|
Post by SockMonkey on Jul 15, 2017 23:57:53 GMT
This place.
*sigh*
So, without wading too deep into the waters of this argument (discussion?), let me please just say WHITE PEOPLE: We do not get to tell people of color how to be angry or how angry they can be. We just don't. So stop it.
And back to Beyonce: Before you get mad about her picture, let me just share that white people have cornered the market on crazy baby photos. We just have.
Exhibit:
|
|
libby
Junior Member
Posts: 50
Mar 22, 2017 16:44:03 GMT
|
Post by libby on Jul 15, 2017 23:59:42 GMT
This 1000 times. Seriously Olan, you are blinded by your hatred of anyone of a different race than you. You think you have the answers to the problem when in fact you are the problem. I believe SOME of what you have personally felt as racism actually has nothing to do with race. It has to do with your bitter personality. Check Libby's post history - very racist. Have I stated anything that was untrue? Or is truth now = racist.
|
|
|
Post by ahiller on Jul 16, 2017 0:11:57 GMT
This place. *sigh* So, without wading too deep into the waters of this argument (discussion?), let me please just say WHITE PEOPLE: We do not get to tell people of color how to be angry or how angry they can be. We just don't. So stop it. And back to Beyonce: Before you get mad about her picture, let me just share that white people have cornered the market on crazy baby photos. We just have. Exhibit: I don't know what you are talking about, Sock. I think most people want a rifle involved in revealing the sex of their baby. W.t.f.
|
|
|
Post by crimsoncat05 on Jul 16, 2017 4:29:13 GMT
what I think about Beyonce's photo shoot does not have ANYTHING to do with what I think about baby, engagement, or wedding photos. If this thread was about some of them, you'd find out my opinion of them. But it's not. I probably WOULD find some of them over-the-top and tacky, too.
But do I have to preface anything I write about Beyonce's photo with 'for the record, I also think the same thing about some white people's photos' for other people to not think I'm racist? and if so, why is that?
Why aren't my opinions about things allowed to be self-contained and individual? Why do we have to bring race into this discussion just because Beyonce happens to be black? If Jessica Simpson had just posted a photo of herself with a new baby staged like that, I would have said the same damn thing about IT. But why do I have to tell everyone that? Why do we have to qualify what we write/think just because we're talking about a black person?
|
|
PrettyInPeank
Pearl Clutcher
Posts: 4,691
Jun 25, 2014 21:31:58 GMT
|
Post by PrettyInPeank on Jul 16, 2017 5:35:32 GMT
Had to scan the link 3 times before I realized the babies were in her arms. Lol. Olan The only thing I'm going to say to you is this, and I am entirely serious: I often don't even recognize race as an important detail in many threads until you enter. Think about that for a minute. I see a woman, Beyonce, surrounded by flowers. Apparently holding babies. Then you said but she's black. And then I am made aware again, by you, the color of someone's skin. I was raised to see the color of someone's skin to be no different than the color of their hair, or eyes, and it's really starting to piss me off that now I'm recognizing only color. As if it's fucking important I identify them by their color. With me, maybe others here, your comments are counterproductive. I swear I never recognized Simone as black, just a crazy talented gymnast who was also a fantastic dancer. I see her character and talent, and I'm pissed you make me see her as a color. Stop making me see only color; the women you list are so much more than that.
|
|
|
Post by leftturnonly on Jul 16, 2017 6:41:42 GMT
Should every white person in this country apologize to all black people? The generations of my family in this country before me had nothing to do with slavery. Multiple generations of my family paid a heavy price in the fight to end slavery so that people of color could live their lives in freedom in this country. An occasional acknowledgement that people with fair skin died in muddy trenches and suffered agonizing wounds and illnesses for the rest of their lives leaving women and children destitute with little to no support would be nice. I won't apologize to anyone because of my skin color.
