Olan
Pearl Clutcher
Enter your message here...
Posts: 4,053
Jul 13, 2014 21:23:27 GMT
|
Post by Olan on Jan 23, 2021 23:46:59 GMT
Discuss racism openly Find out how slavery, the civil war, and Jim Crow are being taught in your school district. Advocate that it is taught correctly.This one has been particularly challenging in my district lately. Not because of our teachers or our admin; most of our staff (teachers AND admin) is working hard to counteract the traditional white-centric/white-supremacist narratives that have been so prevalent in education.Ā Parents observing lessons remotely are BIG mad that we are discussing racism with students (including in conjunction with reading To Kill a Mockingbird, a decidedly NOT anti-racist book written by a white woman 60 years ago). They're mad we have prioritized equity and diversity, filing FOIA requests for any emails that contain BLM/Black Lives Matter. I guess their counterargument is that Black lives don't matter? It's fucking exhausting as a white person trying to effect change, and I can "opt out" any time because I'm white; the fact that Black women especially have to do so much lifting is unconscionable.Ā I canāt imagine the exhaustion an educator who canāt get parents on board must feel but I wanted to say thank! This is important necessary work.
|
|
|
Post by SockMonkey on Jan 24, 2021 0:12:37 GMT
Read this yesterday and after doing so, I totally get your comment "It's fucking exhausting as a white person trying to effect change, and I can "opt out" any time because I'm white; the fact that Black women especially have to do so much lifting is unconscionable." linkWhite Rage in action.
|
|
Olan
Pearl Clutcher
Enter your message here...
Posts: 4,053
Jul 13, 2014 21:23:27 GMT
|
Post by Olan on Jan 24, 2021 16:37:52 GMT
In response to your passage that I bolded for emphasis, what would have happened is that white women would have been punished in any number of āniceā, creative ways as they literally had no more legal rights than Black people at that time. They were more socially accepted,Ā yes, obviously, but legally they were at the mercy of their husbands and fathers and dependent upon their goodwill. They were their husband's property and subject to their rules. Standing up to men at that time might have resulted in their medication into submission, threats to separate them/actually separate them from their children, physical violence, institutionalization, among others. Not exactly the breeding ground for social justice action.Ā Never seems to be š¤·š¾āāļø Note: Revisionist history and the unwillingness to confront Americaās past. Also the boldness in which the falsehoods are shared š Mothers of Mass Resistance would be an eye opening read. Elizabeth McRae is the author. I appreciate the candor. I would stew about the motives and now I can just chalk it up to ummm...predictable behavior. FTR I disagree with the āif you donāt like things, why stayā it slaps of 45 supporters telling everyone to like it or leave. If I leave who will continue posting āBlack issuesā Olan I appreciate the info you post and the links. I have found them valuable. But that you feel you are the annointed savior of the Karens of 2 Peas is a bit much. I am eminently capable of edumacating myself by my own little self. Edumacating sounds about right š„“ If someone provided information I found āvaluableā I would be much more gracious in my criticism of them but what the hell do I know about kindness š
|
|
|
Post by aj2hall on Jan 24, 2021 20:25:12 GMT
Iām going to regret this but here goes. I didnāt vote because Iām opposed to reparations and I think black people are perfectly capable of advocating for themselves. No one called her out for this comment? I'm not sure how to respond to her post, but I find it objectionable. eta - Maybe its best just to ignore her? She tends to post something controversial, especially on political threads, then just disappears.
|
|
Olan
Pearl Clutcher
Enter your message here...
Posts: 4,053
Jul 13, 2014 21:23:27 GMT
|
Post by Olan on Jan 24, 2021 20:57:46 GMT
Iām going to regret this but here goes. Ā I didnāt vote because Iām opposed to reparations and I think black people are perfectly capable of advocating for themselves. No one called her out for this comment? Ā I'm not sure how to respond to her post, but I find it objectionable. eta - Maybe its best just to ignore her? Ā She tends to post something controversial, especially on political threads, then just disappears. I purposely ignored her. The most Iāll do is quote because peas have removed comments from my threads after the fact. The biggest part of me values this type of pointed language. Not knowing where I stand with peas always keeps me from engaging in threads that arenāt my own. You will think youāve found community when people object to your right to live freely and shit. I like clean lines. Linda provides em š
|
|
|
Post by SockMonkey on Jan 24, 2021 21:05:10 GMT
Iām going to regret this but here goes. I didnāt vote because Iām opposed to reparations and I think black people are perfectly capable of advocating for themselves. No one called her out for this comment? I'm not sure how to respond to her post, but I find it objectionable. eta - Maybe its best just to ignore her? She tends to post something controversial, especially on political threads, then just disappears. Sometimes you get a vibe for whether or not people are open to changing their thinking. As much as I believe in calling other white folks in as much as possible, there are some people who simply won't be worth the emotional labor, because they've already said who they are. With their whole chest.
|
|
Olan
Pearl Clutcher
Enter your message here...
