|
Post by hop2 on Sept 28, 2024 11:49:31 GMT
What has been paying for your in-laws care up until now? Does the estate owe money to Medicare?
The one thing I do know is that Medicare can & WILL go to the estate for the money owed. Btdt
I willl also like the peas above recommend talking to someone with expertise in estate law in that state.
|
|
|
Post by Bridget in MD on Sept 28, 2024 13:25:31 GMT
What has been paying for your in-laws care up until now? Does the estate owe money to Medicare? The one thing I do know is that Medicare can & WILL go to the estate for the money owed. Btdt I willl also like the peas above recommend talking to someone with expertise in estate law in that state. From what I understand she has money saved but they haven’t had to touch it. She gets social security and that’s what they have been using.
|
|
|
Post by jill8909 on Sept 28, 2024 13:56:45 GMT
There's legal and family stuff here.
Let's start with some legal. "estate" is a legal term meaning the property that passes AFTER someone dies. Right now, the house is your MIL's and, unless someone has been appointed guardian or power of attorney, she can do what she wants with the house. In other words, she can sign it over to her daughter without your husband's approval. It's not an estate.
The advice above to consult an elder law attorney is SPOT ON. I think your husband should talk to his sister and recommend this and if the MIL doesn't do it herself then he should do it in the state where the house is. Ideally he and his sister and the half brother would see the lawyer together but at least your husband.
You will want to know the effect any transfer of the house BEFORE SHE DIES has on her ability to get Medicaid. This is absolutely critical. Your MIL and SIL may think that she can stay in that house until she dies but there is a decent chance she is going to need nursing home care (not skilled nursing - that's rehab) but custodial nursing home care. The government will consider the house hers if it is transferred to someone else within 5 years before she needs Medicaid. (at least that was the law a few years ago.).
It is in everyone's interest to consult the attorney. The attorney should be advising the kids OR the mother. Their interests differ.
Family - does your husband trust his sister to take care of the mom once the house is in the sister's name? If so, I would be grateful to have someone do that. But things happen. The mom could end up being in a nursing home. The sister could die and then her husband and/or kids own the house and are they going to take care of the mom?
Bottom line - see a lawyer, hope for the best.
|
|
|
Post by jill8909 on Sept 28, 2024 13:58:22 GMT
What has been paying for your in-laws care up until now? Does the estate owe money to Medicare? The one thing I do know is that Medicare can & WILL go to the estate for the money owed. Btdt I willl also like the peas above recommend talking to someone with expertise in estate law in that state. I think you mean Medicaid, not Medicare. Medicare pays for SHORT term stays in skilled nursing homes, also known as rehab. Medicaid pays for long term stays in a regular (custodial) nursing home. The MIL is living in a private home, I suspect she's paying out of pocket
|
|
|
Post by worrywart on Sept 28, 2024 14:15:51 GMT
I'm not sure that SIL and her dh understand the immense amount of care an elderly person needs. The cost for in home care 24 hours - even 16 hours a day can run easily over 10,000 a month. Even with care, do they want a caregiver living in 'their' home most of the time?
I do not think that fixing up the house with MIL money at this point is anything that your dh or his 1/2 brother should agree to. I'm sorry this is a lot to deal with in an already hard situation.
|
|
|
Post by littlemama on Sept 28, 2024 14:48:00 GMT
I would involve an expert, legal with estate, probate and tax knowledge for the state in question. You need to make decisions collectively with the correct information to avoid issues in the future. Is you MIL capable of making decisions? Has anyone got power of attorney? No, she has dementia. My SIL is their POA for medical and financial. The dementia to me means that she needs far more care than can be given at home. She is settled at the care home and that is likely the best place for her, assuming they have proper memory care procedures in place. If this half-sibling comes from the mom, he absolutely needs to be involved in these conversations. Your dh needs to slow down before agreeing to anything. An elder care attorney should be retained and all interested parties should meet with them.