|
|
|
Post by leftturnonly on Jul 16, 2017 6:43:45 GMT
Why do we have to qualify what we write/think just because we're talking about a black person? We don't.
|
|
inkedup
Pearl Clutcher
Posts: 4,837
Jun 26, 2014 5:00:26 GMT
|
Post by inkedup on Jul 16, 2017 7:49:39 GMT
This place. *sigh* So, without wading too deep into the waters of this argument (discussion?), let me please just say WHITE PEOPLE: We do not get to tell people of color how to be angry or how angry they can be. We just don't. So stop it. And back to Beyonce: Before you get mad about her picture, let me just share that white people have cornered the market on crazy baby photos. We just have. Exhibit: Jesus fucking Christ. What a straw man argument. No one is telling Olan how to feel. No one is telling her she doesn't have a right to her feelings. No one said anything about black people having "cornered the market on crazy baby photos." What bothers me is being told that the reason I dislike Beyonce is that she's black and I hate watching women (black or white) succeed. Thanks for your helpful reminder to "white people", too. What a sanctimonious hand slap that wss for someone who didn't want to "wade too deeply into the discussion."
|
|
|
Post by miominmio on Jul 16, 2017 7:55:26 GMT
This x 10000000 Thank you Paget! Same here.
Olan, I wish you well. Really, I do. I feel like I can't possibly begin to know what it's like to walk in your shoes and those of your ancestors, and it would be inappropriate of me to try. I admit I grew up/live in a bubble in the middle of the country, and have not experienced rabid racism on either side, so I respect that the things you and your family have gone through, have made a huge impact on your whole being - and well they should!!! I don't intend in any way to minimize that or "write it off". It's very real and definitely a discussion that needs to be ongoing in our country, especially with the jack*** that's currently "leading" it.
BUT.....
Life is only 10% what happens to you, and 90% what you make of it.
Look at the world around you. Appreciate what you have. Do your ancestors proud by spending your emotional energy for the good - be it volunteering with youth, helping the homeless, working at a food bank. How do you think they would feel about the bitterness that has built up in you? Wouldn't they want you to move forward and be grateful for what you have that they didn't?
Be open-minded to other people's points of view. I think you will be pleasantly surprised.
The thing is (since you brought up the ancestor part): While I get the "I'm upset because white people treat me like s**t" (although I guess it has nothing to do with her colour and everything to do with her personality), if she (or anyone) starts touting "I hate white people because my ancestors were slaves", she/they are seriously lacking historical knowledge. 1) Statistically, if any of you have Nordic blood in your veins, you have ancestors who were slaves (30% percent of the population were slaves during what is now called the Viking Age). OK, they were white, so maybe to olan that makes their suffering less important, but they were slaves. (Slavery wasn't abolished until the thirteenth century) 2) Roman empire, anyone? They had slaves, some from North Africa, others from the rest of Europe. 3) European slaves ended up in Africa and the Middle East, after either being transported and sold in the slave markets there, or they were bought by slave traders from those areas and brought home. 4) African slavetraders went as far North as Iceland to capture slaves....I think the last raid happened in 1780? 5) let us not forget that African tribes very happily sold their captured enemies to foreign slave traders....the same thing that has been going on every inhabited continent. Olan complaining about the terrible white people, is like muslims complaining about the Crusadrs.
|
|
wellway
Prolific Pea
Posts: 9,073
Jun 25, 2014 20:50:09 GMT
|
Post by wellway on Jul 16, 2017 8:14:51 GMT
|
|
|
Post by AussieMeg on Jul 16, 2017 8:18:20 GMT
I wondered why a thread about Beyonce's babies had gone to 7 pages. I'm going to ignore the accusations of racism and just respond to the OP.
1. I love her dress in the photo! She wears it better than the male model in the other thread I saw today. 2. Her babies are divine and I am so jealous - it was my dream to have boy/girl twins. 3. I really like the name Rumi. 4. I think the name Sir is just stupid. 5. I'm not a fan of Beyonce's music, I prefer rock. 6. But I LOVE the song Crazy In Love. 7. I can't stand the song Single Ladies. 8. But I think she's a fabulous dancer in that film clip.