Posts: 4,053
Jul 13, 2014 21:23:27 GMT
|
Post by Olan on Jan 24, 2021 21:08:29 GMT
For what itās worth I take more issue with people not calling out peano. White women seem to think correcting one another is a pile on. As if private messaging doesnāt work. Trust me I get solidarity and holding rank šbut I will pull a Black women to the side with a loving correction in a second. Youāll see the few Black peas do the same to me.. Peano is smug with it too. Repeat offender evenš³. One thread the work Black women have to do is unconscionable but in another simply to disagree with me she gives a participation trophy to everyone who voted. Guess who becomes the bully when I say sit down with a book and STFU.
|
|
|
Post by SockMonkey on Jan 24, 2021 21:12:22 GMT
For what itās worth I take more issue with people not calling out peano . White women seem to think correcting one another is a pile on. As if private messaging doesnāt work. Trust me I get solidarity and holding rank šbut I will pull a Black women to the side with a loving correction in a second. Youāll see the few Black peas do the same to me.. Peano is smug with it too. Repeat offender evenš³. One thread the work Black women have to do is unconscionable but in another simply to disagree with me she gives a participation trophy to everyone who voted. Guess who becomes the bully when I say sit down with a book and STFU. I'm confused because I couldn't find that comment about being a Karen-savior in this thread, so I'm reading out of context. But, @peano, I would say that as a white woman, you're probably NOT totally capable of educating yourself by yourself on issues around race, and listening to Black women is important. That comment is highly problematic.
|
|
Olan
Pearl Clutcher
Enter your message here...
Posts: 4,053
Jul 13, 2014 21:23:27 GMT
|
Post by Olan on Jan 24, 2021 21:50:43 GMT
Never seems to be š¤·š¾āāļø Note: Revisionist history and the unwillingness to confront Americaās past. Also the boldness in which the falsehoods are shared š Mothers of Mass Resistance would be an eye opening read. Elizabeth McRae is the author. I appreciate the info you post and the links. I have found them valuable. But that you feel you are the annointed savior of the Karens of 2 Peas is a bit much. I am eminently capable of edumacating myself by my own little self. Edumacating sounds about right š„“ If someone provided information I found āvaluableā I would be much more gracious in my criticism of them but what the hell do I know about kindness š Maybe it got loss š¤·š¾āāļøToday peano said while valuable she finds my participation a bit much. She took it even further and said I fancy myself the Savior of Karens. Especially upsetting when my official stance on Karens is they wonāt ever change. And the most effective method physical correction. No recording. No Gayle interviews. I appreciate the info you post and the links. I have found them valuable. But that you feel you are the annointed savior of the Karens of 2 Peas is a bit much. I am eminently capable of edumacating myself by my own little self. Thank you for weighing in. For posterity sake this is the pea who told me white women were powerless and couldnāt exercise any good judgement during chattel slavery. When I explained that wasnāt the case she never came back to acknowledge the misinformation she tried to pass as fact. The thread: 2peasrefugees.boards.net/thread/110444/black-peoplePlease note I donāt give a damn how youāve categorized my participation or what you find valuable. Just last week I posted a lovely video of Toni Morrison where she implores white people to tackle racism without the help of Black women. Iāll bump it.
|
|
melissa25
Junior Member
Posts: 56
Sept 13, 2020 15:02:56 GMT
|
Post by melissa25 on Jan 24, 2021 22:19:44 GMT
I remember in a thread about black men being arrested in a Starbucks I shared an unpopular opinion (š) that allyship really looked more like a human shield to me than anything else. So Iām wondering whatās the consensus on what Black people really need from white allies. I found you something that may help you.