|
|
|
Post by Bridget in MD on Sept 28, 2024 19:26:50 GMT
No, she has dementia. My SIL is their POA for medical and financial. The dementia to me means that she needs far more care than can be given at home. She is settled at the care home and that is likely the best place for her, assuming they have proper memory care procedures in place. If this half-sibling comes from the mom, he absolutely needs to be involved in these conversations. Your dh needs to slow down before agreeing to anything. An elder care attorney should be retained and all interested parties should meet with them. DH and SIL share the same parents. They shared the same father with the half brother. SIL has POA but I don’t think it is a guardianship or conservatorship. From what I understand my MIL is completely wheelchair bound. She is not a flight risk bc she can’t actually move without help. She is totally dependant on her caregivers. This is why I think they need to give her more care than they think or or she may end up not staying out of a facility for long bc they need more specialized care for her.
|
|
|
Post by jill8909 on Sept 28, 2024 19:58:44 GMT
Just wanted to add that I am so sorry. Getting old sucks.We took care of my mother for many years in our home and spent hundreds of thousands on home reno and caretakers.
There are no great solutions, just the best of bad ones. hang in there
|
|
|
Post by mom on Sept 28, 2024 21:53:26 GMT
Honestly, I think it's important to remember that a POA has a fiduciary duty to protect MIL interests and needs. And not doing so could be a form of elder abuse.
|
|
|
Post by crazy4scraps on Sept 29, 2024 2:18:44 GMT
No, she has dementia. My SIL is their POA for medical and financial. The dementia to me means that she needs far more care than can be given at home. She is settled at the care home and that is likely the best place for her, assuming they have proper memory care procedures in place. If this half-sibling comes from the mom, he absolutely needs to be involved in these conversations. Your dh needs to slow down before agreeing to anything. An elder care attorney should be retained and all interested parties should meet with them. The dementia also means that she is likely no longer of sound mind enough to handle any legal matters for herself anymore. The lawyer needs to be working on mom’s behalf and not for the potential gain of the beneficiaries.
|
|
|
Post by Bridget in MD on Oct 3, 2024 21:21:46 GMT
Update: So SIL and BIL came on Saturday and DH was very quiet until Tuesday. I didnt push but he told me they brought papers to sign and left him. He brought up many of the things I mentioned the peas mentioned here, plus some stuff on reddit. I found a MD website that clearly stated about the 5 yr reach back for medicade, consequences of selling or gifting the house for less than market value, etc. He especially paused when I mentioned what happens if something happens to SIL, she is early 50s and BIL is early 40s - will BIL take care of MIL? They dont have kids. What if her savings runs out? That really seems to make him think. He thinks she has plenty of money, and is currently not using her savings, but using only social security, but I told him, she needs 24 hr care. That can really add up.
He didn't sign anything, and I looked at the paper (which was filled out), this is what they want him to sign:
Affidavit and Consent
I, DH, do swear and affirm under penalty of perjury the following:
1. I am the son of MIL who is legally incompetent.
2. I am a remainder-person in a Life Estate deed with full powers excuted by MIL and FIL (deceased) on XYZ date, and recorded among t he land records of X county address, ("the property")
3. I hearby irrecovably concent to SIL, as POA and Atty in Fact for MIL, exercising such POA to transfer the Property, for no consideration, to SIL and BIL.
4. I understand this this transfer will extinguish any rights I may have in the Property after the death of MIL.
I solemly affirm under the penalities of perjury that the contents of the forgeoing are true, to the best of my knowledge, information, and belief.
Date__________ and then DH's siggy space
So, they were going back to a lawyer with more questions I guess. I asked what does 1/2 brother say about all this, and he said apparently they have been trying to meet with him, but he won't unless his wife is there, and I guess that hasn't happened. It does seem cut and dry, he just gives up his rights to the property, which I guess means if they run thru her money, they either have to possibly sell the house or pay for her care? I don't know if that was discussed, or what happens if she has to go into a facility.
They did say the plan was to just fix/renovate what they needed to get her in the house (ie the bathroom), and then they would do a much more extensive renovation after she passed. They just don't want to put money into a house they don't own...