ETA: 9. None of the above has anything to do with her race.
|
|
|
Post by miominmio on Jul 16, 2017 8:18:45 GMT
I would like to add (before reading your link), that it is well documented that African slave traders "shopped" both in Rouen and in Ireland.
|
|
|
Post by miominmio on Jul 16, 2017 9:23:38 GMT
The same could be said for Madonna and Cher. But no one does. I love how you know what every non-black person thinks. Since we are just one racist monolith, right? So are non-blacks required to love everything black people do so that we won't be accused of being racist? That's what it feels like with you. I hate Madonna but I have to admit that I like Cher's campiness. For the record, I hate most pop music. I find it inane and awful. But no one is talking about Madonna or Cher because they aren't doing photo shoots with their newborns and selling them to news outlets and tabloids. I'm not going to let you bait me into an argument of why I am racist and how awful every woman here is. I enjoy some of your posts, but you've decided that we are all terrible people and nothing will change your mind. So I am not going to waste my energy or time. If you say you love something black people do, the accusation of cultural appropriation will come next. One just can't expect to have a rational conversation with a bigot. ETA: does slaughtering non-believers count? Because monotheistic religions have a lot to answer for on that account. Or isn't that bad when it's happening to white people?
|
|
|
Post by miominmio on Jul 16, 2017 9:34:26 GMT
Well, considering that when the US was being created my ancestors were losing their land and during the civil war the other half were living in Germany, soon to move to Russia to take over working the land for a better life (which never really came and why they came to the US at the turn of the century). But I'm supposed to apologize for every white man who lived in the US because I'm white that's all it takes to be complicit in the institution of slavery? Slavery which has existed in the world since society began and tribes formed and has been practiced by people of ALL races? And is still practiced today in some societies? America doesn't want to say sorry. The peas told me so in another thread of mine. So no worries about apologizing for white men. You just keep reaping the rewards sister *thumbs up*. You could also save your apologies until after 45's impeachment. That's a modern day instance of white women falling in line with systemic (I love this autocorrect) racism. And you are wrong. Do you know what made Chattle slavery different from all the rest? Anyone? Does anyone know if any other group of people used the word of God as a way to enslave another group of people? Has that been studied? Read a bit of history...it won't hurt. I know the answer to the two last questions, it is apparent that you don't.
|
|
|
Post by gillyp on Jul 16, 2017 10:20:57 GMT
The way this thread has gone is precisely why we have so many lurkers who are afraid to post. Had this happened on the old board you would not have seen me for dust. The turn was totally unnecessary and has no bearing on the initial post, despite what you think, Olan. This post is going to be long. Please do me the courtesy of reading it, Olan, as I have done with every post here whether I have responded or not. No one here, other than the troll whom I shall ignore, has made a single disparaging remark towards you personally because of your colour or to any other non-white. They have expressed frustration at your comments, a frustration I share, not because you are black but because in the main you are making broad generalisations without the substance to back them up. I can go to Wiki and find the details you have been quoting. Do you know for a fact that your ancestors were enslaved? Do you have documentary evidence? Because not all blacks were enslaved. You said the record keeping was “stellar”. By that do you mean exemplary and very well done? You are wrong. It wasn’t. Many, many, blacks have been lost to the mists of time because they were merely referred to a man, woman, child in records often only distinguished by their apparent age and the scars on their bodies. Children were not even recorded until they reached a “useful” age. Do you know how your ancestors were treated? Do you know what plantations they were on? I can name the plantations my relatives were on. I have seen pictures. Do I have your attention, Olan? I would like to give you some background. My father died when I was 8, he had been ill for years and I don’t have many memories of him. He was in his mid 50s when I was born and had been brought up in a totally different lifestyle to me. He was born at the end of the Victorian age and I was a child of the 60s. You can’t get much different. His generation and those before were mostly racist. When I was about 11 I started asking my mother about my ancestors and she did not have any answers as she knew nothing and believed all the older family generations to have died. She DID tell me that I was somehow related to Grace