julieb
Pearl Clutcher
Posts: 2,845
Jul 3, 2014 16:02:54 GMT
|
Post by julieb on Oct 22, 2020 19:14:09 GMT
I feel horrible for her because I know many young families who have lost a father, including my nephew 2 months ago. They didn't have 200k to fall back on and they are doing fine. You go and get a job (if you don't have one), downsize your house and go on a budget. Your lifestyle changes, but that doesn't mean you stop living.
|
|
Deleted
Posts: 0
Nov 15, 2024 22:02:33 GMT
|
Post by Deleted on Oct 22, 2020 19:19:12 GMT
I think Barack Obama summed it up well when he said yesterday about Trump,
"And with Joe and Kamala at the helm, you're not going to have to think about the crazy things they said every day. And that's worth a lot. You're not going to have to argue about them every day. It just won't be so exhausting.""
and that's how I feel. I'm exhausted, and my exhaustion extends to influencers and their obsession with the need to project a perfect life. I am so sick and tired of social media/media, spreading disinformation, of pitting people against each other, especially when so many people are suffering, and need help.
Good for her for being able to raise funds - she's going to need them Would I like to see everyone that needs money - receive the kinds of money she is getting - absolutely - but we all know that doesn't happen - and its totally human nature to be more than a little pissed off about the unfairness of that. But still, I don't want to be in her shoes.
Edited to add:
My ex brother in law died in his sleep 10 days ago. The family suspects either a heart attack or brain aneurysm. We won't know until the autopsy which is delayed due to COVID. He was in his early 50s, leaves behind 3 boys - I don't know if he has life insurance. He was an ex- and he never gave a cent of child support to my sister. So I somehow doubt it...and no they don't have a go fund me . Our family will step in as they have always done, to help give my sister the emotional and financial support & she and her boys will need. I'm not actually sure why I am adding this....other than to say, bad things happen and they happen to all sorts of people whether they were deserving or not.
|
|
|
Post by crimsoncat05 on Oct 22, 2020 19:24:12 GMT
pianoforte , it sounds like you have something personal vested in this particular issue. Which is fine. But trust me- this is NOT the place to bring personal issues like that related to scrapbooking industry personalities. It will (probably) not go well if you continue on that path (if you've lurked here for even a LITTLE bit, you'd understand that). We talk about scrapbooking, scrapbooking 'celebs' etc. here-- the good and the bad. And we ALL spend PLENTY of money on scrapbooking and crafting supplies. Whatever Elizabeth and Colin Karchner did- or did NOT- do with the money they earned from their various professional pursuits is on them. And that issue is SEPARATE from the fact that we can certainly feel that his loss at such a young age is tragic for their family.
|
|
|
Post by joblackford on Oct 22, 2020 19:55:06 GMT
I don't presume to speak for other people but it I want to be clear, that we are all capable of thinking the go fund me is tacky and and simultaneously feel sad that Collin passed away at such a young age. We can think that he acted douchey in the past and feel empathy for his wife and their children. We can find the lack of health insurance questionable and simultaneously see that he and his wife clearly adored each other and their children. I just don't want anyone to think that some of what is being posted here makes us heartless and insensitive. This exactly. Thank you! I knew there would be someone coming to call us all out for the views expressed here, but almost everyone I see posting has both/and feelings about this. My first thoughts were about how much the family must be reeling, but also the unpleasant sides of his character I've learned about here. And how hard it will be for them but also how many people lose everything without anyone rallying to support them. It's just sad all around.
|
|
|
Post by sam9 on Oct 22, 2020 20:15:40 GMT
I agree that people feel sorry for the kids and Liz for what happened. Just not sorry enough to take action and help them in some way. And certainly not sorry enough to not judge and second guess them. Truth is we don't know the full picture. I can see your second point. Influencers are, in general, insufferable. But they are still people, no? Does becoming a public figure mean you no longer qualify for basic respect? Nope, you traded that in, suckers, for fame and fortune. It's open season!! We're all walking around with burdens, why we always gotta make everyone else's heavier? Oh, the humanity! Exactly how I feel. I don't know them. I have no vested interest in them and they haven't influenced my life in any way. They're just people who I've seen on social media. And what people generally show on social media is the best stuff about their lives, and I have questions/issues even with some of that. So while I'm genuinely sorry that she and the kids are going through this unimaginable heartbreak, I'm not sorry enough to take action and donate to their GFM. There are plenty of people in my real life who I know are deserving of my help.