I am not much feeling better about this... I know DH thinks I am a doomsday thinker, but I feel like he has no idea the costsbut we will keep talking.
|
|
|
Post by epeanymous on Oct 3, 2024 21:59:49 GMT
Genuinely I don't want to meddle in the family business of people I don't know but I think it's not ethical for your SIL to be acting with POA over your MIL's affairs to enrich herself financially. I really think your husband needs to talk to an expert, preferably a lawyer, about the situation.
You're not the only doomsday person here. I'm envisioning what happens if he signs the papers and SIL quickly realizes that MIL needs more care than she can provide and returns MIL to other care.
|
|
MorningPerson
Pearl Clutcher
Posts: 2,549
Location: Central Pennsylvania
Jul 4, 2014 21:35:44 GMT
|
Post by MorningPerson on Oct 3, 2024 22:11:16 GMT
He thinks she has plenty of money, and is currently not using her savings, but using only social security, but I told him, she needs 24 hr care. That can really add up. ****************** I am not much feeling better about this... MIL must be getting a heck of a social security check if she hasn't needed to use any of her savings for her care. I would want to verify this if I were your husband. And as you said, if she ends up needing 24 hour care her expenses will skyrocket. Re: your feelings. I think they are understandable and appropriate in this situation.
|
|
|
Post by revirdsuba99 on Oct 3, 2024 22:27:30 GMT
And what stops SIL/BIL from selling the house and leaving mom to fend for herself? If mom is paying for everything herself and is expected to pay for renovations, SIL/BIL will take care of mom forever and get the house? Her forever could be many years or only 2 weeks.... Her quality of care could determine her forever also...
Your DH needs to talk the his lawyer. He needs to make some decisions, hard ones. What happens if the money is gone and mom needs more and longer care, is he willing to pay while SIL/BIL walk?
Or IF mom's forever is short they are being paid extremely well for short work.
|
|
|
Post by mom on Oct 3, 2024 22:38:07 GMT
iMHO, this is all such a bad idea. Run, run, run.
There are a million different ways this can (and probably will) go sideways that I would not want to touch anything until after MIL is gone. It just feels so wrong that her POA is trying to get her stuff now. If I were your DH, I would tell them that once MIL is gone, then I would agree to give her MIL house (if he still wants to). But as long as she is living, I would not be willing to do anything.
|
|
|
Post by Bridget in MD on Oct 3, 2024 22:49:38 GMT
iMHO, this is all such a bad idea. Run, run, run. There are a million different ways this can (and probably will) go sideways that I would not want to touch anything until after MIL is gone. It just feels so wrong that her POA is trying to get her stuff now. If I were your DH, I would tell them that once MIL is gone, then I would agree to giver her MIL house (if he still wants to). But as long as she is living, I would not be willing to do anything. This is what I said. What is kind of driving the timeline is that both BIL and SIL rent and I believe their leases end April 2025. They are in a wierd situation. My SIL rents a 1 BR apt and my BIL rents a room from his parents. They got married last year and I guess haven’t combined thier households. Now, IMO i don’t think this should drive my DH into making a decision but I understand why they are looking to do this now - so they can make the renovations and move. So while I totally think they should wait and make other decisions, this seems to be the path they want to go.
|
|
|
Post by mom on Oct 3, 2024 23:06:41 GMT
iMHO, this is all such a bad idea. Run, run, run. There are a million different ways this can (and probably will) go sideways that I would not want to touch anything until after MIL is gone. It just feels so wrong that her POA is trying to get her stuff now. If I were your DH, I would tell them that once MIL is gone, then I would agree to giver her MIL house (if he still wants to). But as long as she is living, I would not be willing to do anything. This is what I said. What is kind of driving the timeline is that both BIL and SIL rent and I believe their leases end April 2025. They are in a wierd situation. My SIL rents a 1 BR apt and my BIL rents a room from his parents. They got married last year and I guess haven’t combined thier households. Now, IMO i don’t think this should drive my DH into making a decision but I understand why they are looking to do this now - so they can make the renovations and move. So while I totally think they should wait and make other decisions, this seems to be the path they want to go. Yeah, I can see why they are wanting to make a big move....but I would hold firm in my resolve not to. Their living situation isn't your DH or his MIL problem.