Bumbry, the black American opera singer. Fast forward about 35 years and thanks to the internet I was able to start researching my ancestors. Another 15 years on and I now have a huge database. I have paid particular attention to my maiden surname because everyone with that name is related. We all descended from the same French man. I have documentary evidence of this if not in my possession then it is in the National Archives. People/relatives from around the world have contacted me for information because of my findings and I remain in contact with many. One of these contacts is a distant cousin in London, England. He and I share 7 x great grandparents. He sent me photos of his family, all with black skin and afro hair styles and I sent him photos of mine, all of us as white as he was black. He was descended from a coupling, for want of a better word, there is no evidence as to actually what went on, between a son of the sugar plantation owner in what was known then as British Guiana and a slave. The plantation owner was my 3rd cousin 5 times removed, so pretty distant, and the owner was something like 5th gt.grandfather to my London cousin. This was the first time I became aware of slavery within the family. To say I was horrified is putting it mildly. Don’t sneer, Olan, at me sitting in my nice, safe, white home – not bought with a single penny of money based on slavery – being appalled at what went on within the family. You being black does not give you exclusive rights to bang on about the atrocity that was slavery. The London cousin and I did a lot of research together, including me transcribing the Wills of the plantation owner and his wife. They were not nice reading, referring to the slaves at chattels, as you would expect in that time period, and complaining about the amount of money they, the owners, were to receive from the British government for their slaves. It was horrific. Did my London cousin ever ask me to apologise for what the white side of the family did to the black side? Never once although he knew my feelings of revulsion for what had gone on. He had a perfect right to ask for my apology, don’t you think Olan? He actually said to me that slavery was a thing of those times and thankfully something we had moved on from. The Will of another white male connected with this side of the family left all of his possessions to his slave “wife” and the four children they had had together. Not every slave was treated badly. Not every child of a white man and a black slave was born of rape and violence and you cannot claim that to be the case, Olan. Descendants of the black line of this branch of the family are today living in Guyana, Puerto Rico, Canada, America, England to name a few. I have been in touch with many. They are all proud of their heritage. They know who I am and the link to the family. Not one has asked me to apologise. Why do you feel the need, Olan? In the 1600s a distant uncle travelled as an indentured servant from England to Richmond, Virginia to work on a tobacco plantation. He had a ‘relationship’ with a black slave whose name, regrettably is unknown, and they founded the largest black community in the area, from which Grace Bumbry is descended. There are many still living there today. They know who I am. Not one has asked me to apologise. Why do you feel the need, Olan? I have a reasonable lifestyle but not one penny of it was inherited wealth. I have worked damn hard all my life and continue to do so, to earn a living. No one in my branch of the family has received any money whatsoever from the proceeds of slavery, thankfully. As to this little white woman not liking winners, especially white female winners? Tosh. You do not know what you are talking about. I love it when anyone succeeds and does well in life. Adele, Victoria Beckham, Jessica Ennis-Hill, Maggie Smith to start with. I’m getting bored with my own post now. Olan, you come across as young. I feel you are banging the same drum as others instead of making your own judgments. If you are really, truly, that bothered get out there and start making a difference instead of berating unknown people on a message board who have only been, in this thread, very understanding of what you are saying. Sometimes being quieter and more moderate will get your views taken far more seriously than being loud and aggressive. For the record, AM I sorry about what went on in the past? Absolutely. The way people were treated was horrendous. The way some people are treated NOW is horrendous. It really saddens me to think that people are still being downtrodden, treated badly, not given the same opportunities as others, because of their skin colour, because of their religion, because of their disabilities etc. etc. etc. The world is not a fair place, it never has been and it sure as heck is not going to become so in my lifetime. It saddens me to think you may have had crap things go on in your own life because of your colour. That’s more than enough from me. I’ve probably broken the message board now.
|
|
Olan
Pearl Clutcher
Enter your message here...