|
|
pinklady
Drama Llama
Posts: 6,044
Nov 14, 2016 23:47:03 GMT
|
Post by pinklady on Oct 22, 2020 20:39:14 GMT
pianoforte , I'm thinking you didn't read the whole thread because everyone does have compassion for the kids and feels sorry for the family having to deal with a tragedy. However, when you shove yourself into the spotlight by being an "influencer" or blogger or whatever, you have to expect people will have opinions and questions about their choices. If you don't want what you are doing to be questioned by the masses, don't become a public figure. I agree that people feel sorry for the kids and Liz for what happened. Just not sorry enough to take action and help them in some way. I was fine with your personal investment in his death until you posted this. The fact that you think you can shame a bunch of people on a message board for not taking action and giving to their money grab is too much. Get the fuck out with this.
|
|
|
Post by sleepingbooty on Oct 22, 2020 20:47:33 GMT
I agree that people feel sorry for the kids and Liz for what happened. Just not sorry enough to take action and help them in some way. I was fine with your personal investment in his death until you posted this. The fact that you think you can shame a bunch of people on a message board for not taking action and giving to their money grab is too much. Get the fuck out with this. It's almost like this is... a discussion board?
|
|
|
Post by sleepingbooty on Oct 22, 2020 20:49:23 GMT
@northrigg Very sorry for your sister and nephews. It must've been such a shock. I hope the autopsy isn't delayed too long so the boys can move on with the healing process. It's hard not to know.
|
|
PaperAngel
Prolific Pea
Posts: 7,980
Jun 27, 2014 23:04:06 GMT
|
Post by PaperAngel on Oct 22, 2020 20:54:00 GMT
Offering my sincere condolences to the Kartchner family during this time... ....Hell, he's not even in the ground yet and we're ripping the guy apart for lack of an insurance policy. Check out the GoFundMe stats ... more than 3,000 different people have donated. The campaign has been shared 38,000 times. It's basically lots of small donations from a lot of people. You don't have that kind of reach unless you've touched many lives for the better... Likewise, "he's not even in the ground yet" & his own family is leveraging his "reach" from good works to ask for & receive over $200K in donations.
|
|
|
Post by Skellinton on Oct 22, 2020 21:36:38 GMT
Offering my sincere condolences to the Kartchner family during this time... ....Hell, he's not even in the ground yet and we're ripping the guy apart for lack of an insurance policy. Check out the GoFundMe stats ... more than 3,000 different people have donated. The campaign has been shared 38,000 times. It's basically lots of small donations from a lot of people. You don't have that kind of reach unless you've touched many lives for the better... Likewise, "he's not even in the ground yet" & his own family is leveraging his "reach" from good works to ask for & receive over $200K in donations. The thing hat galls me the most about the gfm is that it started out a 100,000, when they realized they were close to that they upped it to 200,000. Now that they passed that they upped it again, this time to 300,000. When will it end?
|
|
|
Post by scrapaddict702 on Oct 22, 2020 21:53:32 GMT
I agree that people feel sorry for the kids and Liz for what happened. Just not sorry enough to take action and help them in some way. I was fine with your personal investment in his death until you posted this. The fact that you think you can shame a bunch of people on a message board for not taking action and giving to their money grab is too much. Get the fuck out with this. Yeah. I'm not gonna be guilted into helping someone with a significantly higher standard of living than my own so they can maintain that lifestyle without working for it. I'm also quite upset AC promoted the GFM. Shimelle? Makes sense. But for a business to use their platform to lift someone with means when there are many more without means that wouldn't get the same benefit just pisses me off. It highlights even more advantages of people with privilege.
|
|
pianoforte
Shy Member
Posts: 12
Oct 22, 2020 0:32:15 GMT
|
Post by pianoforte on Oct 22, 2020 21:56:47 GMT
I was fine with your personal investment in his death until you posted this. The fact that you think you can shame a bunch of people on a message board for not taking action and giving to their money grab is too much. Get the fuck out with this. It's almost like this is... a discussion board? A discussion? A newbie speaking her mind? The impudence! Ha ha. My responses to others in this thread have largely been to challenge the assumptions that people are basing their comments on ... - Liz is rich and doesn't truly need the GoFundMe $. You don't know that.