|
|
|
Post by revirdsuba99 on Oct 3, 2024 23:56:54 GMT
Draw up the papers, let them care for mom in lieu of rent and your DH takes on the financial oversight. When Mom dies they buy house if it is left or the house will be sold! That leaves to house available to pay for Mom's care if she goes into a facility.
|
|
|
Post by mommaho on Oct 4, 2024 10:19:17 GMT
Dealing with family can be so hard when a loved one is sick. I was POA, HCPOA and Executor for my Mom who passed a year ago 10/5. My older and only sibling didn't feel I handled anything properly and was very verbal about it 500 miles away. She didn't have the day to day events, appointments, care and really was upset when Mom and I decided to sell her house and got her settled into an assisted living apartment. Mom had just been confined to a wheelchair and sister wanted me to renovate Mom's house so she could stay there but it just wasn't feasible. Mom needed nursing care to include bathroom/shower assistance and help with her medications. I work full time and sibling would come to visit 2 days about 3 times a year. Assisted living is not cheap - but Mom had a good amount of savings, annuities and life insurance policies that we cashed out to make it work. I preplanned her final expenses all with Mom's requests and all of that wasn't the right thing to do according to my sibling. I did what Mom wanted, but it wasn't what she wanted.
Even with dementia she might still have some views of what she wants and if possible honor them.
As others have said, it isn't what makes the best sense for the relatives, it is what is best for MIL even if it is inconvenient for them.
Hugs - this is a hard time of life. Try to encourage your DH to enjoy time with MIL while he can.
|
|
|
Post by epeanymous on Oct 4, 2024 16:00:17 GMT
Draw up the papers, let them care for mom in lieu of rent and your DH takes on the financial oversight. When Mom dies they buy house if it is left or the house will be sold! That leaves to house available to pay for Mom's care if she goes into a facility. It sounds like all of the siblings have a life estate in the house, which means no one would owe anyone rent for living there. They all could in theory live there now. That's what it seems the mom wanted when she had capacity to devise. OP, the more I read here the more uneasy I get, which, again, I feel badly for saying, because I know what it is like to be the spouse where your husband's family is doing some sketchy decisionmaking and you feel like it's only sort of your place to say anything. But the post you made explaining the timing here really raises my antennae, for your MIL's care and well-being. I'm wondering, given the value of the house (considerable) versus the cost of renovating a bathroom to be accessible (my inlaws did that and it was not incredibly expensive) if the better approach here would be for you guys (and perhaps the half-brother) to share the cost for rehabbing the bathroom and leave everything else about your MIL's estate planning unchanged, but only if you guys feel confident this care arrangement is going to work out for MIL in the first place. Having dealt with dementia with my MIL and now dealing with my mother's mental decline, I just have a very difficult time thinking that removing MIL from a supportive facility and caring for her at home is going to work out long-term. It's such hard, expensive, round-the-clock work.
|
|
wellway
Prolific Pea
Posts: 9,040
Jun 25, 2014 20:50:09 GMT
|
Post by wellway on Oct 4, 2024 16:22:01 GMT
This all reads as a way of solving SIL and BIL's housing issues and says nothing about how your MIL's quality of life will be improved by moving back. Is there even an issue with the care she is currently receiving? The time and effort that SIL is putting into doctor appointments etc will pale into insignificance when compared to providing 24 hour care in a family home.
Your MIL's needs and finances should be the only factors considered here.
I won't sign anything. I really think you need a specialist lawyer involved at this stage.
|
|
|
Post by crazy4scraps on Oct 4, 2024 16:28:47 GMT
This all reads as a way of solving SIL and BIL's housing issues and says nothing about how your MIL's quality of life will be improved by moving back. Is there even an issue with the care she is currently receiving? The time and effort that SIL is putting into doctor appointments etc will pale into insignificance when compared to providing 24 hour care in a family home. Your MIL's needs and finances should be the only factors considered here. I won't sign anything. I really think you need a specialist lawyer involved at this stage. This 100%. My mom’s quality of life was vastly improved when we moved her OUT of the family home and into a care facility, simply because there were more people for her to interact with daily and more things there for her to do (and people who would encourage her to do them). When she was at home her life was so closed off and limited because my brother (who lived with her) was so overwhelmed by having to provide round the clock care, and DH and I could only provide respite a few times a week. One other brother would come sit with her from time to time as he was able, but our other siblings were pretty much worthless in regard to providing actual care. What the OP’s in-laws would do here would be the exact opposite, taking mom from a place where she has more daily interaction and things to do into a situation with considerably less of both.