Posts: 4,053
Jul 13, 2014 21:23:27 GMT
|
Post by Olan on Jul 16, 2017 11:11:45 GMT
For any of you discussing the history of slavery and asking if I am sure my ancestors were enslaved...please don't go there. You haven't done the necessary research. I am going to be wise about how much time I give to the peas this fine Sunday so I won't be providing links that would blow your comments out of the water because really what would that change. It's really clear here that no one wants to take personal responsibility for any of their ancestors actions or that of your own. No one wants to really examine what happened and why black people continue to have the same type of experience in America.
My guess is many of you made comments before even clicking the links I've provided.
|
|
|
Post by gar on Jul 16, 2017 11:15:10 GMT
For any of you discussing the history of slavery and asking if I am sure my ancestors were enslaved...please don't go there. You haven't done the necessary research. I am going to be wise about how much time I give to the peas this fine Sunday so I won't be providing links that would blow your comments out of the water because really what would that change. It's really clear here that no one wants to take personal responsibility for any of their ancestors actions or that of your own. No one wants to really examine what happened and why black people continue to have the same type of experience in America. My guess is many of you made comments before even clicking the links I've provided. Completely ignoring other people's posts/information/questions as usual.
|
|
Olan
Pearl Clutcher
Enter your message here...
Posts: 4,053
Jul 13, 2014 21:23:27 GMT
|
Post by Olan on Jul 16, 2017 11:21:30 GMT
For any of you discussing the history of slavery and asking if I am sure my ancestors were enslaved...please don't go there. You haven't done the necessary research. I am going to be wise about how much time I give to the peas this fine Sunday so I won't be providing links that would blow your comments out of the water because really what would that change. It's really clear here that no one wants to take personal responsibility for any of their ancestors actions or that of your own. No one wants to really examine what happened and why black people continue to have the same type of experience in America. My guess is many of you made comments before even clicking the links I've provided. Completely ignoring other people's posts/information/questions as usual. No I am choosing where best to spend my time. This would be a fruitless waste of time. I tried to explain why line of thought and everyone overshoot and went back to the same angry bitter bandwagon thing. You guys don't need me responding to continue this thread. Click those links and asks me something specifically about them and I would be more than welcome to converse. Be sure to tell me which link it was.
|
|
|
Post by miominmio on Jul 16, 2017 11:37:28 GMT
For any of you discussing the history of slavery and asking if I am sure my ancestors were enslaved...please don't go there. You haven't done the necessary research. I am going to be wise about how much time I give to the peas this fine Sunday so I won't be providing links that would blow your comments out of the water because really what would that change. It's really clear here that no one wants to take personal responsibility for any of their ancestors actions or that of your own. No one wants to really examine what happened and why black people continue to have the same type of experience in America. My guess is many of you made comments before even clicking the links I've provided. Question: why should anyone apologise for something they themselves didn't do? And how far back would you expect someone to count which ancestors they are apologising for? Should I apologise to myself? Why shouldn't we "go there" when it comes to the history of slavery? Why is only your point of view the valid one? Why do you sneer at a person who is part native American? Because only black people's suffering count?
|
|
Olan
Pearl Clutcher
Enter your message here...