|
|
|
Post by catmom on Jan 24, 2021 22:31:54 GMT
I remember in a thread about black men being arrested in a Starbucks I shared an unpopular opinion (š) that allyship really looked more like a human shield to me than anything else. So Iām wondering whatās the consensus on what Black people really need from white allies. I found you something that may help you. Is this video really in response to the comment above? I even watched a couple minutes of the video because I thought I must have misunderstood. Have I misunderstood something? Because to tell someone who has requested assistance if we see abuse in action is gaslighting and victim blaming and an awful thing to do.
|
|
|
Post by gar on Jan 24, 2021 22:54:17 GMT
Have I misunderstood something? Only that she's a troll.
|
|
|
Post by catmom on Jan 24, 2021 23:16:16 GMT
Have I misunderstood something? Only that she's a troll. Ahhh. Thanks.
|
|
Olan
Pearl Clutcher
Enter your message here...
Posts: 4,053
Jul 13, 2014 21:23:27 GMT
|
Post by Olan on Jan 24, 2021 23:16:26 GMT
The pea pants autocorrect wasnāt intentional but I aināt fixing it
|
|
|
Post by papercrafteradvocate on Jan 25, 2021 1:12:06 GMT
I remember in a thread about black men being arrested in a Starbucks I shared an unpopular opinion (š) that allyship really looked more like a human shield to me than anything else. So Iām wondering whatās the consensus on what Black people really need from white allies. I found you something that may help you. Jesus Christ. You really are a maga trump c^nt.
|
|
Olan
Pearl Clutcher
Enter your message here...
Posts: 4,053
Jul 13, 2014 21:23:27 GMT
|
Post by Olan on Jan 25, 2021 13:29:58 GMT
This thread is feeling like one where some white women are simply refusing to acknowledge their ancestors role in history because then theyād be forced to reconcile the role they play in the racism that is still killing Black people in 2021. Make the connection that back then the only way for white women to exert control over their own financial futures was by owning enslaved Africans. Not pea pants version of things at all. Acknowledge that rape did occur. Probably even more than what was documented because Black men reporting sexual contact with white women meant their bodies were mutilated or hung from trees. Acknowledge that they were not at all powerless in what happened. Powerful instead. That it was sick. To be able to separate a mother from her child. To watch that sort of sexual trauma happen to another woman and do nothing. That way we can examine why Tamir Rice or Breonna Taylor didnāt make white women collectively decided that whatever role they play, they need to change course so Black Mothers can have some peace. That youāve got the same power then that you have now. And you use it by Weaponizing the police or Hopping on a bandwagon to discredit or attack a Black woman you wanna silence. Or being an outraged citizen and nothing else. No fucks to give essentially. Pretending like you arenāt just waiting around for Black people to solve it. If you think I am being harsh I think you are too sis. I canāt even imagine being so uncaring. Like I canāt. I read those old threads and think wow why did they talk to me like that. Ummm duhhhh to avoid the work of it all! There is such inter connectedness. Maybe I am doing a shit job of conveying it But Iām positive someone wrote a dissertation already. Donāt worry I wonāt too much of a victim mentality for that much matriculation. Right?! š
|
|
Olan
Pearl Clutcher
Enter your message here...
Posts: 4,053
Jul 13, 2014 21:23:27 GMT
|
Post by Olan on Jan 25, 2021 14:20:46 GMT
I think my idea of the human shield isnāt far from this idea. Walk in front of me though. My body isnāt safe. We have to acknowledge that. If I had a white woman advocating for me and insisting I get the same treatment she does shit would have changed for me some time ago. Imagine what would have happened if white women spoke up during slavery and said no to at least splitting up families and raping women. Slavery still went on but those things that make my stomach turn as a woman...I really canāt see how white women allowed that to go down. I think white women are again being tasked with some hard choices and every time they decide to continue enjoying the comforts of privilege. When Tamir Rice died that should have been a call to at least take a look at how black communities were being policed. When I started the threads about police brutality everyone balked/complained ask why all I brought up were issues of race. Peas even agreed that if I was mistreated by police it would be because of something I said or did and not the propensity of police to bring harm/death to black women. That was the pea response just a few years ago. š¤·š¾āāļøWhen Black people revolt it shouldnāt have come from left field. We are tired. Lay your body on the line for me in the same way my ancestors fed your ancestors. There is most definitely a debt here. The idea that black people pay taxes in counties where police departments have long standing histories of brutalizing communities is crazy to me. Blowing them up even! So while Iām certain Iām owed reparations Iād settle for white people dismantling racist systems without my help and a couple decades of not funding my own mistreatment. In response to your passage that I bolded for emphasis, what would have happened is that white women would have been punished in any number of āniceā, creative ways as they literally had no more legal rights than Black people at that time. They were more socially accepted,Ā yes, obviously, but legally they were at the mercy of their husbands and fathers and dependent upon their goodwill. They were their husband's property and subject to their rules. Standing up to men at that time might have resulted in their medication into submission, threats to separate them/actually separate them from their children, physical violence, institutionalization, among others. Not exactly the breeding ground for social justice action.Ā Olan, I want to respond to you, but Iāve got some stuff going on earlier today and wonāt be able to respond until later. Just putting it out there that Iām not going to fart and disappear. peano Iām unsure of why you tagged me in Michyās thread one totally unrelated to this one but Iāve placed the quote here so no one is confused by what transpired.