|
|
|
Post by Bridget in MD on Oct 4, 2024 17:12:31 GMT
Draw up the papers, let them care for mom in lieu of rent and your DH takes on the financial oversight. When Mom dies they buy house if it is left or the house will be sold! That leaves to house available to pay for Mom's care if she goes into a facility. It sounds like all of the siblings have a life estate in the house, which means no one would owe anyone rent for living there. They all could in theory live there now. That's what it seems the mom wanted when she had capacity to devise. OP, the more I read here the more uneasy I get, which, again, I feel badly for saying, because I know what it is like to be the spouse where your husband's family is doing some sketchy decisionmaking and you feel like it's only sort of your place to say anything. But the post you made explaining the timing here really raises my antennae, for your MIL's care and well-being. I'm wondering, given the value of the house (considerable) versus the cost of renovating a bathroom to be accessible (my inlaws did that and it was not incredibly expensive) if the better approach here would be for you guys (and perhaps the half-brother) to share the cost for rehabbing the bathroom and leave everything else about your MIL's estate planning unchanged, but only if you guys feel confident this care arrangement is going to work out for MIL in the first place. Having dealt with dementia with my MIL and now dealing with my mother's mental decline, I just have a very difficult time thinking that removing MIL from a supportive facility and caring for her at home is going to work out long-term. It's such hard, expensive, round-the-clock work. Another small update: I just wanted to say thank you to all the peas who have chimed in, please know I have read and shared a lot of thoughts with DH. I asked him about only using social security currently - he said he even questioned that bc he thinks she gets like $2500 in SS, but they should be taking $1500 out a month for her care (the cost of her living situation is roughly $4000). My SIL told him it didn't seem like she was having to take out that much. That raised alarm bells right away to me, and even DH then admitted that he has not asked for proof or statements on what is being spent... he doesnt want to be overbearing or act like he doesn't trust her, but this whole house thing is now putting everything in a different light. To the pea who mentioned, what happens if something happens to my SIL, and now my BIL owns the house that wouldn't even go towards my MILs care? Well, that stopped DH right in his tracks. He told me this morning that the things I have brought up - Medicare, my SIL passing before my MIL, etc, has brought him to the conclusion that he just cannot bring himself to sign that paper. He is kicking himself for not even thinking about this scenario, bc he could have told them in person, and now he feels bad he has to say it over the phone. I brought up the idea also mentioned recently, what if they just moved into the house? That alone saves them money. Then they can save the rent they would be paying to make renovations for when the house becomes theirs (bc DH still feels very strongly that SIL should get the house). He said that was an idea, or they buy the house outright from the estate, fair market price, and then do whatever they want with it, and hope they don't put themselves at risk. But this way, the house remains as his mother's asset, and hopefully will not need to be touched for her care. My MIL is in a fantastic facility, so moving her, IMO is not ideal for her. We wished we had moved both her and FIL into a facility like this much earlier, but they fought it. The interaction with others has been so amazing for her, and care has been top notch. The peace of mind it brings my husband is worth every penny. I truly feel bad and understand why they want to start moving forward with the house, but DH has finally realized that this is not in the best interest for his mom, and that is what has to be the #1 priorty. Like someone said, she may live for 2 weeks or she may live for 10 more years. We need to make sure we do not put her quality of care at risk.
