been too sedentary over the past six months and 10 lbs has crept up on me. I know I need to get my keyster moving. I don't believe intense or everyday exercising is the key. I've kept off 45+ pounds for 10 years. I exercise at best once a week. I only do it to get a break and feel good. Weight loss is made in the kitchen, not the gym. I also believe it is very mental. Overeating is very common, especially in women even ones who eat healthy. I can lose weight or maintain eating anything. I just can't do it eating everything
|
|
Deleted
Posts: 0
Aug 18, 2025 21:33:09 GMT
|
Post by Deleted on Jan 2, 2018 21:21:25 GMT
Do you belong to WW online? I'd like to see what their current plan is like but I don't want to make a major investment, so not sure how to do that. I have two friends who each lost 100 lbs within the past 5 years; one had surgery, one did not. Both exercise a lot, every day. That means walking for one, running for the other. I think that has to be key to getting it off and keeping it off. I've been too sedentary over the past six months and 10 lbs has crept up on me. I know I need to get my keyster moving. Yes, I joined online. You can join for a month for $20 to see how it works and how you like it. What I can tell you for free is that chicken breast, turkey breast (plain cooked, not deli meats), whole eggs, and plain, nonfat greek yogurt are all 0 points, in addition to all fruits and vegetables (including peas and corn but not potatoes). Beans and lentils are also 0 points. That gives you a lot of stuff to eat for nothing! LOL Then you get fewer points per day than you used to, to be spent on items that need to be more limited. I notice that high sugar or refined carb items are higher in points than they used to be. High fat items like oil seem to be about the same as before. This seems to be trending the right way to me, guiding you to choose low-glycemic foods overall. I can see how someone who eats too much fruit might get into trouble and need to watch their intake, but I'm not a huge fruit eater anyway. And of course, they tell you to pay attention to feelings of fullness when eating your zero point foods, and not just eat mindlessly or until you are stuffed. That's a good habit to get into no matter what eating plan you follow. Exercise is a big issue for me. One I'm still working on.  My goal for this month is consistency rather than pushing for a certain amount of time or number of miles. Thanks; I'm hypothyroid and hypoglycemic, so it might work for me. In general I have to combine diet + exercise in order to get enough metabolic to lose weight. It's so true about paying attention to feeling full. WW just might be the jumpstart I need.
|
|
Deleted
Posts: 0
Aug 18, 2025 21:33:09 GMT
|
Post by Deleted on Jan 2, 2018 22:05:13 GMT
Whole 30. Lost 15 pounds. I am still eating mostly whole 30, and weight still going down.
|
|
|
Post by bessieb on Jan 2, 2018 22:17:05 GMT
I’m doing CWP ( Cambridge weight loss plan). Have lost 50 lbs so far since September and about 60-70 to go. It’s very restrictive but a double win as recent research has shown it can reverse type 2 diabetes in most patients(compared with very few who lost weight on a low calorie/low fat diet) I have been on the borderline for a couple of years and now all the blood tests are well within the normal range.
|
|