|
|
Olan
Pearl Clutcher
Enter your message here...
Posts: 4,053
Jul 13, 2014 21:23:27 GMT
|
Post by Olan on Jan 25, 2021 15:02:01 GMT
How I see it peano has already farted and disappeared. And she was able to because in a thread about what Black people need from allies there wasnāt one present to tell her to cut the powerless act and revisionist history lesson to answer the question āWhat would happen if white women advocated for Black women?ā I can almost guarantee that if/when peano returns to this thread she wonāt answer that question because she doesnāt want to reconcile what that inaction meant for enslaved women, and what it says about the women who did nothing. Only because then we could make the connection about the missed social justice movement that arenāt being led by white women present day. My sneaky suspicion is if anything changes Black women will be at the helm. Thatās when all the abolitionist will pop out pretending they had a hand in it. Sorta like this election season š
|
|
Olan
Pearl Clutcher
Enter your message here...
Posts: 4,053
Jul 13, 2014 21:23:27 GMT
|
Post by Olan on Jan 26, 2021 14:46:41 GMT
For what itās worth I take more issue with people not calling out peano . White women seem to think correcting one another is a pile on. As if private messaging doesnāt work. Trust me I get solidarity and holding rank šbut I will pull a Black women to the side with a loving correction in a second. Youāll see the few Black peas do the same to me.. Peano is smug with it too. Repeat offender evenš³. One thread the work Black women have to do is unconscionable but in another simply to disagree with me she gives a participation trophy to everyone who voted. Guess who becomes the bully when I say sit down with a book and STFU. I'm confused because I couldn't find that comment about being a Karen-savior in this thread, so I'm reading out of context. But, @peano, I would say that as a white woman, you're probably NOT totally capable of educating yourself by yourself on issues around race, and listening to Black women is important. That comment is highly problematic.Ā . She is capable. As is every other white person in America. Thatās not my hill. I donāt think anyone needs handholding. Anti racist work is just like any other thing you do to improve your character. Someone can help you along the way but personal responsibility and the willingness to be better people is the only thing that will root the change. Black people have also been put on notice that in order to uphold it youāve got to know how it works. So sure listen to Black women but recognize the work that is anti-racist conditioning. Honest work. The work that involves tackling the truth. Even if the truth makes your stomach turn. Also regarding context....I link threads, post quotes, and connect dots very well. So is it confusion or the unwillingness to call out pea friends? Letās forget about the Karen savior comment (the one that didnāt happen in this thread but was linked) and talk about the historical inaccuracy passed off as truth. Why was I the only pea who corrected peano? Why do you think she wasnāt gracious enough to acknowledge the new information? Why the smugness about how educated she is without my help AFTER the historical inaccuracy. That doesnāt smack anyone else as rich AF? Just me? Okay š¤·š¾āāļø
|
|
Olan
Pearl Clutcher
Enter your message here...
Posts: 4,053
Jul 13, 2014 21:23:27 GMT
|
Post by Olan on Jan 26, 2021 14:52:30 GMT
Sock I had already responded but wanted to touch on other things with a fresh morning brain. peano the smell has dissipated šyou are free to be as smug and historical inaccurate as youād like. Coast is clear. Side note: She is likely an educator. Many of the peas are.
|
|
|
Post by peano on Jan 26, 2021 15:02:39 GMT
Sock I had already responded but wanted to touch on other things with a fresh morning brain. peano the smell has dissipated šyou are free to be as smug and historical inaccurate as youād like. Coast is clear. Side note: She is likely an educator. Many of the peas are. I am currently in a meeting. But will address this later. Thanks for your patience.
|
|
Olan
Pearl Clutcher
Enter your message here...