|
|
wellway
Prolific Pea
Posts: 9,040
Jun 25, 2014 20:50:09 GMT
|
Post by wellway on Oct 4, 2024 19:34:13 GMT
This is what I said. What is kind of driving the timeline is that both BIL and SIL rent and I believe their leases end April 2025. They are in a wierd situation. My SIL rents a 1 BR apt and my BIL rents a room from his parents. They got married last year and I guess haven’t combined thier households. Now, IMO i don’t think this should drive my DH into making a decision but I understand why they are looking to do this now - so they can make the renovations and move. So while I totally think they should wait and make other decisions, this seems to be the path they want to go. I'm just being curious so no need to answer if you don't want do. But, why hasn't he moved into her apartment, they only need one bedroom. Are his parents really holding him to a lease? Have they lived together at all since they got married last year?
|
|
|
Post by Bridget in MD on Oct 4, 2024 20:36:41 GMT
This is what I said. What is kind of driving the timeline is that both BIL and SIL rent and I believe their leases end April 2025. They are in a wierd situation. My SIL rents a 1 BR apt and my BIL rents a room from his parents. They got married last year and I guess haven’t combined thier households. Now, IMO i don’t think this should drive my DH into making a decision but I understand why they are looking to do this now - so they can make the renovations and move. So while I totally think they should wait and make other decisions, this seems to be the path they want to go. I'm just being curious so no need to answer if you don't want do. But, why hasn't he moved into her apartment, they only need one bedroom. Are his parents really holding him to a lease? Have they lived together at all since they got married last year? From what I understand, the parents moved into thier current house, which I believe is also a rental? or maybe just a bigger house? And he and his brothers and sisters were still living at home. But, these are all kids in their 40s (he's the youngest), so it's not like they are just coming home from college. Then, I believe in the last couple of years or so, the siblings have gotten married or moved out. My BIL/SIL just celebrated their own 1 yr anniversary this past April. I guess he feels that it was because all the kids were living at home when the parents made the decision to move to that house, and now that they are all gone, he feels obligated? No idea how his parents feel. My SIL is in her 50s, so her apartment was already filled up with her stuff, so I guess he felt there was really no place for him either. I haven't asked, but it sounds like he sleeps over occassionally and other times he stays at his parents.
|
|
MorningPerson
Pearl Clutcher
Posts: 2,549
Location: Central Pennsylvania
Jul 4, 2014 21:35:44 GMT
|
Post by MorningPerson on Oct 5, 2024 1:07:10 GMT
************** My MIL is in a fantastic facility, so moving her, IMO is not ideal for her. We wished we had moved both her and FIL into a facility like this much earlier, but they fought it. The interaction with others has been so amazing for her, and care has been top notch. In my opinion, your SIL should be a whole lot more open about your MIL’s finances, especially since it seems she and your DH have a decent relationship. I was my father’s POA, and I made sure my siblings knew they could have any information they wanted at any time - his bills, sources of income, bank balances etc. I kept them involved every step of the way with any bigger decisions. They very rarely had questions, but I know they appreciated having the ability to understand the whole picture. Your last paragraph above tells me there’s absolutely no reason to move her. It sounds like all the reasons to move her back home are for your SIL and BIL’s benefit only.