- Collin was a douche from birth until his untimely death. Was he?
- The couple were irresponsible morons for not having insurance. It's entirely possible, but we don't know for sure why they didn't have it.
My overall point is, when you see tragedy - this one or any other - either you're moved to action or you're not. I think it's funny I'm being accused of shaming. You feeling shame? I can't make you feel one way or the other, sister. How you feel about what I wrote is your own choice. If you feel shame ... maybe listen to your conscience? I know I'm asking for it with that comment, but I just couldn't help myself. Look. Donate, don't donate -- doesn't affect me one way or the other. I felt bad for Liz and her kids, gave her the benefit of the doubt and sent some money. Toot toot! Looks like GoFundMe took 3% of it + a service fee anyway, so that's rad. Differences aside, I think we're all in agreement that what's befallen the family is tragic, sad, and horrible. Sucks.
|
|
|
Post by sleepingbooty on Oct 22, 2020 22:19:57 GMT
pianoforte Poor you, "speaking your mind" when you are downright lecturing us. Are you kidding me? Please, have a seat. Now it's the the patronising tone calling me "sister". You may want to preach to the mirror first, madame. This is *not* a Dear Lizzy or scrapbook industry fan site. This is a board of scrapbookers who speak their mind freely, openly and discuss all the points, including the less comfortable ones. We are not a charity either. So you donated to the GFM, what do you expect? A chocolate medal and a moral high horse to patrol the board you just joined? The sheriff election is a little tougher here than in the heavily policed, closed FB groups. You have your freedom of speech and so do we. Yes, you played the shame game and it backfired. You're not the first New Member to stroll in and decide it's time to get some mOrAlS handed to the Far West that is 2PR. As a reminder: Keep the $10 and buy a cheeseburger and fries. Instead of taking the piss out her for lacking foresight, being irresponsible, being hypocritical, etc. what if we showed some GD compassion to a fellow human being when she's at her lowest?
|
|
pianoforte
Shy Member
Posts: 12
Oct 22, 2020 0:32:15 GMT
|
Post by pianoforte on Oct 22, 2020 22:29:10 GMT
pianoforte Poor you, "speaking your mind" when you are downright lecturing us. Are you kidding me? Please, have a seat. Now it's the the patronising tone calling me "sister". You may want to preach to the mirror first, madame. This is *not* a Dear Lizzy or scrapbook industry fan site. This is a board of scrapbookers who speak their mind freely, openly and discuss all the points, including the less comfortable ones. We are not a charity either. So you donated to the GFM, what do you expect? A chocolate medal and a moral high horse to patrol the board you just joined? The sheriff election is a little tougher here than in the heavily policed, closed FB groups. You have your freedom of speech and so do we. Yes, you played the shame game and it backfired. You're not the first New Member to stroll in and decide it's time to get some mOrAlS handed to the Far West that is 2PR. As a reminder: Keep the $10 and buy a cheeseburger and fries. Instead of taking the piss out her for lacking foresight, being irresponsible, being hypocritical, etc. what if we showed some GD compassion to a fellow human being when she's at her lowest? Dang. Now THAT was a super gangster reply. My (sheriff) hat goes off to you. Don't mind me, ma'am. I'll just be over here enjoying my chocolate medal on top of my high horse ... or maybe a cheeseburger sounds better. Yell all you want, I still think it's nice to show some GD compassion to someone when they're down.
|
|
|
Post by sleepingbooty on Oct 22, 2020 22:31:26 GMT
Liz is rich and doesn't truly need the GoFundMe $. You don't know that. Collin was a douche from birth until his untimely death. Was he?