Posts: 4,053
Jul 13, 2014 21:23:27 GMT
|
Post by Olan on Jan 26, 2021 17:58:07 GMT
How much time could one possibly need to own having passed off historically inaccurate information as fact? This a 2 page thread from August 2020. You donāt have to sift through many responses to see the flow the dialogue took. There was no savior complex or even insistence you do the work in fact I did all the leg work for you. Graciously admitting you were wrong should have happened at time. Even a like would be acknowledgement. Instead in January 2021 you tell me I have a savior complex and am a bit much. You go even further and say you can educate yourself without my help. Totally unprompted by the way. In 2018 I posted scientific information about the physiological damage Black people go through watching one another experience racial violence. Itās conditioning and I stand by that statement. If peano wants to address anything letās address that! What was rhetoric and what was reality? Who decides? What do you think my mission was in 2018? When you say I am doing it no favors, what did you mean? What could have happened if peas were receptive regardless of how little they liked Olan As Iāve said I am committed to ensuring peas stand by the words they type. Look at the responses and the way people spoke to me. Look at o say the last year and then back to how urgent my calls to action were beginning in 2016. Savior complex? Ummm for my own black ass life. I urged everyone to start looking for ways to become more anti racist before it was trending. If magic shaving powder became a pea thing why couldnāt white women deeply invested in ending racism become a thing too?
|
|
pilcas
Pearl Clutcher
Posts: 3,236
Aug 14, 2015 21:47:17 GMT
|
Post by pilcas on Jan 26, 2021 18:32:53 GMT
I saw a video today of a Black man telling the story about getting pulled over by the police and for the first time ever for him, a white woman was nearby recording the police interaction. He was saying thatās something white people can do. Stand by and be allies. I didnāt catch the whole clip because I was watching it with subtitles and no sound, but the story and the subtitles suggested standing alongside and helping people as people. Advocacy is great but there has to be an engaged audience. Iām sure there are some people who are due reparations. The biggest thing that Iām seeing and hearing is to walk with and be my friend. Paraphrasing an old saying here. Donāt walk in front as I may not follow. Donāt walk behind or I may get lost. Walk next to meātogether. I guess another way to say it is to not only talk the talk, but also walk the walk. I think my idea of the human shield isnāt far from this idea. Walk in front of me though. My body isnāt safe. We have to acknowledge that. If I had a white woman advocating for me and insisting I get the same treatment she does shit would have changed for me some time ago. Imagine what would have happened if white women spoke up during slavery and said no to at least splitting up families and raping women. Slavery still went on but those things that make my stomach turn as a woman...I really canāt see how white women allowed that to go down. I think white women are again being tasked with some hard choices and every time they decide to continue enjoying the comforts of privilege. When Tamir Rice died that should have been a call to at least take a look at how black communities were being policed. When I started the threads about police brutality everyone balked/complained ask why all I brought up were issues of race. Peas even agreed that if I was mistreated by police it would be because of something I said or did and not the propensity of police to bring harm/death to black women. That was the pea response just a few years ago. š¤·š¾āāļøWhen Black people revolt it shouldnāt have come from left field. We are tired. Lay your body on the line for me in the same way my ancestors fed your ancestors. There is most definitely a debt here. The idea that black people pay taxes in counties where police departments have long standing histories of brutalizing communities is crazy to me. Blowing them up even! So while Iām certain Iām owed reparations Iād settle for white people dismantling racist systems without my help and a couple decades of not funding my own mistreatment. White women had very little power on their own at that time. Perhaps they might try to influence their husbands but more often than not they would have been told to ga back to managing the household.
|
|
Olan
Pearl Clutcher
Enter your message here...
