What is your favorite ice cream flavor? Discuss

Vanilla... I know people will roll their eyes. Bit it's my favorite, any vanilla

I love a good creamy chocolate ice cream with peanut butter all throughout!

But my absolute favorite that I can only get SOMETIMES at a local ice cream shop is peanut butter ice cream with captain crunch PB cereal in it. The ice cream softens the outside of the cereal a bit, but it still has a good crunch to it! They change flavors daily as they run out of a flavor, and the PB crunch is apparently not very popular so it is a rarity I get to have it. But when I do it is something I think about for days!

Is this actual pudding?  As a kid we had homemade pudding pops a lot.  Just regular pudding frozen in Dixie cups with a popsicle stick.  I loved those.  I would love to try this. May have to take a trip to Rhode Island sometime soon.  😄

Thanks for the information…but no thanks.  😆. Rum raisin is not one of my favorites. 

It really depends on where I’m getting the ice cream from. If we’re going to the local place at home I almost always pick white chocolate raspberry. It’s white chocolate ice cream base with tiny little dark chocolate cups with raspberry filling and ribbons of raspberry throughout. Local place at the lake cabin, I usually get Coconut Joy which is coconut ice cream with dark chocolate chunks and dark chocolate ribbons. If I’m at Coldstone, I usually pick Founder’s Favorite. If I’m at Culver’s (which is technically frozen custard, but still) I always get a turtle sundae. Grocery store ice cream is kind of a crapshoot depending on what they have. I usually then will look for something with chocolate chunks, waffle cone pieces, brownie pieces, caramel or any combination of those. I prefer the more premium brands like Ben & Jerry’s, Talenti or Edy’s in a pinch. I can’t eat Dairy Queen or McDonald’s type of soft serve at all. There’s something in it that makes me violently ill so I have to pass no matter how much I want to eat it.

I also have a Cuisinart ice cream maker at home and a Ninja Creami machine at the lake cabin and have been known to whip up different variations depending on what sounds good and what we have on hand at the time to throw in at the end as mix ins.

I love vanilla. But I'll try other flavors too. My DDs university (UMD) has a dairy and they make flavors based on the coachs' favorites. It's so fun.

Ice cream is number one in my book. Do not care for chocolate or ice creams with pieces or chunks of chocolate. Favorite in order of how favorite are;
- Carvel soft serve vanilla
- Haagen Daz Vanilla
- Haagen Daz Strawberry
- Though I don't like chocolate, Haagen Daz Rocky Road

Pralines and Cream has long been a favourite of mine if we are out and buying ice cream for a treat. Anything with that salty, caramel sweet going on has my vote.

Buying for home our favourite is by Chapmans - an Ontario company. They make a salted caramel - they fill the tub with vanilla, and then as it moves down the line (this is how I imagine it) it gets stabbed by a whole bunch of thin tubes that inject the salted caramel into the tub from top to bottom. So instead of a swirl, it is more like sticks c caramel - when you open the tub it looks polka dotted. SO yummy!

I love butter pecan.

Licorice! Or strawberry Or Black Cherry!

My go to is mint chocolate chip. I also like butter pecan, strawberry, coffee and sherbet.

About 18 years ago while pregnant, Edys made a tropical sherbet that I couldn’t get enough of. I always look but don’t find it. It was so much better than rainbow sherbet.

If I get soft serve then it’s vanilla. If it is DQ then a chocolate dip is a favorite, or the peanut buster parfait. They’ve jacked the price up on that so much that I won’t buy it any more. Strawberry sundaes are good.

McDonald’s had good hot fudge sundaes with nuts. I don’t buy them since there are no nuts.

I’m watching the price in the ninja Creami. Not sure I need another gadget, or if is really enjoy a healthier ice cream high in protein.

I want to come back and read the other threads but for now here is mine:

Friendly's Almond Joy - I have no idea if they still make this as we don't have Friendly's stores here but I used to get it when traveling and still remember how much I loved this.

Dairio's and Kilwin's Smores. Their versions are different but both delicious.

If I buy store bought, I usually just get chocolate these days. I used to get Mayfield's Brown Cow and all kinds of flavors with chocolate, almonds, chocolate chunks, brownie chunks. You see a chocolate theme here. Unfortunately, chunky ice cream is not the best choice if you have TMJ. I've also cut back on the ice cream as a way to reduce cholesterol. I still have a sweet but I just can't control my ice cream consumption at home.

We've been eating LOTS of ice cream and I've tried many new (to me) flavors.  Right now it's a toss up between White Chocolate Raspberry and Salted Caramel Pretzel Path.  I just checked my freezer--there are 12 (!) cartons of ice cream in varying flavors in there.  But in my defense (really, do I need to defend? I think not-LOL) it's because we bought for a get together held on Sunday and not much got eaten as there was so much other food and dessert there.