|
|
|
Post by mom on Oct 5, 2024 1:42:38 GMT
It sounds like all of the siblings have a life estate in the house, which means no one would owe anyone rent for living there. They all could in theory live there now. That's what it seems the mom wanted when she had capacity to devise. OP, the more I read here the more uneasy I get, which, again, I feel badly for saying, because I know what it is like to be the spouse where your husband's family is doing some sketchy decisionmaking and you feel like it's only sort of your place to say anything. But the post you made explaining the timing here really raises my antennae, for your MIL's care and well-being. I'm wondering, given the value of the house (considerable) versus the cost of renovating a bathroom to be accessible (my inlaws did that and it was not incredibly expensive) if the better approach here would be for you guys (and perhaps the half-brother) to share the cost for rehabbing the bathroom and leave everything else about your MIL's estate planning unchanged, but only if you guys feel confident this care arrangement is going to work out for MIL in the first place. Having dealt with dementia with my MIL and now dealing with my mother's mental decline, I just have a very difficult time thinking that removing MIL from a supportive facility and caring for her at home is going to work out long-term. It's such hard, expensive, round-the-clock work. Another small update: I just wanted to say thank you to all the peas who have chimed in, please know I have read and shared a lot of thoughts with DH. I asked him about only using social security currently - he said he even questioned that bc he thinks she gets like $2500 in SS, but they should be taking $1500 out a month for her care (the cost of her living situation is roughly $4000). My SIL told him it didn't seem like she was having to take out that much. That raised alarm bells right away to me, and even DH then admitted that he has not asked for proof or statements on what is being spent... he doesnt want to be overbearing or act like he doesn't trust her, but this whole house thing is now putting everything in a different light. To the pea who mentioned, what happens if something happens to my SIL, and now my BIL owns the house that wouldn't even go towards my MILs care? Well, that stopped DH right in his tracks. He told me this morning that the things I have brought up - Medicare, my SIL passing before my MIL, etc, has brought him to the conclusion that he just cannot bring himself to sign that paper. He is kicking himself for not even thinking about this scenario, bc he could have told them in person, and now he feels bad he has to say it over the phone. I brought up the idea also mentioned recently, what if they just moved into the house? That alone saves them money. Then they can save the rent they would be paying to make renovations for when the house becomes theirs (bc DH still feels very strongly that SIL should get the house). He said that was an idea, or they buy the house outright from the estate, fair market price, and then do whatever they want with it, and hope they don't put themselves at risk. But this way, the house remains as his mother's asset, and hopefully will not need to be touched for her care. My MIL is in a fantastic facility, so moving her, IMO is not ideal for her. We wished we had moved both her and FIL into a facility like this much earlier, but they fought it. The interaction with others has been so amazing for her, and care has been top notch. The peace of mind it brings my husband is worth every penny. I truly feel bad and understand why they want to start moving forward with the house, but DH has finally realized that this is not in the best interest for his mom, and that is what has to be the #1 priorty. Like someone said, she may live for 2 weeks or she may live for 10 more years. We need to make sure we do not put her quality of care at risk. FWIW, my hinkey meter is still going off about MIL finances. Your husband needs to ask some questions and see real numbers. Yes, it's uncomfortable but also how's he supposed to make an informed decision without real numbers (they dont have to know. yet that you dont want them given the house). There are too many questions about how MIL is paying for things to not be asking some questions, IMHO. You dont have to accuse them of anything, but more like can you show us how all the 'finances work and look like right now'. Also? If SIL and her husband move into mom's house without a legal purchase, you need to set some hard lines --- like a rental agreement or something official that says the house is not theirs and if they chose not to buy the home from the estate at a later date, then they will move out within 30 days or something. You don't want a 'squatter' situation happening where you cant sell it because they are there and they aren't paying whatever bills. I know, I know. Everyone thinks their family member wont destroy the house, wont get into a legal battle over renovation charges that they want paid back. But it happens a lot. I would also require them to carry renters insurance if they choose to live there. I also think any emodeling done will be either on their own dime or agreed upon by all kids if Mom is paying. I can see a situation where they spend a crap ton of money and then demand to be reimbursed even if Mom didn't really want or need the renovations. It's really easy to get carried away in renovations when someone else is paying for the costs.
|
|
|
Post by Bridget in MD on Oct 5, 2024 1:58:30 GMT
FWIW, my hinkey meter is still going off about MIL finances. Your husband needs to ask some questions and see real numbers. Yes, it's uncomfortable but also how's he supposed to make an informed decision without real numbers (they dont have to know. yet that you dont want them given the house). There are too many questions about how MIL is paying for things to not be asking some questions, IMHO. You dont have to accuse them of anything, but more like can you show us how all the 'finances work and look like right now'. Also? If SIL and her husband move into mom's house without a legal purchase, you need to set some hard lines --- like a rental agreement or something official that says the house is not theirs and if they chose not to buy the home from the estate at a later date, then they will move out within 30 days or something. You don't want a 'squatter' situation happening where you cant sell it because they are there and they aren't paying whatever bills. I know, I know. Everyone thinks their family member wont destroy the house, wont get into a legal battle over renovation charges that they want paid back. But it happens a lot. I would also require them to carry renters insurance if they choose to live there. I also think any emodeling done will be either on their own dime or agreed upon by all kids if Mom is paying. I can see a situation where they spend a crap ton of money and then demand to be reimbursed even if Mom didn't really want or need the renovations. It's really easy to get carried away in renovations when someone else is paying for the costs. I agree with you. I am going to try to prep DH before he has his home call on Sunday when he is going to tell them that he is not going to sign the paper, and I assume he may suggest they live there or buy the house or whatever. I suspect they are going to need time to think about it since they assumed DH was going to sign the papers. If they decide to move they will now be 2ish hrs from my MIL, unless they end up moving her too. This is all great advice that I am really taking to heart!
