What do you keep buying, even if you have too many

Sock yarn. It doesn't cost much, you only need one skein, and it comes in so many pretty colors. Forget that I could clothe an entire village (well, their feet at least) with what I already have.

candleangie, your collection reminds me of my BFF. In his house there are 3 acoustic, 4 electric, 2 mandolins and 2 banjos. He lives alone... My DS also seems to accumulate guitars. He has 2 acoustic, 3 electric, 2 bass, 1 mandolin and 1 innocuous little ukulele. Oh, and there’s a violin up there somewhere too, but he knows he can only practise it in the shed. 

I keep buying bamboo socks, jigsaw puzzles, dies, and 6x6 paper pads. Sometimes all in the one day. 

I'll never chastise someone for their great "finds"!!  If you're happy, then you'll find room for it!  (Really--5 people in an 1100 sq ft place?  Kudos to you!  We're 4 people in a 1495 sq ft home and it's not big enough!).  

Anyway, my item would have to be shoes, of any kind--boots, sandals, heels, etc........  I have quite the collection and I've dragged it from my house in NY, to NJ (in with my wonderful fiancé, who rented me a storage unit!) to FL where there's lots of walk-in closets.  I have collections of dishes too, and clothes, but I try to weed through things every time we move.  I've found that if something has meaning to you, then, keep it!  You're fine!

Lip balm, toilet paper, pajamas for the kids.

we have a ridiculous amount of these things, yet I keep buying more.

Lego.

China. I have probably eight sets in my cupboards besides our daily use set of Blue Willow. There are another two-three sets packed away in the attic. In my defense, I do use them all - I love to set a pretty table and we entertain a lot. Plus working for an auction house, I can pick them up very reasonably. I bought a full set of Minton last year for less than $100.

Scrapbook paper.

I still love buying scrapbook supplies, especially printed paper.

body wash. I have an entire drawer full of it - enough to last me about 3 years. But I keep buying more

Pajamas. I love to lounge in my pajamas after work and on weekends.

Any food item that may be discontinued because it is not mainstream.

I have 6 jars of piquillo and artichoke spread that we put on pizza. Kroger discontinued it and it was a house brand.

I probably could make it by grinding up some piquillo peppers and artichokes along with some pizza sauce. Or just put the vegetables on top of the darn pizza that already has the pizza sauce on it.

I will cry when my jars are gone.

Great thread.

Right now I would say I keep buying too many hair, makeup and skin care products. I guess I’m still looking for the magical product that will turn me into a supermodel! Lol

Planner stickers (OMGosh, so many planner stickers. )
Lipsense (however it's been awhile; maybe I've got this one under control. LOL)

I'm trying to evenly distribute my crazy purchases. I will say I only consider them crazy as I have no storage space for them, and we are still trying to re-do this house. So I go in spurts between china, glassware, serviceware, tea towels/kitchen towels, and table linens. My newest is rugs and futon covers and throw pillows. Although I'm suppose to be buying fabric to make pillow covers so I'm not storing pillows. So add fabric in there. (I did buy several valentine styled fabrics for this purpose and for a table runner back in January and haven't touched them.)

Let's not even talk about scrapbooking supplies.

I'm mainly envious of the amount of storage space you must have!!