Posts: 4,053
Jul 13, 2014 21:23:27 GMT
|
Post by Olan on Jul 16, 2017 11:46:44 GMT
For any of you discussing the history of slavery and asking if I am sure my ancestors were enslaved...please don't go there. You haven't done the necessary research. I am going to be wise about how much time I give to the peas this fine Sunday so I won't be providing links that would blow your comments out of the water because really what would that change. It's really clear here that no one wants to take personal responsibility for any of their ancestors actions or that of your own. No one wants to really examine what happened and why black people continue to have the same type of experience in America. My guess is many of you made comments before even clicking the links I've provided. Question: why should anyone apologise for something they themselves didn't do? And how far back would you expect someone to count which ancestors they are apologising for? Should I apologise to myself? Why shouldn't we "go there" when it comes to the history of slavery? Why is only your point of view the valid one? Why do you sneer at a person who is part native American? Because only black people's suffering count? Which article did you read? And what comment of mine discounts the suffering of any group of people? No worries on the apologies. Unless it's for the 2016 election What bothers me is being told that the reason I dislike Beyonce is that she's black and I hate watching women (black or white) succeed. Then simply disagree and move on with your fucking day. Don't call me bitter and angry and try to discount my experience as a black woman. Don't tell me you don't see color when I talk about Serena or Simone. FYI They want to be seen as black women. No one wants that whole color blind garbage anymore. We get how dangerous that is too.
|
|
|
Post by gillyp on Jul 16, 2017 11:51:29 GMT
For any of you discussing the history of slavery and asking if I am sure my ancestors were enslaved...please don't go there. You haven't done the necessary research. I am going to be wise about how much time I give to the peas this fine Sunday so I won't be providing links that would blow your comments out of the water because really what would that change. It's really clear here that no one wants to take personal responsibility for any of their ancestors actions or that of your own. No one wants to really examine what happened and why black people continue to have the same type of experience in America. My guess is many of you made comments before even clicking the links I've provided. I would be grateful if you would explain to me exactly what it is YOU want ME to do in order to take the personal responsibility you feel I need to take. Please also remember that any child born between a white relative of mine and a slave also was a relative of mine and probably enslaved as were the descendants of that child. So, through absolutely no choices I could have made and purely as an accident of genes I am related to both the white owners and the enslaved. Who do I turn to to take personal responsibility for the cousins of mine who were enslaved?
|
|
Olan
Pearl Clutcher
Enter your message here...
Posts: 4,053
Jul 13, 2014 21:23:27 GMT
|
Post by Olan on Jul 16, 2017 11:58:53 GMT
For any of you discussing the history of slavery and asking if I am sure my ancestors were enslaved...please don't go there. You haven't done the necessary research. I am going to be wise about how much time I give to the peas this fine Sunday so I won't be providing links that would blow your comments out of the water because really what would that change. It's really clear here that no one wants to take personal responsibility for any of their ancestors actions or that of your own. No one wants to really examine what happened and why black people continue to have the same type of experience in America. My guess is many of you made comments before even clicking the links I've provided. I would be grateful if you would explain to me exactly what it is YOU want ME to do in order to take the personal responsibility you feel I need to take. Please also remember that any child born between a white relative of mine and a slave also was a relative of mine and probably enslaved as were the descendants of that child. So, through absolutely no choices I could have made and purely as an accident of genes I am related to both the white owners and the enslaved. Who do I turn to to take personal responsibility for the cousins of mine who were enslaved? What if you only took responsibility for your personal actions or inaction. What would that look like? If I found myself living in a world where black people are truly free but I noticed another group of people being persecuted I would not stand idle.
|
|
|
Post by gillyp on Jul 16, 2017 12:06:55 GMT
I would be grateful if you would explain to me exactly what it is YOU want ME to do in order to take the personal responsibility you feel I need to take. Please also remember that any child born between a white relative of mine and a slave also was a relative of mine and probably enslaved as were the descendants of that child. So, through absolutely no choices I could have made and purely as an accident of genes I am related to both the white owners and the enslaved. Who do I turn to to take personal responsibility for the cousins of mine who were enslaved? What if you only took responsibility for your personal actions or inaction. What would that look like? If I found myself living in a world where black people are truly free but I noticed another group of people being persecuted I would not stand idle. You have not answered my question, you have merely waffled. Please explain what personal actions you feel I need to take responsibility for and what inaction I am guilty of. I am now going to watch the Wimbledon Mens Final. I was rooting for Venus Williams yesterday because I admire her athleticism and the fact she is still able to play at such a level given her time in the game. I like her sportsmanship and wanted her to win because it was probably her last ever shot at the title. I suppose I was wrong to do that?
|
|
Olan
Pearl Clutcher
Enter your message here...