|
|
moodyblue
Drama Llama
Posts: 6,263
Location: Western Illinois
Site Supporter
Jun 26, 2014 21:07:23 GMT
|
Post by moodyblue on Oct 5, 2024 1:59:16 GMT
************** My MIL is in a fantastic facility, so moving her, IMO is not ideal for her. We wished we had moved both her and FIL into a facility like this much earlier, but they fought it. The interaction with others has been so amazing for her, and care has been top notch. In my opinion, your SIL should be a whole lot more open about your MIL’s finances, especially since it seems she and your DH have a decent relationship. I was my father’s POA, and I made sure my siblings knew they could have any information they wanted at any time - his bills, sources of income, bank balances etc. I kept them involved every step of the way with any bigger decisions. They very rarely had questions, but I know they appreciated having the ability to understand the whole picture. Your last paragraph above tells me there’s absolutely no reason to move her. It sounds like all the reasons to move her back home are for your SIL and BIL’s benefit only. I totally agree. Your MIL is in a great place for her and those are not always easy to find. And if she needs that care, providing that in a private home is not easy, and it’s expensive to hire help. It sounds like moving her would NOT be best for her. Your husband needs to know more about the costs of her care and if that is factoring into his sister's desire to bring their mom home. Is she trying to preserve more of her assets so she inherits more? Hoping to get the house secured for herself and not see it be sold to pay for her mom's care? Solve the housing issues for her and her new husband? No way would I be signing anything now, even if you totally trust his sister. There are too many ways this could all go south.
|
|
|
Post by Bridget in MD on Oct 5, 2024 2:08:01 GMT
In my opinion, your SIL should be a whole lot more open about your MIL’s finances, especially since it seems she and your DH have a decent relationship. I was my father’s POA, and I made sure my siblings knew they could have any information they wanted at any time - his bills, sources of income, bank balances etc. I kept them involved every step of the way with any bigger decisions. They very rarely had questions, but I know they appreciated having the ability to understand the whole picture. Your last paragraph above tells me there’s absolutely no reason to move her. It sounds like all the reasons to move her back home are for your SIL and BIL’s benefit only. I totally agree. Your MIL is in a great place for her and those are not always easy to find. And if she needs that care, providing that in a private home is not easy, and it’s expensive to hire help. It sounds like moving her would NOT be best for her. Your husband needs to know more about the costs of her care and if that is factoring into his sister's desire to bring their mom home. Is she trying to preserve more of her assets so she inherits more? Hoping to get the house secured for herself and not see it be sold to pay for her mom's care? Solve the housing issues for her and her new husband? No way would I be signing anything now, even if you totally trust his sister. There are too many ways this could all go south. I don’t know if they think bringing her to the house would be cheaper or just better for her, it sounds like both. And maybe it would be at first but I keep reminding him that could all change if MIL’s care needs change and that is why the house really needs to remain as an asset for her until she doesn’t need it (ie passes). I think they want to stop paying rent, live together, they like the neighbors/neighborhood and want to start living there. The house was built in the 1960s and really needs to be updated for themselves but at the very least if MIL moved there they need to renovate the bathroom. DH is going to say they can either pay for those updates and hope they get thier money back when the estate is settled or they just live there as is. I’m sure it’s frustrating to them to have to wait but the house is not thiers at this time. I honestly do not think they are being malicious. I just don’t think they’ve thought it all thru.
|
|