The couple were irresponsible morons for not having insurance. It's entirely possible, but we don't know for sure why they didn't have it.And since you love your rhetorical questions to underline the extreme relative nature of knowledge and speculation, I'll be waiting for you to give me evidence when in this thread we have said: 1. Liz is rich. | People pointed out to her several lucrative jobs such as influencer and AC designer. They've also pointed to her upper-ish middle class lifestyle with the travels, the big home, the pretty clothes, etc. 2. Collin was a douche from birth until death. | Well dayum, I saw no one mention anything about Collin's childhood or teenage years. The very public lying incident over the ticket was brought up so was a thread that discussed his terrible online behaviour and language. A thread barely two years old. 3. The couple were morons for not having insurance. | We only know that Collin doesn't have life insurance (or that is what is being claimed to amass very generous donations). At not one single point have we said anything "moronic" behaviour. And some even speculated that Liz might have life insurance. You have a very problematic and extremely negatively biased view of basic discussions. You extrapolate, you grossly exaggerate and make false claims right to the digital faces of those you've decided to verbally attack. I would say that's very 2020 USA but I'm trying to be respectful here of all the wonderful Americans and American Peas who do not behave thusly. I haven't even touched upon the generalisation of everyone in this discussion in some martyrdom effect of being singled out as the newbie. We were all newbies at some point and we've made it just fine. It would be wise to step back and take a better look at your actual behaviour in this thread.
|
|
|
Post by sleepingbooty on Oct 22, 2020 22:32:25 GMT
And that's exactly what we all did but since we didn't donate, you've felt the need to point the finger at us and blame us for a lack of "GD compassion".
|
|
julie5
Pearl Clutcher
Posts: 3,621
Jul 11, 2018 15:20:45 GMT
|
Post by julie5 on Oct 22, 2020 22:37:55 GMT
I was fine with your personal investment in his death until you posted this. The fact that you think you can shame a bunch of people on a message board for not taking action and giving to their money grab is too much. Get the fuck out with this. It's almost like this is... a discussion board? I seriously love you.
|
|
|
Post by Skellinton on Oct 22, 2020 22:47:49 GMT
It's almost like this is... a discussion board? I seriously love you. Moi aussi, sleepingbooty
|
|
dawnnikol
Prolific Pea
'A life without books is a life not lived.' Jay Kristoff
Posts: 8,520
Sept 21, 2015 18:39:25 GMT
|
Post by dawnnikol on Oct 22, 2020 22:50:40 GMT
The thing hat galls me the most about the gfm is that it started out a 100,000, when they realized they were close to that they upped it to 200,000. Now that they passed that they upped it again, this time to 300,000. When will it end? Well, when AC & SC have now put it on their stories... not sure who else.. FFS. Just bump it up to half a mill.
|
|
|
Post by crafty on Oct 22, 2020 23:12:52 GMT
I will not be taking action to help DL. This does not mean that I don't have empathy for her situation. At some point we as a society need to stop idolizing these people who create these online "influencer" personas. Using social media as your source of income requires you to operate as though you are self employed and have a plan. They made choices and I'm sure she has people in her actual inner circle that will support her. I'm a random stranger on the internet. Asking people for money on GFM is one thing. Continuing to up the amount is disgusting.
|
|
|
Post by papercrafteradvocate on Oct 22, 2020 23:20:46 GMT
I feel very badly for her and their kids. But how does a couple with four young children decide that life insurance is not necessary. A Go Fund Me has already been started. No life insurance in the US with so many dependent children? Very surprising since they were business owners.
|
|
Deleted
Posts: 0
Nov 15, 2024 22:02:33 GMT
|
Post by Deleted on Oct 22, 2020 23:30:29 GMT
Continuing to up the amount is disgusting. Yeah. that. It'd be nice if people could spare some change for the moms of 4 who lost a husband and get nothing instead of heaping it all on a well-to-do white woman. Liz is rich and doesn't truly need the GoFundMe $. You don't know that.They were LITERALLY ON A BEACH VACATION when this happened. So, yeah, I don't "know" but I can build a fairly good hypothesis.