Posts: 4,053
Jul 13, 2014 21:23:27 GMT
|
Post by Olan on Jan 26, 2021 18:40:47 GMT
I think my idea of the human shield isnāt far from this idea. Walk in front of me though. My body isnāt safe. We have to acknowledge that. If I had a white woman advocating for me and insisting I get the same treatment she does shit would have changed for me some time ago. Imagine what would have happened if white women spoke up during slavery and said no to at least splitting up families and raping women. Slavery still went on but those things that make my stomach turn as a woman...I really canāt see how white women allowed that to go down. I think white women are again being tasked with some hard choices and every time they decide to continue enjoying the comforts of privilege. When Tamir Rice died that should have been a call to at least take a look at how black communities were being policed. When I started the threads about police brutality everyone balked/complained ask why all I brought up were issues of race. Peas even agreed that if I was mistreated by police it would be because of something I said or did and not the propensity of police to bring harm/death to black women. That was the pea response just a few years ago. š¤·š¾āāļøWhen Black people revolt it shouldnāt have come from left field. We are tired. Lay your body on the line for me in the same way my ancestors fed your ancestors. There is most definitely a debt here. The idea that black people pay taxes in counties where police departments have long standing histories of brutalizing communities is crazy to me. Blowing them up even! So while Iām certain Iām owed reparations Iād settle for white people dismantling racist systems without my help and a couple decades of not funding my own mistreatment. White women had very little power on their own at that time. Ā Perhaps they might try to influence their husbands but more often than not they would have been told to ga back to managing the household. Wow.
|
|
|
Post by Zee on Jan 26, 2021 19:10:14 GMT
I agree it would have been something if white women had risen up to protect their black sisters from rape and violence being perpetrated by white women's brothers, sons, husbands, etc the way they tackled drinking in the temperance movement. Or if they had used actual Christian ideals to preach during the revival movements.
There were plenty of strong women who had, if not supportive husbands, husbands who were willing to let them speak and act as independently thinking beings.
But I suppose there were, as there still are, too many people who are simply glad not to be the lowest on the totem pole (as they see it). It's been keeping people down for all of human history. Occasionally, things change for the better. It is past due. Thank you Olan for helping me get past myself and do some real self-reflection. There are some hard truths there, my fellow white women. Even those of us who consider ourselves allies need to be checked and to really explore what we've been taught and how our unacknowledged biases shape our actions.
For some of us that will only go as far as reading a book, but that book can help open dialog and shape action for change.
|
|
|
Post by pierogi on Jan 26, 2021 19:25:05 GMT
I think my idea of the human shield isnāt far from this idea. Walk in front of me though. My body isnāt safe. We have to acknowledge that. If I had a white woman advocating for me and insisting I get the same treatment she does shit would have changed for me some time ago. Imagine what would have happened if white women spoke up during slavery and said no to at least splitting up families and raping women. Slavery still went on but those things that make my stomach turn as a woman...I really canāt see how white women allowed that to go down. I think white women are again being tasked with some hard choices and every time they decide to continue enjoying the comforts of privilege. When Tamir Rice died that should have been a call to at least take a look at how black communities were being policed. When I started the threads about police brutality everyone balked/complained ask why all I brought up were issues of race. Peas even agreed that if I was mistreated by police it would be because of something I said or did and not the propensity of police to bring harm/death to black women. That was the pea response just a few years ago. š¤·š¾āāļøWhen Black people revolt it shouldnāt have come from left field. We are tired. Lay your body on the line for me in the same way my ancestors fed your ancestors. There is most definitely a debt here. The idea that black people pay taxes in counties where police departments have long standing histories of brutalizing communities is crazy to me. Blowing them up even! So while Iām certain Iām owed reparations Iād settle for white people dismantling racist systems without my help and a couple decades of not funding my own mistreatment. White women had very little power on their own at that time. Perhaps they might try to influence their husbands but more often than not they would have been told to ga back to managing the household. I see it a little differently. White women give up their power to White men. Both now and throughout history. They do so in exchange for status, financial advantage and comfort. It's always the easier path, and nearly every right wing movement throughout history - the same groups who dehumanize POC, lgbt groups, religious minorities, etc - actively reinforce the "traditional" roles of women as passive homemakers whose only true role is motherhood. It's a lie. Women have been standing up long before Feminism was a concept, and surviving. The truth is that White Supremacy cannot survive without the complicity of White women, whether that complicity is active or passive. Make no mistake, White Supremacists work hard to enforce this passive mentality: they attack education, they shame and vilify White women who step out of the box, who use their voices and privilege to help the marginalized and oppressed, and call them whores, race traitors, communists, unAmerican - the invective is endless. Yet if all White women disrupted the system together, it would fall tomorrow.
|
|
Olan
Pearl Clutcher
Enter your message here...
