Anybody have My Pillow? Any "squishy" pillow recommendation?

I only buy down pillows. Everything else it too stiff for me. I am also a stomach sleeper.

Yes, you can shape it how you want it. I've had mine for four years now and I still love it. If it starts to get flat, you can put it in the dryer to re-fluff. I've only ever had to do that 3-4 times.

I haven't slept on my stomach comfortably for a year, but I used to and loved the MyPillow for that. It's great for side sleepers too.

I bought DH one because he flattened all the others so quickly. He's had this one for a year and really likes it.

Mine was bought for me as sort of a "gag gift" because I get such a kick out of infomercial products, but I have to say it's just about my favorite thing ever.

I have one of the travel versions of My Pillow that a friend gave me, and once it’s squished it gets pretty stiff. It’s okay for side sleeping but not so much for stomach sleeping. I flip and flop all night long from side to side to stomach to back, and a few years ago I decided I will ONLY buy down pillows for myself now. The last one I bought was a Kathy Ireland branded one that I got at Tuesday Morning last summer for about $30 and the down fill is very loose and squishy. I fold it in half to sleep on my side and pull it flat to sleep on my stomach. I like it.

The down pillows at Costco are pretty decent too but they only came in a two pack. I bought some of those to take to the lake cabin a couple years ago. I didn’t want to spend $60-70 when I really only needed one.

Another good place to check is Select Comfort Sleep Number stores. I bought a very nice soft down pillow from there before too but they’re pretty expensive. I think I paid about $75-80 for one pillow in the past and that was after the discount.

I've been using this one for 2 years. Still love it.

Amazon has them for 35% off after you add it to your cart. Not sure how long the sale will be.

Amazon pillow

They have an F rating from the Better Business Bureau.

If you’ve loved a hotel pillow, you might be able to buy that same pillow. I’ve done it with Hilton and I know Westin has offerings too. I recently read a thread of disboards where someone found the same pillows used at the Grand Californian online.

I’ve only felt a My Pillow in the store and didn’t care for the chunkiness of the filling. I’m used to down pillows though.

Mine is squishy, get the loosest fill. DH has the medium I think. I didn't buy mine so I didn't pay attention to that but mine is definitely softer than his.

I tried My Pillow which I bought at Bed Bath and Beyond and returned to them for a refund. I tried it several nights but it was lopsided and no amount of 'squishing' could get it even. I don't think it is worth the money.