|
|
|
Post by lisacharlotte on Oct 23, 2020 0:04:55 GMT
Friends and family of anybody involved in the scrapbooking industry should always think twice before engaging on a hobby message board. It’s not personal to us, the people we discuss are not friends; we don’t “know” them. This isn’t a moderated fan board/group. We are not censoring our comments to spare feelings because our comments aren’t directed at the subject. We are discussing among ourselves the actions we find stupid/funny/uplifting/ridiculous, etc. We’re not being mean, we’re discussing real issues that have consequences. Maybe someone participating might get a clue and secure life insurance so they don’t get caught out like the Kartchners.
Lecturing us on our behavior is the wrong way to integrate into this board.
|
|
|
Post by lasteve1 on Oct 23, 2020 0:10:34 GMT
Liz is rich and doesn't truly need the GoFundMe $. You don't know that. Collin was a douche from birth until his untimely death. Was he? The couple were irresponsible morons for not having insurance. It's entirely possible, but we don't know for sure why they didn't have it.
I wasn't really going to dig into this drama because this is really a touchy, sad subject but really with these assumptions? 1. Yes, we do know that Liz was upper middle class. No, I don't know exactly how much she makes and I know that social media is often spun to make things look better than it is, but the reality was that her family takes multiple luxurious vacations per year, they have an extremely nice house that is very well decorated, her and her entire family are always very well dressed, they are always going out for ice cream & other activities and treats. I don't think anyone has said she's ridiculously rich or that she won't take a financial hit from this, but they are not in poverty and so many people are. 2. I don't think many people have commented on Collin's behavior on this thread (I certainly didn't) but I think those that did pointed to specific instances and mostly acknowledged that it seemed like he was becoming a better person. Everyone has acknowledged that he seemed to be a great husband and father and no one here thinks that this was anything less than a tragedy. 3. They said they didn't have life insurance on the GoFundMe so if they did have it and lied about it to get donations that is even worse. But you are the first one to insinuate that maybe that is the case... besides that, yes, it is irresponsible of them to not have insurance. While I don't necessarily blame them for not being better prepared because this was so unexpected and I feel horrible for their family, it is frustrating when so many others don't have the luxury of not preparing for difficult times just because they don't have 100k instagram followers... and I think that is all anyone is saying. No one is saying that they don't think they could use the money or that it will be a blessing to them, but most people either need to make sure to be prepared or they will not have someone to bail them out. There are so many people that die unexpectedly, especially in the current pandemic, and unless you're Jeff Bezos no one has the funds to contribute to all of them... Liz is going to fare much better than so many others that have suffered or will suffer unexpected losses. ETA: Sorry it didn't quote quite right, hopefully I fixed it.
|
|
|
Post by ScrapbookMyLife on Oct 23, 2020 0:28:36 GMT
I predict..... In a few months or a year from now.....Liz and the children will be somewhere having a "healing, dealing with the grief, etc.... long stay at the beach or another place" and photos will be posted(because that's what influencers do) and there is going to be a huge uproar over how she is spending her "go fund me" funds.
|
|
|
Post by hop2 on Oct 23, 2020 2:46:26 GMT
You have a lot of nerve to judge me on not donating to a go fund me for well off people. I feel for her and her children, it is a tough, devastating loss. It is very tragic and I have a great deal of empathy for what they are going to go thru. But empathy doesn’t equal handing them my money. Especially for a go fund me that clearly illustrates A flippant attitude towards money. I’m pretty sure I need that $10 more than they do.
I’m sure they spent more on their current vacation ( during a pandemic! ) than I make in a month. I spend my income on what *I* want to spend it on. I save and put aside money for emergencies because that what you do when your able to. I donate money all the time - to places where people actually need it. You have no right to judge me for not donating $10 to people who make way more than I do. I have my own issues to deal with and my own financial hardships and know enough people with tragedies that could use help. Pardon me if I don’t give $10 to the go fund me of someone who already clearly has more than I do. I only know that because they publicize that all over the internet.