Posts: 4,053
Jul 13, 2014 21:23:27 GMT
|
Post by Olan on Jul 16, 2017 12:11:41 GMT
What if you only took responsibility for your personal actions or inaction. What would that look like? If I found myself living in a world where black people are truly free but I noticed another group of people being persecuted I would not stand idle. You have not answered my question, you have merely waffled. Please explain what personal actions you feel I need to take responsibility for and what inaction I am guilty of. I am now going to watch the Wimbledon Mens Final. I was rooting for Venus Williams yesterday because I admire her athleticism and the fact she is still able to play at such a level given her time in the game. I like her sportsmanship and wanted her to win because it was probably her last ever shot at the title. I suppose I was wrong to do that? You feel that I waffled instead of answering your question so you've refused to answer mine. Your pokey commentary of "I suppose I am wrong to do that" lets me know where this has been heading. Have a good day. gillyp said: Please explain what personal actions you feel I need to take responsibility for and what inaction I am guilty of. That isn't for me to decide. That's what I challenged you to do. I can see you've decided reflecting quietly is too much work.
|
|
kibblesandbits
Pearl Clutcher
At the corner of Awesome and Bombdiggity
Posts: 3,305
Aug 13, 2016 13:47:39 GMT
|
Post by kibblesandbits on Jul 16, 2017 12:16:16 GMT
I would be grateful if you would explain to me exactly what it is YOU want ME to do in order to take the personal responsibility you feel I need to take. Please also remember that any child born between a white relative of mine and a slave also was a relative of mine and probably enslaved as were the descendants of that child. So, through absolutely no choices I could have made and purely as an accident of genes I am related to both the white owners and the enslaved. Who do I turn to to take personal responsibility for the cousins of mine who were enslaved? What if you only took responsibility for your personal actions or inaction. What would that look like? If I found myself living in a world where black people are truly free but I noticed another group of people being persecuted I would not stand idle. Several people have (here and in other threads) stated what THEY ARE DOING to combat racial prejudice and bogotry, only to be told by you that it wasn't enough/ineffective/not what needs to be done. Yet, you continue to demur when asked what it is you DO want. So please, try to put in one succinct sentence what you want. I hope this is not how you argued your thesis papers in college. SaveSave
|
|
Olan
Pearl Clutcher
Enter your message here...
Posts: 4,053
Jul 13, 2014 21:23:27 GMT
|
Post by Olan on Jul 16, 2017 12:30:36 GMT
What if you only took responsibility for your personal actions or inaction. What would that look like? If I found myself living in a world where black people are truly free but I noticed another group of people being persecuted I would not stand idle. Several people have (here and in other threads) stated what THEY ARE DOING to combat racial prejudice and bogotry, only to be told by you that it wasn't enough/ineffective/not what needs to be done. Yet, you continue to demur when asked what it is you DO want. So please, try to put in one succinct sentence what you want. I hope this is not how you argued your thesis papers in college. SaveSaveThat's a lie. Ive never told anyone whatever effort they are making to bring about change wasn't enough. Those of you who have interacted with me and know this isn't true....your silence I see it. I love how you want to twist my arm into providing ONE sentence about what I want as if the peas plan to wave a magic wand. Everyone just wants to argue down everything I haven't said totally disregarding what I have said. All while calling me bitter angry and racist. *shrugs* Be introspective. Ask yourself what personal responsibility looks like to you. Do something. What if you only took responsibility for your personal actions or inaction. What would that look like? If I found myself living in a world where black people are truly free but I noticed another group of people being persecuted I would not stand idle.
|
|
kibblesandbits
Pearl Clutcher
At the corner of Awesome and Bombdiggity
Posts: 3,305
Aug 13, 2016 13:47:39 GMT
|
Post by kibblesandbits on Jul 16, 2017 12:40:32 GMT
You're gas lighting - it's beyond frustrating.