Posts: 4,053
Jul 13, 2014 21:23:27 GMT
|
Post by Olan on Jan 26, 2021 20:03:11 GMT
Most Americans know that George Washington owned enslaved people at his Mount Vernon home. But fewer probably know that it was his wife, Martha, who dramatically increased the enslaved population there. When they wed in 1759, George may have owned around 18 people. Martha, one of the richest women in Virginia, owned 84.
The high number of people Martha Washington owned is unusual, but the fact that she owned them is not. Stephanie E. Jones-Rogers, a history professor at the University of California-Berkeley, is compiling data on just how many white women owned slaves in the U.S.; and in the parts of the 1850 and 1860 census data sheās studied so far, white women make up about 40 percents of all slave owners.
Slaveholding parents ātypically gave their daughters more enslaved people than land,ā says Jones-Rogers, whose book They Were Her Property: White Women as Slave Owners in the American South came out in February 2019. āWhat this means is that their very identities as white southern women are tied to the actual or the possible ownership of other people.ā
White women were active and violent participants in the slave market. They bought, sold, managed and sought the return of enslaved people, in whom they had a vested economic interest. Owning a large number of enslaved people made a woman a better marriage prospect. Once married, white women fought in courts to preserve their legal ownership over enslaved people (as opposed to their husbandās ownership), and often won. āFor them, slavery was their freedom,ā Jones-Rogers observes in her book.
They Were Her Property upends a lot of older scholarship. For example, previous scholars have argued that most southern white women didnāt buy, sell or inflict violence on enslaved people because this was considered improper for them. But Jones-Rogers argues that white women were actually trained to participate from a very young age.
Their exposure to the slave market is not something that begins in adulthoodāit begins in their homes when theyāre little girls, sometimes infants, when theyāre given enslaved people as gifts,ā she says. Citing interviews with formerly enslaved people that the Works Progress Administrationāa New Deal agencyāconducted in the 1930s, Jones-Rogers shows that part of white childrenās training in plantation management involved beating enslaved people.
āIt didnāt matter whether the child was large or small,ā one woman told the WPA. āThey always beat you ātil the blood ran down.ā
As adults, white women often tore black women away from their babies so they could nurse the white mistressā baby instead. To this end, white women placed thousands of advertisements in newspapers looking for enslaved āwet nursesā to feed their own children and created a huge market for enslaved black women who had recently given birth.
Why did these white women want black women to nurse their children? One complained āshe felt like continuously having children and continuously nursing her children made her āa slaveā to her childrenāthatās an actual quote,ā Jones-Rogers says.
Some black women reported in WPA interviews that their mothers would always give birth around the same time as the white mistress, suggesting that these mistresses were also orchestrating the sexual assault of enslaved women.
āThere were instances in which formerly enslaved people did in fact say that their mistresses either sanctioned acts of sexual violence against them that were perpetrated at the hands of white men; or that they orchestrated instances of sexual violence between two enslaved people that they owned, in hopes of producing children from those acts of sexual violence,ā Jones-Rogers says.
White women also fought to maintain the wealth and free labor that slavery provided them through the Civil War. As Union troops made their way through the south freeing enslaved people, white women would move enslaved people farther from the soldiersā path. One woman, Martha Gibbs, even took enslaved people to Texas and forced them to work for her at gunpoint until 1866, a year after slaveryās formal abolition.
After the Civil War, southern white women sought to recreate slavery through exploitative work contracts. Some also wrote books portraying the institution of slavery as gentle and benignāthe most famous being Gone With the Wind by Margaret Mitchell, a woman born 35 years after abolition. Yet as Jones-Rogers argues in her book, it was not only white womenās āideological and sentimental connectionsā to slavery that made them defend it. Scarlett O'Hara wouldāve been protecting her economic interests, too.
NOT POWERLESS.
Born in Ann Arundel County, Maryland, Black was moved to New Orleans at a very young age. By the time he turned six, Mr. Bradford, a carpenter, was his master. While Mr. Bradford was not particularly cruel or prone to punishing Black, his wife was a different story. She beat the young Black both passionately and frequently, sometimes ordering her ten-year-old son to partake either in the physical beatings or to simply degrade Black by spitting in his face. In one particular instance, Mrs. Bradford asked Black to carry a bushel of corn upstairs, and when he could not, she knocked him down with a Johnnycake board, causing his head to lose a quart of blood.