Your the one being judgmental and rude for castigating us for not ‘being moved’ to Donate. Insinuating that empathy has a dollar amount attached to it.
And your damn right ‘hamburger’ I haven’t had steak in my budget since March so hamburger will have to do & probably for 2 meals. But that’s ok I know how to use it and can make a tasty dinner with chopped meat any day of the week.
But you can take your judgment and shove it.
|
|
msliz
Drama Llama
The Procrastinator
Posts: 6,419
Jun 26, 2014 21:32:34 GMT
|
Post by msliz on Oct 23, 2020 3:07:06 GMT
You have a lot of nerve to judge me on not donating to a go fund me for well off people. I feel for her and her children, it is a tough, devastating loss. It is very tragic and I have a great deal of empathy for what they are going to go thru. But empathy doesn’t equal handing them my money. Especially for a go fund me that clearly illustrates A flippant attitude towards money. I’m pretty sure I need that $10 more than they do. I’m sure they spent more on their current vacation ( during a pandemic! ) than I make in a month. I spend my income on what *I* want to spend it on. I save and put aside money for emergencies because that what you do when your able to. I donate money all the time - to places where people actually need it. You have no right to judge me for not donating $10 to people who make way more than I do. I have my own issues to deal with and my own financial hardships and know enough people with tragedies that could use help. Pardon me if I don’t give $10 to the go fund me of someone who already clearly has more than I do. I only know that because they publicize that all over the internet. Your the one being judgmental and rude for castigating us for not ‘being moved’ to Donate. Insinuating that empathy has a dollar amount attached to it. And your damn right ‘hamburger’ I haven’t had steak in my budget since March so hamburger will have to do & probably for 2 meals. But that’s ok I know how to use it and can make a tasty dinner with chopped meat any day of the week. But you can take your judgment and shove it. Thank you for saying what I wanted to say, and saying it so much better than I could.
|
|
|
Post by artsyk on Oct 23, 2020 4:50:06 GMT
Unity Stamp Co. now posted it on their FB page.
|
|
|
Post by refugeepea on Oct 23, 2020 5:12:24 GMT
It's devastating he died at such a young age and his wife and kids seem to truly love him. His poor wife is unraveling in front of everyone. Honestly, I'm glad she's mad. I'm glad she's pissed. I'm glad she's swearing. Losing someone suddenly will do that to anyone. She isn't trying to be sunshine and roses. Collin spoke out against what he thought was wrong. I found it to be harmful and emotionally stunting. He would say stay off social media. Yet his family was constantly displayed on Instagram. Don't watch porn but have a speaker who believes masturbation and porn is a sin speak at a University. A LDS speaker who also thinks it's okay for pre-teens and teens to talk to a grown man (with no training) in private about anything sexual in nature they have done for the sake of confessing. Normal things any other teen will do. The number one reason for deaths among young people in Utah is suicide. There is so much shaming. The culture of perfection is toxic. The state of Utah named porn a health crisis and they even had white ribbon week in schools before they addressed teens dying. Not everyone will become addicted to porn, just like with alcohol. The standards of the main religion in Utah are strict. Even if you aren't a member, others feel the judging of what they are not doing "right". Too many have died because they find themselves irredeemable. I know of too many people who have gone way too early or have made attempts.
Smart phones aren't going away. Talk about what controls you can use on apps. Which ones should not be allowed on phones. Taking phones away at night after a certain time. Teach them boundaries. Some reasonable compromises. Let teens know if they are in trouble, you will help them no matter what. It's okay to make mistakes. Don't take their issues to other people unless they are practicing psychologists.
I want to make it clear, I have had success and failures with my kids and I'm not trying to be preachy. I'm just typing out what I did and should have done with my kids.
|
|
FurryP
Drama Llama
To pea or not to pea...
Posts: 7,271
Site Supporter
Jun 26, 2014 19:58:26 GMT
|
Post by FurryP on Oct 23, 2020 5:19:58 GMT
I truly feel bad for her loss, but I'm buying some stamps and dies with my compa$$ion. Not sorry. Not cold-hearted either.
|
|