No one wants to argue - just want to understand what THE FUCK YOU WANT. You continue to obfuscate the topic and evade any direct answer.
|
|
Olan
Pearl Clutcher
Enter your message here...
Posts: 4,053
Jul 13, 2014 21:23:27 GMT
|
Post by Olan on Jul 16, 2017 12:45:12 GMT
You're gas lighting - it's beyond frustrating. No one wants to argue - just want to understand what THE FUCK YOU WANT. You continue to obfuscate the topic and evade any direct answer. Is that what you got from my last response. The one you didn't quote? Gaslighting? Really? kibblesandbits have a good Sunday. If anyone wants to actually discuss what I meant by white women not wanting to see black women win read here www.theroot.com/on-white-women-who-pen-criticisms-of-beyonce-and-serena-1792721829
|
|
kibblesandbits
Pearl Clutcher
At the corner of Awesome and Bombdiggity
Posts: 3,305
Aug 13, 2016 13:47:39 GMT
|
Post by kibblesandbits on Jul 16, 2017 13:09:55 GMT
From the linked article: Taken together, these critiques suggest that when black women like Williams and Bey define their womanhood on their own terms, whether by taking racy images or floating across the Grammy stage like a reincarnated spirit, they are somehow breaching some unspoken contract that they should exist only on the terms set for them by others. To these women, Bey and Serena aren’t following the rules. And it comes as no surprise that white women are acting as the womanhood police./b] Yes, Williams and Bey face criticism when stepping onto a stage upon which they are not recognized for. As do many other artists. People in the public eye are continually under scrutiny for their actions on and off the stage/court/podium. Hell, even Hillary was excoriated for ridiculous things that had NOTHING to do with the campaign.
In response, writer Sinead Kissane suggested that Serena’s baring of her flawless body was hypocritical because “it shows success doesn’t change some women’s desire to be validated for how they look.” Calling Serena’s prior images “sassy,” Kissane echoes Schaefer by finding no value in this sort of bodily display. For Kissane, Serena “taking her clothes off for a magazine” undermines her performance on the tennis court. It is as if she can only be one or the other: athlete or sexy woman. Apparently there is no room in this white woman’s mind for the two to exist simultaneously./b] It is a common theme to portray women who choose to bare their bodies/lose weight/endure cosmetic surgery as hypocritical. Again, I don't see this as a race thing, more a "female" thing.
I'll give you this - Beyonce's pregnancy performance (and, further, the themes behind the Lemonade album) were rooted in historical structures and references that did not necessarily play to the great masses. She's asking people to think, in a world that doesn't. Don't know what to do about that - I continue my ways of teaching diversity, modeling acceptance, and showing evidence of research and thought prior to shooting my mouth off.
|
|
imsirius
Prolific Pea
Call it as I see it.
Posts: 7,661
Location: Floating in the black veil.
Jul 12, 2014 19:59:28 GMT
|
Post by imsirius on Jul 16, 2017 13:32:52 GMT
You're gas lighting - it's beyond frustrating. No one wants to argue - just want to understand what THE FUCK YOU WANT. You continue to obfuscate the topic and evade any direct answer. You won't get a straight answer. This is repeated behaviour..over and over and over.. She is not interested nor does she want discussion, she wants to be told she is a victim and we are all responsible whether we like it or not. She wants to be right. She cannot see any other point but her own. She wants us to admit all whites are bad and all are racist. Until we grovel at her feet, she won't be happy. It's the same shit every time. Don't waste your breath, you won't get anything but word salad and denials/reflections. Lather, rinse repeat..every.single.time.
|
|