While Blackās story did not occur on a plantation, Mrs. Bradford was in the same position of managing a household as the plantation mistresses were in managing their plantations. Although entirely possible that Mrs. Bradford simply experienced some form of emotional pleasure in beating Black, she held many responsibilities just like plantation wives, meaning that feeling in control was likely of importance to her as well. Beating Black could have confirmed her role in the household for her. Ultimately, wives of slaveholders did not want to demonstrate any loss of power or poise to their inferiors, and the way in which they treated their slaves was a direct reflection of the level of security they felt around the slaves.
|
|
|
Post by peano on Jan 26, 2021 20:13:58 GMT
Read this yesterday and after doing so, I totally get your comment "It's fucking exhausting as a white person trying to effect change, and I can "opt out" any time because I'm white; the fact that Black women especially have to do so much lifting is unconscionable." linkWhite Rage in action. Would you unpack this for me. I do not understand what you are talking about?
|
|
Olan
Pearl Clutcher
Enter your message here...
Posts: 4,053
Jul 13, 2014 21:23:27 GMT
|
Post by Olan on Jan 26, 2021 20:19:52 GMT
White women had very little power on their own at that time. Ā Perhaps they might try to influence their husbands but more often than not they would have been told to ga back to managing the household. I see it a little differently. White women give up their powerĀ to White men. Both now and throughout history. They do so in exchange for status, financial advantage and comfort. It's always the easier path, and nearly every right wing movement throughout history - the same groups who dehumanize POC, lgbt groups, religious minorities, etc - actively reinforce the "traditional" roles of women as passive homemakers whose only true role is motherhood. It's a lie. Women have been standing up long before Feminism was a concept, and surviving. The truth is that White Supremacy cannot survive without the complicity of White women, whether that complicity is active or passive.Ā Make no mistake, White Supremacists work hard to enforce this passive mentality: they attack education, they shame and vilify White women who step out of the box, who use their voices and privilege to help the marginalized and oppressed, and call them whores, race traitors, communists, unAmerican - the invective is endless. Yet if all White women disrupted the system together, it would fall tomorrow.Ā This is a really informative article www.vox.com/platform/amp/2021/1/15/22231079/capitol-riot-women-qanon-white-supremacyElizabeth Tyler didnāt have to take her power back from anyone. She was born with it. Weāve got to stop painting white women out to be victims. Look at the last administration š
|
|
|
Post by pierogi on Jan 26, 2021 20:54:30 GMT
I see it a little differently. White women give up their power to White men. Both now and throughout history. They do so in exchange for status, financial advantage and comfort. It's always the easier path, and nearly every right wing movement throughout history - the same groups who dehumanize POC, lgbt groups, religious minorities, etc - actively reinforce the "traditional" roles of women as passive homemakers whose only true role is motherhood. It's a lie. Women have been standing up long before Feminism was a concept, and surviving. The truth is that White Supremacy cannot survive without the complicity of White women, whether that complicity is active or passive. Make no mistake, White Supremacists work hard to enforce this passive mentality: they attack education, they shame and vilify White women who step out of the box, who use their voices and privilege to help the marginalized and oppressed, and call them whores, race traitors, communists, unAmerican - the invective is endless. Yet if all White women disrupted the system together, it would fall tomorrow. This is a really informative article www.vox.com/platform/amp/2021/1/15/22231079/capitol-riot-women-qanon-white-supremacyElizabeth Tyler didnāt have to take her power back from anyone. She was born with it. Weāve got to stop painting white women out to be victims. Look at the last administration š Outstanding article. TFS. I had noticed online that the biggest boosters of Qanon were White women, and the article connects the dots of why. I also noticed the strong presence of White women at the Capitol assault, and tying in the pernicious attraction to the Qanon movement with White Supremacy and Trumpism, we're going to be fighting a major political and social block as we move forward from the disaster of the last few years. It's lazy to dismiss it as mere "brainwashing;" it's a pattern of active complicity and violence perpetrated by White women, and the only way forward is accountability and consequences for those who partake and participate. I'm very interested in the WPA interviews. Until today, I hadn't known they existed. The voices within need to heard and amplified by everyone.
|
|